Who that hears this will not set down as mad
those who suspect Dionysius of holding with Arius? For lo! in these
words, by arguments based on truth, he tramples upon his entire heresy.
For by the simile of the Brightness he destroys the statements that
‘He was not before He was begotten,’ and ‘There was a
time when He was not,’ as also by saying that His Father was
never without issue. But their allegation that He was made ‘of
nothing’ he destroys by saying that the Word was like a river
from a well, and a shoot from a stock, and a child from a parent, and
Light from Light, and Life from Life. And their barring off and
separating the Word from God, he overthrows by saying that the Triad is
without division and without diminution gathered together into the
Monad. While their statement that the Son has no part in the
Father’s essence, he unequivocally tramples down by saying that
the Son is of one essence with the Father. Wherein one must wonder at
the impudence of the irreligious persons. How can they, when Dionysius
whom they claim as their partisan says that the Son is of one essence It
should be noted that Dionysius while assenting to this word, does not
use it as his own., themselves go about buzzing like gnats with
the complaint that the Synod was wrong in writing ‘of one
essence?’ For if Dionysius is a friend of theirs, let them not
deny what their partisan holds. But if they think that the expression
was wrongly used, how can they reiterate that Dionysius, who used it,
held with them? the more so as he does not appear to have written these
things merely by the way, but having previously written other letters Possibly to other bishops who had questioned his teaching (Routh,
Rell. iii. p. 380)., he convicts of falsehood those who had
charged him with not saying that the Son was of one Essence with the
Father, while he refutes those who thought that he said that the Word
was originated, shewing that he did not hold what they supposed, but
even if he had used the expressions, he had done so merely in order to
shew that it was the Son, not the Father, who had put on the
originated, formed, created body; for which reason the Son also is said
to have been originated, created, and formed.