SECT. I.
General observations upon his way of arguing, and answering arguments; with some in-
stances of the first method excepted against.
Mr. W. endeavours to support his own opinion, and to confute the book he pretends
to answer, by the following methods.
1. By frequently misrepresenting what I say, and then disputing or exclaiming against
what he wrongfully charges as mine.
2. By misrepresenting what others say in their writings, whose opinions he pretends to
espouse.
3. By seeming to oppose and confute arguments, and yet only saying things which have
no reference at all to them, but relate entirely to other matters, that are altogether foreign to
the argument in hand.
4. By advancing new and extraordinary notions; which are both manifestly contrary to
truth, and also contrary to the common apprehensions of the christian church in all ages.
5. By making use of peremptory and confident assertions, instead of arguments.
6. By using great exclamation, in the room of arguing; as though he would amuse and
alarm his readers, and excite terror in them, instead of rational conviction.
7. By wholly overlooking arguments, and not answering at all; pretending, that there is
no argument, nothing to answer; when the case is manifestly far otherwise.
8. By frequently turning off an argument with this reflection, that it is begging the ques-
tion; when there is not the least show or pretext for it.
9. By very frequently begging the question himself, or doing that which is equivalent.
10. By often alleging and insisting on things in which he is inconsistent with himself.
510
As to the first of these methods used by Mr. W. i.e. his misrepresenting what I say, and
then disputing or exclaiming against what he injuriously charges as mine, many instances
have been already observed: I now would take notice of some other instances.
In p. 15. c. He charges me with “affirming vehemently, in a number of repetitions, that
the doctrine taught is, that no manner of pretence to any visible holiness is made or designed
to be made.” These he cites as my words, marking them with notes of quotation. Whereas
I never said or thought any such thing, but the contrary. I knew, that those whose doctrine
I opposed, declared that visible holiness was necessary: and take particular notice of it, (p.
8.) where I say, “It is granted on all hands, that none ought to be admitted, as members of
the visible church of Christ, but visible saints:” and argue on this supposition for fifteen
pages together, in that same part of my book where Mr. W. charges me with asserting the
contrary. What I say is, that people are taught, that they come into the church without any
pretence to sanctifying grace, (p. 15. d.) I do not say, without a pretence to visible holiness.
Thus Mr. W. alters my words, to make them speak something not only diverse but contrary
SECTION I. Method of disputing.
1968
SECTION I. Method of disputing.