The
date of the rise of Gnosticism cannot be fixed. Indeed, all the
requisite conditions existed from the beginning. It was the
“acute Verweltlichung” (as Harnack calls it) of
Christianity, the development of it in connection with the various
ethnic philosophies, and it began as soon as Christianity came in
contact with the Greek mind. At first it was not heretical, simply
because there were no standards by which to try it. There was only the
preaching of the Christians; the canon was not yet formed; episcopacy
was not yet established; both arose as safeguards against heresy. It
was in the time of Hadrian, perhaps, that these speculations began to
be regarded as heresies, because they contradicted certain fundamental
truths to which the Christians felt that they must cling, such as the
unity of God, his graciousness, his goodness, etc.; and therefore the
Christians dated Gnosticism from that time. Gnosticism was ostensibly
conquered, but victory was achieved only as the Church itself became in
a certain sense Gnostic. It followed the course of Gnosticism a century
later; that is, it wrote commentaries, systems of doctrine, &c.,
philosophizing about religious things (cf. Harnack’s
Dogmengeschichte, I. p. 162 sq.). It must be remembered in
reading the Fathers’ accounts of Gnosticism that they took minor
and unimportant details and magnified them, and treated them as the
essentials of the system or systems. In this way far greater variety
appears to have existed in Gnosticism than was the case. The essential
principles were largely the same throughout; the differences were
chiefly in regard to details. It is this conduct on the part of the
Fathers that gives us such a distorted and often ridiculous view of
Gnosticism.
The Carpocratians are the first
of whom Irenæus expressly says that they called themselves
Gnostics (adv. Hær. I. 25, 6), while Hippolytus first
speaks of the name as adopted by the Naasseni (V. 1). The Carpocratians
are mentioned by Hegesippus (quoted below in chap. 22). The system was
more exclusively Greek in its character than any other of the Gnostic
systems. The immorality of the sect was proverbial; Tertullian (de
Anima, c. 35) calls Carpocrates a magician and a fornicator. He
taught the superiority of man over the powers of the world, the moral
indifference of things in themselves, and hence, whether he himself was
immoral or not, his followers carried out his principles to the
extreme, and believed that the true Gnostic might and even must have
experience of everything, and therefore should practice all sorts of
immoralities.
Eusebius is probably
right in assigning Carpocrates to this period. The relation of his
system to those of Saturninus and Basilides seems to imply that he
followed them, but at no great interval. Other sources for a knowledge
of Carpocrates and his sect are Irenæus (I. 25 and II.
31–33), Clement of Alexandria (Strom. III. 2), Hippolytus
(Phil. VII. 20), Tertullian (de Anima, 23, 35),
Pseudo-Tertullian (adv. omnes Hær. 3), Epiphanius
(Hær. 27), and Philaster (c. 35). Of these only
Irenæus, Clement of Alexandria, and the earlier treatise of
Hippolytus (which lies at the base of Pseudo-Tertullian and Philaster)
are independent; and probably, back of Irenæus, lies Justin
Martyr’s lost Syntagma; though it is very likely that
Irenæus knew the sect personally, and made additions of his own.
Compare Harnack’s Quellenkritik des Gnosticismus, p. 41
sq.