And if it be so that these persons, in some of their conversation and behaviour, have
manifested a contentious, froward spirit, at the time of their withdrawing from your church;
I confess this gives greater ground of suspicion of the sincerity of their plea of conscience;
yet, as to this, I humbly conceive allowances must be made. It must be considered, that it is
possible that persons, in an affair of this nature, may, in the thing itself, be conscientious,
and yet, in the course of the management of it, may be guilty of very corrupt mixtures of
passion and every evil disposition; as indeed is commonly the case with men, in long con-
troversies of whatever nature, and even with conscientious men. And therefore it appears
to me, that if persons in such a case are not obstinate, in what is amiss in them in this respect,
and don’t attempt to justify their frowardness and unchristian speeches, they notwithstanding
may deserve credit, when they profess themselves conscientious in the affair in general.
Thus, dear Sir, I have freely communicated to you some of my thoughts, with regard to
some of the concerns of this difficult day, which prove a trouble to you; not however with
any aim at directing your conduct, but merely to comply with the request to which I have
alluded. I am fully sensible, that I am not the pastor of the second church of Hartford; and
I only desire you would impartially consider the reasons I have offered. Begging of Christ,
our common Lord, that he would direct you in your theory and practice, to that which will
be acceptable in his sight,
I remain, Rev. Sir,
Your friend and brother,
jonathan edwards.”
In May, 1743, Mr. Edwards went, as he often did, to Boston, to attend the convention
of the clergy, which is held the day after the General Election. He was on horseback, and
had his eldest daughter on a pillion behind him. At Brookfield, they fell in company with
the Rev. Mr. Clap, rector of Yale College, his wife and son-in-law, also on horseback, with
several others, all traveling in the same direction; and Mr. Edwards, joining the company,
rode side by side with Mr. Clap, during a considerable part of the journey. At the commence-
ment of Harvard college in the following year, 1744, Mr. Clap stated, before a large number
of gentlemen, both at Boston and Cambridge, that, while riding through Leicester, in May
of the year preceding, he was informed by Mr. Edwards, that Mr. Whitefield told him, “that
he had the design of turning out of their places the greater part of the ministers of New
England, and of supplying their pulpits with ministers from England, Scotland, and Ireland.”
This statement surprised those who heard it; yet, coming from such a source, it was believed,
and extensively circulated. Mr. Edwards heard of it with astonishment, and without hesitation
denied that he had said so. Mr. Clap, hearing of this denial, addressed a letter to Mr. Edwards,
dated Oct. 12, 1744, in which he stated anew the alleged conversation, in the same terms;
but before the latter received it, he had forwarded a letter to Mr. Clap, dated Oct. 18, 1744,
showing him his mistake, and calling on him to correct it. On Oct. 29th, he wrote a reply
153
Chapter XIII. First Interview with David Brainerd--Separations From Churches--Letter…