Serapion (Letter 54 §1) had written
to Athanasius asking for three things,—a history of recent events
relating to himself, an exposé of the Arian heresy, and an
exact account of the death of Arius. The latter Athanasius furnishes in
the letter just referred to. For the two former, he refers Serapion to
a document he had written for the monks (ἅπερ
ἔγραψα τοῖς
μοναχοῖς), and which he
now sends to Serapion. He begs Serapion at the end of his letter not on
any account to part with the letters he has received, nor to copy them
(he gave, he adds, the same directions to the monks, cf. Letter
52. 3), but to send them back with such corrections and additions as he
might think desirable. He refers him to his letter to the monks for an
explanation of the circumstances which render this precaution
necessary. The monks (ib. 1) had apparently made the same
request as Serapion afterwards made. It has been conjectured that the
four ‘Orations’ against Arianism, or the first three, are
the treatise on the heresy addressed to the monks and subsequently sent
to Serapion. But the description of
that treatise ἔγραψα δί
ὀλίγων (Letter 52. 1) is
quite inapplicable to the longest treatise extant among the works of
Athanasius. Still less, even if the Arian History were a fragment (see
above), could we suppose that the accompanying treatise formed the
missing first part. We must therefore acquiesce in the conclusion that
the treatise in question has perished. Accordingly we cannot be sure
(although it is generally regarded as highly probable See
Eichhorn, p. 61; Bright. p. lxxiv.) that the historical portion is preserved to
us in the ‘Arian History.’ In any case the Letter to Monks
is quite unconnected with it in its subject matter, and ends with the
blessing, as the History does with the doxology, in the form of an
independent document.