With regard to the name “Apostolic Canons” there need be no more hesitation in applying
it to these canons than in calling Ignatius an “Apostolic Father,” the adjective necessarily
meaning nothing more than that the canons set forth the disciplinary principles which were
given to the early Church by the Apostles, just as we speak of the “Apostles’ Creed.”
While this is true there can be no question that in the East the Apostolic Canons were
very generally looked upon as a genuine work prepared by the Holy Apostles. I proceed
now to quote Bishop Hefele, but I have already (Cf. Council in Trullo) expressed my own
opinion that there is not contained in the Quinisext decree any absolute definition of what
is technically known as the “authenticity” of the Canons of the Apostles.
(Hefele. Hist. of the Councils, Vol. I., p. 451 et seqq.).
The Synod in Trullo being, as is well known, regarded as ecumenical by the Greek
Church, the authenticity of the eighty-five canons was decided in the East for all future
time. It was otherwise in the West. At the same period that Dionysius Exiguus translated
the collection question for Bishop Stephen, Pope Gelasius promulgated his celebrated decree
de libris non recipiendis. Drey mentions it, but in a way which requires correction. Following
in this the usual opinion, he says that the Synod at Rome in which Gelasius published this
decree was held in 494; but we shall see hereafter that this synod was held in 496. Also Drey
considers himself obliged to adopt another erroneous opinion, according to which Gelasius
declared in the same decree the Apostolic Canons to be apocryphal. This opinion is to be
maintained only so long as the usual text of this decree is consulted, since the original text
592
as it is given in the ancient manuscripts does not contain the passage which mentions the
Apostolic Canons.562 This passage was certainly added subsequently, with many others,
probably by Pope Hormisdas (514–543) when he made a new edition of the decree of
Gelasius. As Dionysius Exiguus published his collection in all probability subsequently to
the publication of the decree of Gelasius, properly so called, in 496, we can understand why
this decree did not mention the Apostolical Canons. Dionysius did not go to Rome while
Gelasius was living, and did not know him personally, as he himself says plainly in the
Præfatio of his collection of the papal decrees. It is hence also plain how it was that in an-
other collection of canons subsequently made by Dionysius, of which the preface still remains
to us, he does not insert the Apostolic Canons, but has simply this remark: Quos non admisit
uniniversalitas, ego quoque in hoc opere prætermisi. Dionysius Exiguus in fact compiled
this new collection at a time when Pope Hormisdas had already explicitly declared the
Apostolic Canons to be apocryphal.
Notwithstanding this, these canons, and particularly the fifty mentioned by Dionysius,
did not entirely fall into discredit in the West; but rather they came to be received, because
the first collection of Dionysius was considered of great authority. They also passed into
562 Cf. Ballerini, Opp. S. Leon. M., Vol. III. p. 158; Mansi, Conc., Tom. VIII., 170.
1084
The Apostolical Canons. Introduction.