Calendarium Rom. in Petavius Uranal. p. 113. The date varies by a
year or two, according to way of reckoning, but 274 is the date usually
given. (Cf. Burckhardt, Manso, Keim, De Broglie, Wordsworth, etc.)
Eutropius and Hieronymus say he died in his sixty-sixth year,
Theophanes says he was sixty-five years old, and Socrates and Sozomen
say substantially the same, while Victor, Epit. has sixty-three,
and Victor, Cæs. sixty-two. Eusebius says he lived twice
the length of his reign, i.e. 63 +.
Manso chose 274, because
it agreed best with the representations of the two Victors as over
against the “later church historians.” But the two Victors
say, one that he lived sixty-two years and reigned thirty-two, and the
other that he lived sixty-three and reigned thirty; while Eutropius,
secretary to Constantine, gives length of reign correctly, and so
establishes a slight presumption in favor of his other statement.
Moreover, it is supported by Hieronymus, whose testimony is not of the
highest quality, to be sure, and is quite likely taken from Eutropius,
and Theophanes, who puts the same fact in another form, and who
certainly chose that figure for a reason. The statement of Eusebius is
a very elastic generalization, and is the only support of Victor,
Epit. Socrates, who, according to Wordsworth, says he was in his
sixty-fifth year, uses the idiom “mounting upon”
(ἐπιβ€ς)
sixty-five years, which at the least must mean nearly sixty-five years
old, and unless there is some well-established usage to the contrary,
seems to mean having lived already sixty-five years. In the
interpretation of Sozomen (also given in translation “in
his sixty-fifth year”) he was “about” sixty-five
years old. Now if he died in May, his following birthday would not have
been as “about,” and he must have been a little over
sixty-five. This would make a strong consensus against Victor, against
whom Eutropius alone would have a presumption of accuracy. On the whole
it may be said that in the evidence, so far as cited by Manso,
Wordsworth, Clinton, and the run of historians, there is no critical
justification for the choice of the later date and the shorter
life.