From this canon we see that the Nicene fathers entertained no doubt that the faithful
in the holy Communion truly received “the body of Christ.” Secondly, that that was “offered”
in the church, which is the word by which sacrifice is designated in the New Testament, and
therefore it was at that time a fixed tradition that there was a sacrifice in which the body of
Christ was offered. Thirdly that not to all, nor even to deacons, but only to bishops and
presbyters was given the power of offering. And lastly, that there was recognized a fixed
hierarchy in the Church, made up of bishops and presbyters and deacons in subordination
to these.
Of course even at that early date there was nothing new in this doctrine of the Eucharist.
St. Ignatius more than a century and a half before, wrote as follows: “But mark ye those
who hold strange doctrine touching the grace of Jesus Christ which came to us, how that
they are contrary to the mind of God. They have no care for love, none for the widow, none
for the orphan, none for the afflicted, none for the prisoner, none for the hungry or thirsty.
They abstain from eucharist (thanksgiving) and prayer, because they allow not that the
Eucharist is the flesh of our Saviour Jesus Christ, which flesh suffered for our sins, and which
the Father of his goodness raised up.”100
In one point the learned scholiast just quoted has most seriously understated his case.
He says that the wording of the canon shews “that the Nicene fathers entertained no doubt
that the faithful in the holy Communion truly received ‘the body of Christ.’” Now this
statement is of course true because it is included in what the canon says, but the doctrinal
statement which is necessarily contained in the canon is that “the body of Christ is given”
by the minister to the faithful. This doctrine is believed by all Catholics and by Lutherans,
but is denied by all other Protestants; those Calvinists who kept most nearly to the ordinary
Catholic phraseology only admitting that “the sacrament of the Body of Christ” was given
in the supper by the minister, while “the body of Christ,” they taught, was present only in
the soul of the worthy communicant (and in no way connected with the form of bread,
which was but the divinely appointed sign and assurance of the heavenly gift), and therefore
could not be “given” by the priest.101
This canon is found in the Corpus Juris Canonici, Decretum. Pars I. Dist. XCIII., c. xiv.
100 Ignat. Ad Smyr. § vi. Lightfoot’s translation. Apost. Fath. Vol. II. Sec. I. p. 569.
101 Cf. Art. xxviij. of the “Articles of Religion” of the Church of England, which declares that “The Body of
Christ is given, taken, and eaten in the Supper,” etc.
103
Canon XVIII.