65. Moreover, if they say that the Son is by
will, they should say also that He came to be by understanding; for I
consider understanding and will to be the same. For what a man
counsels, about that also he has understanding; and what he has in
understanding, that also he counsels. Certainly the Saviour Himself has
made them correspond, as being cognate, when He says, ‘Counsel is
mine and security; mine is understanding, and mine strength Prov. viii.
14..’ For as strength and security are the
same (for they mean one attribute), so we may say that Understanding
and Counsel are the same, which is the Lord. But these irreligious men
are unwilling that the Son should be Word and Living Counsel; but they
fable that there is with God περὶ τὸν
θεόν. vid. de Decr.
22, n. 1; Or. i. 15. Also Orat. i. 27, where (n. 2 a.),
it is mistranslated. Euseb. Eccl. Theol. iii. p. 150. vid. de
Syn. 34, n. 7., as if a habit ἕξιν. vid. Or. ii.
38, n. 6; iv. 2, n. 7., coming and going συμβαινούσαν
καὶ
ἀποσυμβαινούσαν, vid. de Decr. 11, n. 7, and 22, n. 9, σύμβαμα, Euseb. Eccl. Theol. iii. p. 150. in the same, though a
technical sense. vid. also Serap. i. 26; Naz. Orat. 31,
15 fin.,
after the manner of men, understanding, counsel, wisdom; and they leave
nothing undone, and they put forward the ‘Thought’ and
‘Will’ of Valentinus, so that they may but separate the Son
from the Father, and may call Him a creature instead of the proper Word
of the Father. To them then must be said what was said to Simon Magus;
‘the irreligion of Valentinus perish with you Acts viii. 20.;’ and let every one rather trust to
Solomon, who says, that the Word is Wisdom and Understanding. For he
says, ‘The Lord by Wisdom founded the earth, by Understanding He
established the heavens.’ And as here by Understanding, so in the
Psalms, ‘By the Word of the Lord were the heavens made.’
And as by the Word the heavens, so ‘He hath done whatsoever
pleased Him.’ And as the Apostle writes to Thessalonians,
‘the will of God is in Christ Jesus Prov. iii. 19; Ps.
xxxiii. 6; cxxxv. 6, cxv. 3; 1 Thess. v. 18..’ The Son of God then, He is the
‘Word’ and the ‘Wisdom;’ He the
‘Understanding’ and the Living ‘Counsel;’ and
in Him is the ‘Good Pleasure of the Father;’ He is
‘Truth’ and ‘Light’ and ‘Power’ of
the Father. But if the Will of God is Wisdom and Understanding, and the
Son is Wisdom, he who says that the Son is ‘by will,’ says
virtually that Wisdom has come into being in wisdom, and the Son is
made in a son, and the Word created through the Word Read
‘a word,’ cf. p. 394, n. 6.; which is incompatible with God and is
opposed to His Scriptures. For the Apostle proclaims the Son to be the
own Radiance and Expression, not of the Father’s will De
Syn. 53, n. 9., but of His Essence οὐσία and ὑπόστασις are in these passages made synonymous; and so infr.
Orat. iv. 1, f. And in iv. 33 fin. to the Son is attributed
ἡ πατρικὴ
ὑπόστασις. Vid. also ad Afros. 4. quoted supr. Exc. A,
pp. 77, sqq. ῾Υπ. might have been
expected too in the discussion in the beginning of Orat. iii.
did Athan. distinguish between them. It is remarkable how seldom it
occurs at all in these Orations, except as contained in Heb. i. 3. Vid.
also p. 70, note 13. Yet the phrase τρεῖς
ὑποστάσεις
is certainly found in Illud Omn. fin. and in
Incarn. c. Arian. 10. (if genuine) and apparently in Expos.
Fid. 2. Vid. also Orat. iv. 25 init.
Itself, saying, ‘Who being the Radiance of His glory and the
Expression of His Subsistence Heb. i. 3..’ But if, as we have said before, the
Father’s Essence and Subsistence be not from will, neither, as is
very plain, is what is proper to the Father’s Subsistence from
will; for such as, and so as, that Blessed Subsistence, must also be
the proper Offspring from It. And accordingly the Father Himself said
not, ‘This is the Son originated at My will,’ nor
‘the Son whom I have by My favour,’ but simply ‘My
Son,’ and more than that, ‘in whom I am well
pleased;’ meaning by this, This is the Son by nature; and
‘in Him is lodged My will about what pleases Me.’