This is the
first of the ten letters of Gregory to the notorious Brunechild.
A daughter of Athanagild, king of the Visigoths in Spain, she had
married Sigebert I., one of the grandsons of Clovis, who reigned over
that part of the dominion of the Franks which was called Austrasia,
having on her marriage renounced Arianism for Catholicity.
Sigebert having been assassinated a.d. 575,
his son Childebert II., then only five years old, was proclaimed King
of Austrasia; whereupon Brunechild herself became the virtual ruler of
the kingdom. So she was again after the death of Childebert,
a.d. 596, as guardian of Theodebert II., his
illegitimate son, who succeeded him at the age of ten years. See
Pedigree of Kings of Gaul, p. xxx.
The praises lavished on her by
Gregory in this and his other epistles to her appear strangely
inconsistent with the character given her by the historians of the
time. It has been suggested in explanation; 1. That the
historians may have maligned her, attributing to her crimes that were
not her own; 2. That, whatever her misdemeanours, Gregory might not
have heard of them, knowing of her only as a faithful Catholic, and a
supporter of the Church; 3. That no such misdemeanours had become
notorious when Gregory wrote to her in such flattering terms, the worst
doings imputed to her having in fact been after his death. She
survived him some nine years. Still, when we consider
Gregory’s diplomatic turn, together with his habitual deference
to potentates apparent elsewhere, we cannot think it unlikely that he
might ignore purposely in his addresses to them even their known moral
delinquencies, so long as he could enlist their support of religion and
orthodoxy, or their loyalty to the see of Rome. And, after all,
Brunechild may not have been much worse than some other Frank
royalties, all of whom he would be naturally and properly desirous of
conciliating, and making the best of them he could. A less
defensible instance of apparently politic flattery is found in his
letters to the Emperor Phocas and his Empress Leontia after the
deposition and murder of Mauricius. See XIII. 31, 38, 39, and
Proleg., p. xxvii.