The Church’s servility toward the orthodox rulers
is fairly expressed, and yet with comparative moderation, by Sozomen.
He is an apologist for Constantine, and reflects, as do all the
historians, and especially Evagrius in his criticism of Zosimus, the
adulations and subterfuges of Eusebius. The religious fluctuation of
that emperor is masked; his crimes are suppressed; he is made to appear
orthodox, even when at his worst Eusebian stage. No wonder that
Philostorgius charged the Homoöusians with worshiping Constantine
as a god in the ceremonies connected with his image! Constantius, a
vacillating, cruel, incompetent, is also apologized for, but to the
damage of his intelligence. Julian, for his years in some respects, one
of the most promising and earnest rulers of ancient times, is loaded
with obloquy, his highest motives and ideals ridiculed, his victories
belittled, his death savagely exulted in. Jovian’s and
Valentinian’s toleration are not understood, but their personal
orthodoxy is in so far praised. Valens is looked at through the eyes of
his two fierce Cappadocian assailants. His excellences are entirely
ignored; the most inconsequent views are imputed to him while
attempting to glorify Basil; in the sad story of the emperor’s
dying son, that bishop appears as a brute in his treatment of the
agonized father. The stories of heroism attributed to the orthodox are
only examples of insufferable insolence; one must marvel at the
patience of Valens, if there be any truth in them. Gratian, that
beau-ideal of Western orthodoxy, was really a nose of wax in the hands
of Ambrose; he was esteemed more moderately by the East, and that
rather for having called Theodosius to a share in the throne, than for
any quality in himself; but his utter moral collapse, after the
magnificent promise of his youth, is wholly veiled from sight.
Theodosius the Great is glorified, not for his superior statecraft and
generalship, but for his efforts to
suppress paganism and heresy. The charges against his private life such
as Eunapius and Zosimus suggest, are not hinted at. He is a man of
prayer and visions, a relic-worshiper, and a persecutor of pagans and
Arians. Great as he certainly was, his distinguishing and conspicuous
qualities are passed by. His pitiful children, Arcadius and Honorius,
the sorriest quidnuncs of those stormy times, are heroes of piety.
Pulcheria, excellent as she was, was not worthy of the excessive
flattery poured out upon her; while Anthemius, Troïlus,
Valerianus, and other noble figures of the day are passed by. The
younger Theodosius, with his good training and generally fair endeavor,
is delineated in the dedication as the consummate man of all time,
while he is a very third-rate soul at best. The eulogies by Socrates
(vii. 22 and 42) are just as fulsome. This was the grave sin of the
State Church; the Arian State Church did the same for Constantius and
Valens; more and more as history reveals the truth concerning many of
those idols, does the revulsion increase against a union of two
functions which could so degrade both.