Furthermore, while you have truly and accurately
professed the right faith, we find that among those whom you have held
to be condemned by the most holy general synods you have condemned a
certain Eudoxius; whose name we have not found mentioned in the Latin
language either in synods or in the books of the bishops of blessed
memory, Epiphanius, Augustin, or Philaster, whom we know to have been
the chief disputants against heretics It is a sign of
Gregory’s scanty knowledge of the history of controversies that
so far he seems never to have heard of so noted an Arian leader as
Eudoxius, whose followers, under the name of Eudoxians, had been
specifically condemned in the 1st Canon of the first general Council of
Constantinople. But it appears from a subsequent letter (VII.
34), that there was no copy at Rome of the canons of that Council,
which had not in fact been accepted there, probably because of the 3rd
Canon, which assigned a primacy of honour after Rome to the See of
Constantinople as being new Rome. When he wrote this subsequent
letter, he had become aware that the Eudoxians had been so condemned,
but still had no idea who Eudoxius had been. The fact was that he
was not well versed in past ecclesiastical history and, being totally
ignorant of Greek, could only consult such Latin writings as were
within his reach; and in these he had failed to find Eudoxius
mentioned. He applied, however, to the patriarchs of Alexandria
and Antioch for further information on the subject (see VII. 34, and
VIII. 30), and was at length satisfied that Eudoxius had been a
veritable heretic, having been condemned by many Greek Fathers of
repute, and concluded that he was “manifestly slain, against whom
our heroes have cast so many darts” (VIII. 30).. Now if any one of the
catholic
Fathers
really condemns him, we undoubtedly follow their opinion. If,
however, in your synodical epistle you have wished to condemn by name
those also who, apart from the holy synods, are condemned in the
writings of the Fathers, your Fraternity has mentioned too few by many;
but if those whom the general synods reject, then too many by this
one. But in the midst of all these things it is to be remembered,
that in order that we may be free to profess the true faith and to
order whatever has to be done in peace and concord, we ought to pray
incessantly for the life of our most serene lords and of their
offspring, that Almighty God would subdue
barbarous nations under their feet, and grant them long and happy
lives, to the end that through a Christian empire the faith which is in
Christ may reign.