§2.
Sources.
Remembering the class of
students for which the series is chiefly intended, effort has been made
to refer to translations of sources where they are at hand, and to
refer to the best accessible English authorities on them. But the plan
has been to refer to the source itself in the edition actually used,
and for literature on them to choose the best for ready reference. Both
editions and authorities on sources are therefore selections, usually
from many, of such as seem most directly useful. The intention has been
to guide to all frequently mentioned sources, whether they were of
great value or not, since a useless one costs often quite as much
trouble to hunt up and find useless, as a good one to use. It is hardly
to be hoped that all the sources often referred to have been gathered,
but the following list represents pretty much all that are worth
mentioning, and some which are not.
1.
Inscriptions, coins,
medals, &c.
In some sense these are the most
reliable of sources, in spite of counterfeits. A large number will be
found collected in Clinton. For farther critical study, compare the
collections, great and small; for which, with the matter of
inscriptions in general, see Hicks, E. L., and Hübner, E., in the
Encyclopædia Britannica
, 13 (1881) 121–133; and
Babington, in Smith and Cheetham, 1 (1880) 841–862. Monographs on
those relating to Constantine will be found under the names, Cavedoni,
Cigola, Eltz, Freherus, Garucci, Harduin, Penon, Revellot, Valois,
Westphalen, Werveke, in the
Literature
of this
volume.
2.
Laws
.
These, with their dates, their
official nature, their fullness and variety, are primary, and are the
only sources recognized by some. They are embodied in the Theodosian
and Justinian Codes, and collected from these are edited in Migne,
Patrol
.
Latina
, Vol. 8. See under
Writings
of
Constantine, above.
3.
Other Writings by
Constantine
.
See under
Writings
,
above, p. 436. With this might perhaps be included also writings
to
Constantine, like that of Anulinus in Augustinus,
Ep
.
88.
4.
General Literary
Sources
.
Taking in general chronological
order, without attempting the impossibility of fixing the exact
chronological place, the first group of contemporary sources is that of
the Panegyrists (for collected editions, see Engelmann).
It was a serious
mistake, now recognized, to pass them by as worthless. Like all
authentic documents, they have a minimum residuum of undoubted
material, which is larger or smaller according to the critical acumen
of the investigator. In the case of these, however inflated or
eulogistic they may be, the circumstances under which they were spoken
give a considerable value.
(1)
Incerti auctoris
Panegyricus Maximiano et Constantino dictus
(
Paneg
. 307). In
Migne,
Patrol. Lat
. 8 (1844), 609–620. Pronounced at
celebration of marriage of Constantine and Fausta,
a.d.
307. Besides having the great value of being
contemporary evidence, the author shows a certain ingenuity in
enlarging on the virtues of the young Constantine, who had few deeds to
show, and on the deeds of Maximian, who had few virtues, and has
therefore a certain discernible modicum of truth.
Compare the
Monitum
in
Migne, Ramsay’s article on
Drepanius
, in Smith, Dict.
1073–4, and references under Eumenius.
(2)
Eumenius
(310–311).
(a) Panegyric (Panegyricus
Constantino Augusto
). In Migne,
Patrol. Lat
. 8 (1884),
619–640. (
b
)
Thanksgiving Oration (Gratiarum Actio
Constantino Augusto
). In Migne,
Patrol. Lat
. 8 (1844),
641–654. Eumenius flourished during the reigns of Constantius,
with whom he was in high favor, and Constantine. He was head of the
school at Autun. The
Panegyric
was delivered at Treves, in 310.
The authorship of Eumenius has been unwarrantably questioned, on the
ground that the flattery and exaggeration of the work are not
consistent with his taste and sense; but it would seem that both his
exaggeration and his taste have been themselves exaggerated. His praise
is hardly more “outrageous” than panegyrics were wont to
be,—or are, for that matter; and so far from being
“worthless,” there is a peculiar deal of interesting,
unquestionable, and primary historical evidence. Still, his taste and
veracity are not much above that of modern eulogists of living or dead
emperors and politicians. The
Gratiarum Actio
is the official
oration of thanks to Constantine in behalf of the citizens of Autun, on
account of favors shown them. It was pronounced at Treves in
311.
Compare Ramsay, in Smith,
Dict
. 2 (1859), 92; the Proœmium, in ed. Migne,
619–622; also for editions, Ramsay, article
Drepanius
, in
Smith,
Dict
. 1. 1073–4; and for literature, Chevalier. For
general account of the Panegyrists, see this article on
Drepanius.
(3)
Incerti Panegyricus
Constantino Augusto
(Paneg. 313). In Migne,
Patrol. Lat
. 8
(1844), 653– . This is usually ascribed to Nazarius, on the
ground of style. It was spoken at Treves in 313, and relates mainly to
the war with Maxentius. Various details relating to this are of such
nature and form as to suggest again that the author is the same as that
of the 321 Paneg.,—Nazarius.
Compare Ramsay, in Smith,
Dict
. 2 (1859), 1145; the Proœmium in ed. Migne, &c.,
and literature as under
Eumenius
,
above.
(4)
Nazarius
. (321)
Panegyric
(
Panegyricus
Constantino Augusto dictus
). In ed. Migne,
Patrol. Lat
. 8
(1844), 581–608. Nazarius is mentioned by Jerome as a
distinguished rhetorician. This oration was delivered at Rome in 321.
Constantine was not present. It is superlatively eulogistic, but like
the related panegyrics contains many historical facts of greatest
value.
Compare Ramsay, in Smith,
Dict
. 2 (1859), 1145, the
Monitum
, in Migne, and
references under
Eumenius
.
In the midst of the period which
these cover comes one of the two great Christian sources, and he is
followed by a considerable row of great and small Christians during the
century.
(5)
Lactantius
(ab. 313–314).
On the Deaths of the
Persecutors (De M. P.
). Ed. Fritsche (Lips. 1842), 248–286;
ed. Migne,
Patrol. Lat
. 7 (Par. 1844), 157–276; tr. in
T. & T. Clark Library
, 22 (Edinb. 1871), 164–211, and
in Ante-Nicene Fathers (Buffalo and N.Y.), 300–326 [Lord
Hailes’ translation]. There are many editions in collected works,
and about a dozen separate, and many translations,—in all a
hundred or more editions and translations. There has been much
controversy regarding the author of this work, but there is little
doubt that it was Lactantius. Ebert (
Gesch. chr. Lat. Lit
. 1.
83) claims to have demonstrated the fact, and most of the later writers
agree. The work was composed after the edict of Constantine and
Licinius, and before the break between the two, i.e. 313–314. It
was written thus in the midst of things, and has the peculiar
historical value of a contemporary document, unprejudiced by later
events. It is a sort of psalm of triumph, colored by the passionate
rejoicing of one persecuted over the Divine vengeance which has come
upon the persecutors. “In the use of the work the historian must
employ great critical discernment” (Ebert, in Herzog, 8 [1881],
365). But granted all his prejudice, the facts he witnesses are of
first value.
Compare Ffoulkes, in Smith and
Wace, 3 (1882), 613–617; Teuffel,
Hist. Rom. Lit
. 2
(1873), 334; Ebert, in Herzog,
Encyk
. 8 (1881), 364–366,
and
Gesch. chr. Lat. Lit
. 1 (1874), 83; and for farther
literature,
Bibliog, Synops
. in
Ante-Nicene Fathers Suppl
.
(1887), 77–81.
(6)
Eusebius
(ab. 260–340). I.
Ecclesiastical
History
. 2.
Constantine
. 3.
Chronicle
.
For 1 and 3 compare Prolegomena
of Dr. McGiffert at the beginning of this volume, and for 2,
Special
Prolegomena
, p. 466.
(7)
Optatian
(fl. ab. 326).
Panegyric
, in Migne,
Patrol. Lat
. 19 (1846), 395–432; Letter to Constantine,
do. 391–392. Optatian, Porfirius, or Porphyrius, as he is
variously called, is dubiously Christian, composed this
poem, or series of
poems, while in exile, on the occasion of the Vicennalia of
Constantine. It dates, therefore, from 325 or 326. It is a most
extraordinary aggregation of acrostics, pattern poems, and every
possible device of useless, mechanical variety of form, of little
value, excepting as a sort of dime-museum exhibition of patience and
ingenuity. It consists mainly in calling Constantine flattering names,
but contains here and there an historical suggestion. It was
accompanied by a letter to Constantine, and drew one from him, and a
pardon as well (Hieronymus,
Chron.
).
Compare Wilson, article
Porfirius,
in Smith & W. 4 (1887), 440; article
Porphyrius,
in Smith,
Dict.
3 (1859), 502; and for
editions and literature, Engelmann.
(8)
Athanasius
(296–373).
Apology against the
Arians,
and various works, ed. Bened. (1698), 2 v. in 3, fo; ed.
Migne,
Patrol. Gr.
25–28 (1857), 4 v.; translated in part
in Newman,
Library of the Fathers,
and in Schaff-Wace,
Nicene
and Post-Nicene Fathers
(announced). The works of Athanasius
contain various letters of Constantine (see under
Works
) and
much of primary historical value for the latter part of
Constantine’s reign. So far as it goes, the matter is almost
equal to official documents as source.
Compare Bright, in Smith &
W. 1 (1877), 179–203; Schaff,
Hist. of Church,
23 (1884),
884–893; and for extensive literature and editions, Chevalier and
Graesse.
(9)
Cyril of
Jerusalem
(ab. 315–386).
Catechetical Lectures.
In
Migne,
Patrol Gr.
33 (1857), especially 830. English
translations in Newman,
Library of Fathers,
2 (1838), one ref.
p. 178.
Letter to Constantine II. concerning the sign of the cross
seen at Jerusalem,
c 3. In Migne,
Patrol. Gr.
33 (1857),
1165–1176, ref. on 1167–1168. Two or three references only
to excavation of the cross and building of churches, &c., at
Jerusalem. They take significance only in the fact that Cyril is so
near the time (the letter was 351 [?], or not many years later), and
delivered his lectures in the very church which Constantine had built
(sect. 14, 22).
Compare Schaff,
Hist. of
Church,
3 (1884) 923–925; Venables, in Smith & W. 1
(1887), 760–763; and literature in Chevalier Schaff, &c.;
also editions in Graesse, Hoffmann, &c.
(10)
Ambrosius
of Milan
(ab. 340–397).
Oration on the Death of
Theodosius.
In Migne,
Patrol. Lat.
16 (1866), portion
relating to Constantine especially, 1462–1465. Relates chiefly to
the Finding of the Cross.
Compare Davies, in Smith &
W. 1 (1877), 91–99; also Chevalier, Engelmann, Schoenemann,
&c.
(11)
Hieronymus
(
Jerome
)
(331–420).
Chronicle.
In Migne,
Patrol. Lat.
27
(1866). Part relating to Constantine, 493 (497)–500. A
translation and continuation of the
Chronicle
of Eusebius, who
ends with the death of Licinius. An indispensable but aggravating
authority.
Compare Salmon,
Eusebius,
Chronicle of,
in Smith & W. 2 (1880), 348–355.
(12)
Augustinus
(354–430).
Ep.
43, ed. Migne, 33
(1865), 159– , §§4, 5, 20, &c. He gives account of
the various Donatist hearings, and speaks of having read aloud from
various original documents, including the petition to Constantine, the
proconsular acts, the proceedings of the court at Rome, and the letters
of Constantine. He speaks of the hearing at Milan.
Ep.
88, ed.
Migne,
Patrol. Lat.
33 (1865), 302–309. This has the text
of letter of Anulinus to Constantine and Constantine to Probianus.
Eps.
76. 2; 93. 13–14, 16 (which contains account of
decree of Constantine that property of obstinate Donatists should be
confiscated); 105. 9, 10 (not translated); 141. 8–10 (not
translated), in ed. Migne, and tr. English ed. Schaff, contain various
matter on the Donatist acts of Constantine.
Ad Donatistas post
collationem,
c. 33, §56; ed. Migne, 43 (1861), 687 (important
for
dates
given).
Contra litt. Petil.
Bk. II. ch. 92,
§205; ed. Migne, 45 (1861), 326. Tr. in Schaff,
Nicene and
Post-Nicene Fathers,
4 (1887), 580–581.
Contr. Epist.
Parmen.
Bk. I. chs. 5–6, §10–11; ed. Migne, 43
(1841), 40–41. Augustine as a source is of primary value, because
of the otherwise unknown sources which he uses and quotes.
Compare Schaff,
Hist. of
Church,
3 (1884), 988–1028; Maclear, in Smith & W.
Dict.
1 (1877), 216–228. For literature see Schaff,
Chevalier, Engelmann, and for particular literature of the Donatist
portions, Hartranft, in Schaff,
Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers,
4 (1887), 369–372; and for editions, see Schoenemann, Graesse,
Brunet, Engelmann, Schaff, Hartranft, &c.
The equally numerous series of
non-Christian writers is headed, in value at least, though not in time,
by Constantine’s secretary.
(13)
Eutropius
(4th cent.).
Abridgment of Roman History,
Bk. 10. Multitudes of editions and translations; the ones used are:
(Paris, 1539), 63–68; transl. by Watson, (Bohn, 1853),
527–535. Eutropius was secretary to Constantine, and afterwards
the intimate of Julian. His testimony, though brief, is of peculiar
weight from his position for knowing and from a certain flavor of
fairness. It was early remarked (Nicephorus Gregoras) that his praise
of Constantine had peculiar force, coming from a heathen and friend of
Julian. His dispraise, on the other hand, is conditioned by the fact
that he applies it only to the period after Constantine began
peculiarly to favor the Christians. He seems to be a cool, level-headed
man of the world, unsympathetic with Constantine’s religion and,
writing
from this standpoint,
presents a just, candid, reliable
account of him.
Compare Ramsay, in Smith,
Dict.
2 (1859), 126–127; Watson,
Notice,
in his
translations; also for multitudinous editions and translations, and
relatively scanty though considerable literature, Chevalier, Engelmann,
Graesse.
(14)
Scriptores Historiæ
Augustæ
(? 2–324). Ed. Jordan and Eyssenhardt, Berol.
1864, 2 v. Contains a few dedications to and mentions of Constantine,
for which see Index.
Compare Teuffel,
Hist. of
Rom. Lit.
tr. Wagner, 2 (Lond. 1873), 320–324.
(15)
Victor,
Sextus Aurelius
(fl. 350–400).
Cæsars
. In ed.
Schottius, Antv. Plantin, 1579, p. 97–167. Section on Constantine
chiefly, 157–162.
Epitome,
Antv. 1579. Section on
Constantine, p. 49–52. These works, by different authors, have
been associated since the time of the above edition with the name of
Victor. The former is by him, the latter probably by a slightly later
Victor. They use the same sources with Zosimus, but supplement him
(Wordsworth). Both are interesting and important, and in Manso’s
judgment, final where they agree.
Compare Ramsay, in Smith,
Dict.
3 (1859), 1256–1257; Thomas, article
Aurelius,
in
Biog. Dict.
(1886), 228; Manso,
Leben
Const.
p. 215; and scanty references in Chevalier. For editions and
farther literature, see Engelmann.
(16)
Praxagoras Atheniensis
(4th cent). In Photius,
Cod.
62; Ed. Bekker, p. 20; ed. Müller,
Fragm.
4 (1868),
2–3. Lived in reign of Constantine (Müller, p. 2). Although
a heathen (Photius,
Cod,
62), he lauds Constantine above all his
predecessors. He wrote various works in the Ionic dialect, among others
a “history of the deeds of Constantine the Great, in two
books,” composed at the age of twenty-two. The fragments or
resumé
are preserved by Photius, as above. Though brief
(three columns), it is a concise mass of testimony.
Compare Smith,
Dict.
3.
517; also for literature, Chevalier; and for editions, the various
editions of Photius in Graesse, Hofmann, Engelmann, &c.
(17)
Calendarium Romanum Constantini Magni
(350). In Petavius,
Uranologium
(1630), 112–119. Written after 337, and in or
before 355, probably in 355. It is authority for the birthday of
Constantine, Constantius, &c.
Compare Greswell,
Origines
Kalendariæ Italicæ
, 4 (Oxf. 1854),
388–392.
(18)
Julian
the Apostate
(331–363).
Cæsars. Orations on
Constantius and Constantinus, et pass.
Ed. Paris, 1630, p.
12–96, 422; Vol. 2, 1–54,
passim.
Compare also ed.
Hertlein, Lips. 1875–76, 2 v. 8vo. Editions and translations are
very numerous. (Compare arts. of Wordsworth and Graves; also Engelmann,
Graesse, &c. The orations which are panegyrical were delivered
(Wordsworth) 355 and 358, and the
Cæsars
dates from shortly
after his accession (in 361). The latter is a satire which has found
literary favor, the substantial purpose of which is thought to be a
suggestion that he (Julian) is much superior to all the great emperors;
but which if one were to venture a guess at its real motive is quite as
much a systematic effort to minimize by ridicule the lauded
Constantine. The laudatory words of Julian himself in his orations are
quite overshadowed by the bitter sarcasms of the Cæsars. As a
matter of estimate of the value of this source, there is to be
remembered the bitterness of Julian’s hostility to Christianity.
What to Eusebius was a virtue would to Julian be a vice. In view of his
prejudice, everything which he concedes is of primary weight, while his
ill-natured gossip carries a presumption of slanderousness.
Compare Schaff,
Hist. of
Church,
2. 40–59; Wordsworth, in Smith & W. 3.
484–525; Graves, in Smith,
Dict.
644–655. Compare
for endless literature, Wordsworth, Chevalier, Engelmann, 1 (1880),
476–477.
(19)
Libanius,
(314 or 316–391 +).
Orations.
Ed.
Morellus, Par. 1606–1627. Contain a few allusions of more or less
interest and historical value, for which, see ed. Morellus, Index
volume 2, fol. Qqqv
b
.
Compare Schmitz, in Smith,
Dict.
2 (1859), 774–776; and for editions and literature,
Chevalier, Engelmann, &c.
(21)
Ammianus
Marcellinus
(d. ab. 395).
Histories.
There are many
editions, for which compare Engelmann, Graesse, and Wordsworth. Among
editions are ed. Valesius (1636) and ed. Eyssenhardt, Berol. 1871. The
work was a continuation of Tacitus, but the first thirteen books
(including Constantine’s period) are best. He says (Bk. 15, ed.
Valesius, 1636, p. 56–57) that Constantine investigated the
Manichæans and like sects through Musonius, and gives account of
the bringing of his obelisk to Rome, perhaps by Constantine (Bk. 17, p.
92–93; compare Parker,
Twelve Egypt. Obelisks in Rome,
Oxf. 1879, p. 1), and makes other mention, for which see Index to ed.
Eyssenhardt, p. 566.
Compare Wordsworth, in Smith
& W. 1 (1879, 99–101, and for literature, Chevalier (scanty)
and Engelmann, 2 (1882), 43–45 (Rich).
(22)
Eunapius
(Anti-Christian) (ab. 347–414).
Lives of
the Philosophers and Sophists; Ædesius.
Ed. Boissonade (Amst.
1822), 19–46
passim.
Eunapius was born at Sardis about
347, and died after 414
a.d.
(cf. Müller,
Fragm.
87). He was a teacher of rhetoric, and besides this work
wrote a continuation of the history of Dexippus, extending from
270–404
a.d.
Fragments of this are
preserved, but none relating to Constantine. Photius (
Cod.
77)
says that he calumniated the Christians, especially Constantine. With
the fragments in Müller,
Fragm.
4 (1868), 11–56, is
included also (14–15) a fragment from the
Vita Ædes
.,
relating to Sopater. The death of Sopater and the relation of Ablavius
to it is given more fully in the
Vita Ædes
. with various
suggestive allusions. Much of his history is supposed to be
incorporated in Zosimus, and this gives importance to his name, weight
to Zosimus, and light on the hostile position of Zosimus towards
Constantine.
Cf. Photius,
Cod.
77; Müller,
Fragm.
4 (1868),
7–9; Mozley, in Smith & W. 2 (1880), 285–286; Schmitz,
in Smith,
Dict.
2 (1859), 93; also for further literature and
editions, Chevalier and Engelmann.
(23)
Bemarchius
(4th cent.) was of Cæsarea in Cappadocia;
wrote the
Acts of Constantine
in ten books (Suidas, s.v.
Βήμαρχιος
; cf. Zonaras, p. 386). No portion is preserved. Wrote
under Constantius, on whom he is said (Libanius,
Orat.
ed.
Reiske, p. 24) to have delivered a panegyric.
Cf. Müller,
Fragm.
4
(1868), 3; Smith,
Dict.
1 (1859), 482, &c.
An early but as yet valueless
group is that of Syriac and Armenian sources on the (apocryphal) treaty
of Constantine with Tiridates.
(24)
Zenobius
of Klag
(fl. ab. 324).
History of Daron.
French
translation from Armenian in Langlois,
Coll. Hist. Arm.
1
(1867), 353–355. Like the works of the other Armenian historians,
the text of this writer has suffered more or less from corruption. He
has two mentions (p. 344 and 351) of Constantine, the latter being an
account of the treaty with Tiridates.
Compare introduction of
Langlois, and literature in Chevalier.
(25)
Agathangelus
(ab. 330).
History of the Reign of
Tiridates and of the Preaching of St. Gregory the Illuminator,
c.
125–127, §163–169; in
Acta SS. Boll.
Sept.
VIII. 320– ; also with French translation from Armenian in
Langlois
Coll. d. hist. de l’Arm.
p. 97– . The work
extends for 226–330
a.d.
The author was
secretary to Tiridates, but the work as we have it is a redaction made,
however, not long after, as it was used by Moses of Khorene. This was
in turn later (seventh century?) retouched by some Greek hagiographer.
This Greek form is extant in
mss.
at Florence
and Paris (cf. editions above), and there is reason to suppose that the
extant Armenian is a version from this Greek form. But with its
additions of arrantly apocryphal matter, it is hard to tell what is
what, and so all considerable mention of the relation of Constantine
and Tiridates has been left out of the account of Constantine’s
life. Yet we must hesitate to put it all down under the mythical; for
Tiridates certainly had intercourse with the Romans, and the original
form of this life was certainly by a competent hand, and the matter
relating to Constantine is in part soberly historical
enough.
For farther information, compare
Davidson on Gregorius Illuminator, in Smith & W.,
Dict.
2.
737–739; Introduction, Langlois, p. 99–103.
(26)
Faustus
of Byzantium
(320–392).
Historical Library.
French
translation from the Armenian in Langlois,
Coll. d. hist. Arm.
1. 201–310. There are mentions of Constantine and Tiridates in
Bk. 3, chaps. 10 and 21. The work is open to some suspicions of having
been tampered with, but Langlois inclines to give it a fairly good
character. If genuine, the mention of the treaty with Tiridates would
nearly establish it as historical fact.
Compare Beauvois
Nouv. biog.
gén.
17 (1856), 203, and Introduction of Langlois; also,
literature in Chevalier.
The writers of the following
centuries are for the most part Christian, uncertain or religiously
unknown, excepting the very pronounced non-Christian who heads the
list.
(27)
Zosimus
(fl. ab. 400–450).
History.
Ed.
Bekker (Bonn, 1837), 8vo. Section on Constantine occupying Bk. 2.
8– , p. 72–106. The date of this writer has been put as
early as the fourth century and as late as the end of the fifth. It
will be safe to divide extremes. He is a heathen who, on the period of
Constantine, draws from an anti-Christian and anti-Constantinian
source, and who regards the introduction of Christianity as a chief
cause of the decline of the Roman Empire (cf. various passages cited by
Milligan). He is prejudiced against Christianity with the bitter
prejudice of one who finds himself in a steadily narrowing minority,
and he is occasionally credulous. But he wrote in a clear, interesting
style, without intentional falsifications, and was quite as moderate as
the Christian writer (Evagrius 3. 41) who calls Zosimus himself a
“fiend of hell.” His extended account is therefore of great
value among the sources, and especially as it is probably drawn in
large measure from the earlier lost work of Eunapius.
Compare Milligan, in Smith &
W., 4 (1887), 1225–1227: Mason, in Smith,
Dict.
3 (1859),
1334–1335; also, for literature, Chevalier and Engelmann, and for
editions, Engelmann.
Anonymus Valesianus
(fifth century). Ed. Valesius (Paris, 1636), p.
471–476. This fragment, first published by Valesius in the above
editions of Ammianus, is of the highest value for the life of
Constantine. It is evidently drawn from various sources, many of which
are now lost. The compiler or writer shows a judiciousness and
soberness which commends his statements as peculiarly
trustworthy.
Compare the exhaustive
examination by Ohnesorge,
Der Anonymus Valesii de Constantino.
Kiel, 1885. 8vo.
(27)
Stephen
of Byzantium
(ab. 400).
Greek Cities.
Venet. Aldus, 1502,
fol. H. iii. s.v.
Ναϊσσὸς
. The work is a dictionary of geography, and the fact in these few
lines is of first value.
Compare Smith, in Smith,
Dict.
3 (1859), 904–906. Chevalier, Hoffmann,
etc.
(28)
Sozomen
(b. ab. 400).
Ecclesiastical History.
Ed.
Hussey, English translation, London, Bohn, 1855; newly edited by
Hartranft in Schaff,
Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers,
2 (1890)
[in press]. This history covers the period 323–423 (not 439). He
draws largely from Eusebius. He has been described rightly
(Dowling,
Study of Eccl. Hist.
p. 31) as
relatively inaccurate, rhetorical and credulous. But he works from
sources, though mainly from exact ones. For farther discussion, compare
Hartranft in volume 2 of this series.
Compare also Milligan, in Smith
& W. 4 (1887), 722–723, and literature in
Chevalier.
(29)
Socrates
(b. ab. 408).
Ecclesiastical History
. Ed.
Hussey, reprinted with Introduction by Bright, Oxf. 1878. English
translation London, Bohn, newly edited by Zenos in volume 2 of this
series [in press]. This history covers the period 306–439. It is
written with general good judgment, but for Constantine adds little to
Eusebius of which it professes to be a continuation.
For farther description and
discussion, compare Zenos, Milligan, in Smith & W. 4 (1887),
709–711, and literature in Chevalier.
(30)
Theodoret
(b. ab. 393?–457?).
Ecclesiastical
History
. In Migne,
Patrol. Gr
. 82 (1859), 879–1280.
English translation, London, Bohn, 1854. The birth of Theodoret has
been placed at various dates, 386, 387, 393, &c., and the exact
time of his death (453–458) is equally uncertain. This work
reaches from 324 to 429, and is generally regarded as learned and
impartial. It gives much concerning Constantine’s relations to
the Arian controversy and incorporates many documents, which appear to
be taken mainly from Eusebius’
Life of Constantine
. A
chief value is, it would seem, for the text of Eusebius. But his very
use of documents shows care and gives value.
Compare Venables, in Smith &
W. 4 (1887), 904–919; Newman,
Hist. Sketches
, 2 (1876),
303–362; Schaff,
Hist. of Church
, 3 (1884), 881–882;
and literature in Chevalier; also for editions, Graesse and
Hoffmann.
(31)
Orosius,
Paulus
(ab. 417).
Histories
, Bk. 7, chaps. 26–28.
Ed. Migne
Patrol. Lat
. 31 (1846), 635–1174; section
relating to Constantine occupies 1128–1137. For many editions and
mss.
compare Schoenemann,
Bibl. Patr.
Lat
. 2 (1794), 481–507, and Engelmann, 2 (1882), 441– .
It is said (Manso) that Orosius adds nothing to existing material. This
is only in part true. At all events, his value as corroboratory
evidence is considerable, brief as the work is.
Compare Phillott, in Smith &
W, 4 (1887), 157–158; Ebert,
Gesch. d. chr. Lat. Lit
. 1
(1874), 323–330, and literature in Chevalier and
Engelmann.
(32)
Prosper
Aquitanus
(403–463+).
Chronicle
. Ed. Migne,
Patrol. Lat
. 51 (1861), 535–606 (8). Portion relating to
Constantine, 574–576. The
Chronicle
extends to 444 or 455.
To 326 he depends mainly on Eusebius’
Chronicle
, and for
the rest of our period on the continuation of Hieronymus.
Compare Phillott, in Smith &
W. 3 (1882), 492–497; Teuffel,
Hist. of Rom. Lit
. 2 (Lond.
1873), 482–484; and for literature, editions, &c., Chevalier,
Engelmann, &c.
(33)
Idatius
(468+).
List of Consuls
(Fasti Idatiani).
In Migne,
Patrol. Lat
. 51 (1861), 891–914; portion
relating to Constantine, 907–908. Idatius lived until after 469.
This work, which is not generally acknowledged to be his, although
quoted under his name, ends in 468. It contains brief statements of
some events under the most significant years.
Compare Ramsay, in Smith,
Dict
. 2 (1859), and literature under “Idace de
Lamego,” in Chevalier.
(34)
Gelasius
of Cyzicus
(ab. 450– ).
History of the Council of
Nicæa
. In Labbe,
Concilia
, 2 (1671), 103–286.
There is also an abstract in Photius,
Bibl. Cod
. 88, ed. Migne,
Patrol. Gr
. 103 (1860), 293–296. Venables is probably just
when he says: “His work is little more than a compilation from
the ecclesiastical histories of Eusebius, Socrates, Sozomen, and
Theodoret, to which he has added little but what is very doubtful or
manifestly untrue.” There is a little on Constantine not in those
sources, but to try to fix on any of it as authoritative quite baffles
one. Still, it is not wholly clear that he did not use sources, as well
as his own imagination, in adding to the other sources. It may be said
to be “of doubtful value,” as source. It is not easy to see
what Venables means in saying that the third hook, as we have it, gives
only three letters of Constantine. This is true; but the second book,
“as we have it,” gives several more.
Compare Venables, in Smith &
W. 2 (1880), 621–623.
(35)
Jacobus
of Sarug
(452–521).
Homily on the Baptism of
Constantine
. Ed. Frothingham, Roma, 1882. For further information
consult the extended study of Frothingham.
(25)
Philostorgius
(b. ab. 468). English translation by Walford
(Lond. Bohn, 1855), 425–528. The original work covered the period
between 300 and 425. The fragments preserved contain several
interesting facts, or fictions, relating to Constantine, some not found
elsewhere. Photius and all the orthodox have always called him
untrustworthy or worse, and a very unorthodox critic (Gibbon) finds him
passionate, prejudiced, and ignorant; but it seems to be agreed that he
used some sources not availed of by others.
Compare Milligan, in Smith &
W. 4 (1587), 390; Dowling,
Study of Eccl. Hist
. p. 26–27;
and literature in Chevalier.
(26)
Hesychius
Milesius
(ab. 500?– ).
Origins of Constantinople
.
In Müller,
Fragm
. 4 (1868), 146–155; also in ed.
Orelli (Lips. 1820), 59–73. Hesychius, surnamed Illustris, of
Miletus lived in the early part of the sixth century. This work
contains several allusions to the founding of the city of Constantine.
It seems to have been taken almost word for word in parts by
Codinus.
Compare Venables, in Smith &
W. 3 (1882), 12–13; Means, in Smith,
Dict
. 2 (1859),
447–448; Müller,
Fragm
. 4 (1868), 143–145; also
literature in Chevalier, and editions and literature in
Engelmann.
(27)
Cassiodorus
(ab. 468–561+).
Tripartite History.
In Opera, ed. Garetius, 1 (Rotom. 1679,
fol.), b 1–b 372. On Constantine, especially p. 207–243.
(Same ed. in Migne,
Patrol. Lat.
69 [1865], 879–1214.)
Cassiodorus was born about 468 and lived to be more than ninety-three
years old. This work is an epitome of Socrates, Sozomen, and Theodoret,
and has no additional value as source. A work on the Goths has been
preserved to us only in an epitome by Jordanes. See
Jordanes.
Compare Young, in Smith & W.
1 (1877), 416–418, or (better for this work) Ramsay, in Smith, 1
(1859), 623–625; and for literature and editions, Chevalier,
Engelmann, Graesse, etc.
(28)
Lydus,
Joannes (Laurentius)
(490–550+).
De Mensibus; De
Magistratibus; De Ostentis, passim.
Ed. Bekker, in
Corp. Hist.
Byz.
(1837). Other editions of the various works may be found
noticed in Graesse,
Trésor,
4 (1863), 122; Brunet,
Manuel,
3 (1862), 880; Engelmann,
Bibl. scr. class.
1
(1880), 478–479; Hoffmann,
Lex
. He was born at
Philadelphia in 490, and lived some time after 550. He was a heathen,
but respectful toward Christianity (Photius, Cod. 180). He mentions
Constantine ten or a dozen times; e.g. his foundation of Constantinople
(
De O.
21. 5), Constantine’s learning and military skill
(
De mag.
3. 53), and quotes (
De magistr.
3. 33, ed.
Bonn., p. 226), Constantine’s own writings.
Compare Photius, Cod. 180;
Means, in Smith,
Dict.
2 (1859), 600; Hase, Pref. and in ed.
Bekker; Joubert, in
Nouv. biog. gén.
(Hoefer), 32 (1860),
388–391; and for farther literature, Chevalier and the article of
Joubert, and Engelmann,
Bibl. scr. class.
1 (1880),
479.
(29)
Jordanes
(or Jornandes)
( –551?).
History of the Goths, (De
Getarum origine et rebus gestis).
In Cassiodorus, Opera, ed.
Garetius, 1 (Rotom. 1679), 397–425; same ed. in Migne,
Patrol.
Lat.
69 (1865), 1251–1296. This work on the Goths is said by
its author to be an epitome of the work of Cassiodorus. It says (p.
406–407) that Constantine employed Goths in his campaign against
Licinius, and also in the building of Constantinople. It was composed
in 551 or 552 (cf. Wattenbach,
Deutschland’s Geschichtsq.
1 [1877], 66).
Compare Hodgkin, in
Encycl.
Brit.
13 (1881), 747–749; Acland, in Smith & W. 3 (1882),
431–438 (exhaustive); and abundant literature in Chevalier,
Engelmann, Wattenbach, &c.; also editions in Engelmann,
“Potthast.
Bibl. hist. med. æv.
1862, p. 102,”
&c.
(30)
Anonymous, qui Dionis Cassii historias continuavit
(sixth
century?). 14. Licinius (18 lines); 15. Constantinus (9 lines). In
Müller,
Fragm.
4 (1868), 199; of especially Introd. in
Müller, p. 191–192. These were first published by Ang. Mai
in
Script. Vet. Nov. Call.
2, 135–, 527–, and are
found also in various editions of Dion Cassius; e.g. ed. Sturz. 9 (Spz.
1843). Mai strongly inclines to suspect that Johannes Antiochenus is
the author, but this Müller (p. 191) argues to be impossible. They
are sometimes referred to as Excerpta Vaticana. Petrus Patricius and
various others have been suggested as authors, but all that is affirmed
with any assurance is that the author was a Christian. This is on the
ground of Diocletianus, 1 (p. 198). The fragments are very brief, but
contain several little facts and turns not found elsewhere.
(31)
Evagrius
(536?–594+).
Ecclesiastical History,
3. 40–41. English translation (1709), 472–474. A violent
invective against and disproval of the charges of Zosimus against
Constantine and adds nothing to historical facts.
Compare Milligan, in Smith &
W. 2 (1880), 423–424.
(32)
Procopius
Cæsariensis
(fl. 547–565).
Histories.
Ed.
Dindorf, Bonn, 1833–1838, 3 v. Two or three slight mentions, of
which the nearest to any account is the division of the empire by
Constantine, and the founding of Constantinople (
De bel. Vand,
1. 1). He flourished from about 547 to 565. Whether he was Christian or
heathen is uncertain. He is characterized by peculiar truthfulness (cf.
his
De ædif.
1; Praf. ed. Bonn, v. 3, 170–, and
Milligan).
Compare Milligan, in Smith &
W. 4 (1887), 487–488; Plate, in Smith,
Dict.
3,
538–540; also for literature, Chevalier and Engelmann, 1. 655;
and for editions, Milligan, Plate, and the various
bibliographies.
(33)
Petrus
Patricius
(fl. 550–562).
Fragments.
In Müller,
Fragm.
4 (1868), 189. Gives account of an embassy of Licinius to
Constantine.
Compare Means, in Smith,
Dict.
3 (1859), 226–227; also Chevalier and
Hoffmann.
(34)
Gregory
of Tours
(ab. 573–594).
History of the Franks,
1.
34. Ed. Ruinart (Paris, 1699), 27, &c. (?)
History of the Seven
Sleepers,
do. 1272–1273, &c.
Liber miraculorum,
do. 725–729. The edition of Ruinart is reprinted in Migne,
Patrol. Lat.
vol. 71 (1867). In the first of these he quotes as
authorities, Eusebius and Junius; the latter are full of legendary
matter.
Compare Buchanan, in Smith &
W. 2 (1880), 771–776; also for editions and literature,
Engelmann, Chevalier, and Graesse.
(35)
Chronicon
Paschale
(ab. 630
a.d.
) Ed. Dindorf,
Bonn, 1832, 2 v.; section relating to Constantine occupies vol. 1, p.
516–533. Ed. Migne,
Patrol. Gr.
92 (Paris, 1865). The work
is a chronicle of the world from the creation until 630. It has been
thought, but on insufficient grounds (cf. Salmon), that the first part
ended with
a.d.
354 and was written about that
time. It is really a homogeneous work and written probably not long
after 630
a.d.
(Salmon). It is frequently
quoted, unfortunately, as Alexandrian Chronicle (e.g. M’Clintock
and Strong Cycl.). The chief value is the chronological, but the author
has used good sources and presumably some not now extant. It has
something the value of a primary source of second rate.
Compare Salmon, In Smith & W. 1. (1877), 509–513;
Clinton,
Fasti. Rom.
2 (1850), 169; Ideler,
Handb. d.
Chron.
2 (1826), 350–351, 462–463; and for literature
and editions, Salmon.
(36)
Anonymous Acts of
Metrophanes and Alexander
(seventh century?), “in which is
contained also a life of the emperor Constantine the Great.” In
Photius, Cod. 256; ed. Migne,
Patrol. Gr.
104 (1860),
105–120. A more complete recession of this anonymous piece was
edited by Combefis, who regards it as the work of a contemporary,
written therefore in the middle of the fourth century (cf. his
Hist.
Mon.
p. 573, teste Fabricius). The authentic details can be traced
word for word, according to Tillemont, in other historians, while
impossible statements show it to be not the work of a contemporary. It
seems to fall under the class of works where “What is true is not
new, and what is new is not true,” but it can hardly be regarded
as sufficiently determined whether or no it is worthless.
Compare Tillemont,
Mém.
7 (1732), 657; Fabricius,
Bibl. Gr.
9 (1737),
124 and 498;
Acta. SS
. Nov. 1.
(37)
Johannes
Antiochenus
(fl. 610–650).
Chronological History.
Fragments in Müller, 4 (1868), 535 (8)–622;
Fragm.
168–169, on Constantius and Galerius, and 170–171a, on
Constantine, p. 602–603. This writer is to be distinguished from
Johannes Malalas, also known as Johannes Antiochenus. He flourished
somewhere between 610–650 (Müller, p. 536). The sections
relating to Constantine are in the main exactly correspondent to
Eutropius. It has been conjectured (Müller, p. 1538) that
Eutropius and Johannes copied from a common Greek source; but the
curious error in the section on Constantine (p. 603), by which
“commodæ” is converted into a proper name, and becomes
the name of the sister whose son Constantine put to death, shows it to
have been translated from the Latin. The work of Johannes has, however,
some interesting suggestions and additions; e.g. its paraphrase of the
word “dubius” in the characterization of
Constantine’s conduct towards his friends.
Compare Müller, p.
535–538; Means, in Smith,
Dict.
2 (1859), 587; also
article of Stokes, and other literature under Malalas.
(38)
Malalas
(=
John
of Antioch) (ab.
700).
Chronography,
Bk. 13, 1–11. Ed. Dindorf (Bonnæ,
1831); in
Corp. scr. hist. Byz.
(section on Constantine, p.
316–324); also in Migne,
Patrol. Gr.
97 (Par. 1865),
1–70. Earlier editions are, Oxf. 1691, 8
o
; Venice,
1733, fol. [reprint of 1691, “quite useless”]. Lived about
700 (Müller,
Fragm.
4 [1868], 536), or about 650
(Chevalier, 1205). He has been placed as late as ninth century (Hody),
and as early as 601 (Cave). Noting is known of his personal history. He
is to be distinguished from the John of Antioch in Müller’s
Fragm.
who is earlier than Malalas. He is very credulous and
inaccurate and the section on Constantine is no exception to the
rule.
Compare Prolegomena of Hody and
Dindorf; Stokes, in Smith & W. 3 (1882), 787–788, &c.;
and farther literature in Chevalier,
Rép
. 1205; Hoefer,
Nouv. biog. gén.
32 (1060), 1007, and the article of
Stokes.
(39)
Pseudo-Isidore
(eighth cent.?).
Decretals.
In
Migne,
Patrol. Lat.
130 (1853), 245–252. The famous
“Donation of Constantion,” which appears here for the first
time. See under
The Mythical Constantine.
Compare Schaff,
Hist. of
Church,
4 (1885), 268–733; and for literature, Chevalier
under Isidore Mercator; also the literature of the
Donation.
(40)
Theophanes
(758–818).
Chronography.
Ed.
Classen, Bonn. 1839–41, 2 v. Section on Constantine occupying
vol. 1, p. 10–51; also in Migne,
Patrol. Gr.
108 (186).
This work “is justly regarded as one of the most important in the
whole series of Byzantine historians” (Dowling, p. 69).
Theophanes was friend of Georgius Syncellus; and at his request
(Prœm. p. 5) took up the latter work at the point where he left
off (Diocletian), extending it to 811. He is an authority of judgment
and weight for matters relating to his own times, and on quite a
different level of historical character from Cedrenus and Zonaras.
Although of very much less value for Constantine, he shows even here a
certain historical judgment and discrimination. His book is an
intelligent work from various sources, one of which is Eusebius. He
says that he has diligently examined many works, and reports nothing on
his own authority, but on the authority of ancient historiographers and
“logographers” (Prœm. p. 5).
Compare Dowling
Introd.
(Lond. 1838), 69–70; Smith, in Smith,
Dict.
3.
1082–1083; Gass, in Herzog,
Real Enc.
15 (1885),
536–537;
Acta sanctorum Boll.
March 12; and for
(extensive) literature, Chevalier.
(41)
Anastasius Bibliothecarius
(d. 879).
Lives of the Roman
Pontiffs.
In Migne,
Patrol. Lat.
127–128 (1852). 34.
S. Silvester, vol. 127, 1511–1527. Small use.
Compare Schaff,
Hist. of the
Church,
4 (1885), 774–776; and for literature and editions,
Chevalier and Graesse.
(42)
Photius
(ninth cent.).
Bibliotheca.
In Migne,
Patrol. Gr.
vols. 103–104 (1860). Contains excerpts from
and comments on Praxagoras, Eunapius, Gelasius, Anon. Metroph., and
Eusebius, which see.
Compare Schaff,
Hist. of
Church,
4 (1885), 636–642; Means, in Smith,
Dict.
3
(1859), 347–355.
(43)
Constantinus Porphyrogenitus
(c. VII.) (fl.
911–959).
De thematibus.
Ed. Bekker (Bonn. 1840),
1–64, in
Corp. scr. hist. Byz.;
and in ed. Migne,
Patrol. Gr.
113 (1864), 63–140. Gives (2. 8, ed. Bonn. p.
57–58) account of division of the empire among his sons by
Constantine. He also mentions in his
De cer. aul. Byz.
(ed.
Reiske, Bonn. 1829; ed. Migne,
Patrol. Gr.
112); e.g. the
“cross of Constantine” several times mentioned, and gives a
few facts of archæological interest. Constantinus VII was emperor
911–959.
Compare Plate, in Smith,
Dict
. 1. 349–351; Ceillier,
12 (1862), 811–813; and for farther literature, Chevalier and
Engelmann, 1 (1880), 249; also for editions, Plate, who has admirable
survey.
(44)
Leo
Diaconus
(tenth century).
Histories
, 5. 9 and 8. 8. In
ed. Hase (Bonn. 1828), p. 91 and 138. Mentions the foundation of a
city, the vision of the cross, the Scythian wars, and burial in the
Church of the Apostles at Constantinople, and characterizes him as
“among emperors the one renowned in story” (8. 8). For
other editions, compare Brunet, Graesse, Hoffmann, and Engelmann. He
lived from about 950 to at least 993. He was used by Scylitzes (cf.
Cedrenus) and perhaps Zonaras. “Style vicious,” and
“knowledge…of ancient history is slight”
(Means).
Compare Means, in Smith,
Dict.
2 (1859), 743–744; M’Clintock and Strong,
Encycl
. 5 (1875), 351; Hase, Præf.; and for literature,
Chevalier.
It is by some stretching of the
term that many of those dating before the year 1000 are admitted as
sources. Some contribute hardly a single fact not in other sources.
This is still more true of the period following, but this period is
especially rich in sources of historical fictions—and these must
be considered. So the Byzantine historians to the invention of printing
are given, and some Western writings, which contain relevant
matter.
(45)
Zonaras,
Johannes
(1042–1130?).
Chronicle
. Ed. Migne,
Patrol. Gr
. 134–135 (Par. 1864). The section relating to
Constantine occupies Vol. I. 1097–1118, Bk. 13, chs. 1–4;
cf. also end of Bk. 12. The ed. Pinder, Bonn. 1841–1844, 2 v., is
unfinished, containing only twelve books. It has since been edited by
Dindorf, Lips. 1868–1875, 6 v. Bk. 13 is in Vol. 3 (1870). This
work consists of eighteen books extending from the beginning of the
world until 1118. Zonaras draws, for Christian period, from Eusebius,
Philostorgius, &c., with some discernment, and so deserves a
tolerably high place among the Byzantine historians (Zöckler). He
incorporates a choice variety of fables, but gives more or less facts
which seem to be facts. He actually adds almost nothing to the sources
of Constantine, though there are certain facts over which one lingers a
little before relegating to the great class of “interesting, if
true.”
Compare Smith,
Dict
. 3.
1331; (Zöckler), in Herzog,
Real Enc
. 17 (1886),
555–556; and for (rich) literature, Zöckler, Chevalier, and
Engelmann, 1 (1880), 798.
(46)
Cedrenus,
Georgius
(ab. 1057).
Compendium of History
. Ed. Bekker,
Bonn. 1838–1839, 2 v., the section relating to Constantine
occupying Vol. I, p. 472–520
et pass
. Also in Migne,
Patrol. Gr
. 121–122 (Par. 1864). Nothing is known of his
personal history. The work is a chronicle from the beginning of the
world until 1057
a.d.
He mentions as his chief
sources Georgius Syncellus, “until the time of Maximianus and
Maximinus,” and from this point Theophanes, Siculus, Psellus, and
others (cf. p. 4; cf. also Glycas.
Chron.,
ed. Bonn. p. 457),
and claims to have collected facts not in these sources. He mentions
the work of Joannes Thracesius, or Curopalates, who is probably
Scylitzes, whose work corresponds so exactly with that of Cedrenus in
parts as to suggest the one or the other a better copier than compiler.
The statement of Ceillier is that Cedrenus copied the work of Scylitzes
for the period 811–1057, and that Scylitzes afterwards continued
his work to 1081; i.e. there was a double edition of the work of
Scylitzes, and Cedrenus wrote between. But Means (p. 760) thinks
otherwise, and gives good reasons, making one edition and placing
Cedrenus’ work later, i.e. after 1081. The “additional
facts” are few, the compilation is uncritical and credulous; but
the work is recognized as a source to be consulted, though with
greatest critical care.
Compare Plate, in Smith,
Dict
. 1. 658; Ceillier, 13 (1863), 560; Means,
Scylitzes
,
in Smith,
Dict
. 3. 759–762; and for literature, Chevalier,
under the words
Cedrene
and
Scylitzes
.
(47)
Pseudo-Leo
.
Chronography
, under
Constantius
Chlorus
and
Constantinus Magnus
. Ed. Bekker (Bonn. 1842), p.
83–90. In
Corp. scr. hist. Byz
. from Cramer,
Anecd. gr.
bibl. reg. Par
. 2 (1839), 243–379. It is published as the
first part of the
Chronography
of Leo Grammaticus, because
assigned to him by the catalogues of the
ms.
at Paris. It is thought by Cramer, however, not to be by him, but to be
“compiled from various writers,—Cedrenus, Joannes
Antiochenus,
Chronicon Paschali
, and perhaps others which are
lost” (cf. Cramer,
Anecd. gr.
2. 243–379, quoted by
Bekker, Præf. iii.–iv.). In this section the author quotes
Socrates and Eusebius, but uses other and some unusual sources. While
one hesitates to lay much weight on an author of such unknown age and
personality, and which contains obvious errors, yet it carries the
conviction of a certain moderate weight. Many passages are identical,
almost word for word, with Cedrenus. In one of these passages the
author refers to Socrates as his authority, while there is no such
mention in Cedrenus. They may have taken from the same source. At all
events, this work appears on its face much more like sober history than
do Cedrenus and Zonaras. Its absolute value as source is very
slight.
Compare Preface of
Bekker.
(48)
Attaliata, Michael
(ab. 1072).
History
. Ed. De
Presle and Bekker, Bonn. 1853. 8°. He mentions (p. 217, also p.
222) half a dozen things relating to Constantine; that he was reckoned
among the apostles, the sign of the cross, &c., but nothing of
value, unless (p. 222) the transposition of a colony from Iberia to
Assyria (?).
Compare Præf. of De Presle,
also Graves, in Smith,
Dict
. 1. 409, who, however, does not
mention this work; and for literature, Chevalier and De Presle, p.
7–8.
(49)
Anna Comnena.
Alexias
. Ed.
Schopen-Reifferscheid, Bonn. 1839–1878. Mentions among two or
three other deeds, a statue which this “father and lord of the
city” had made over for him (12. 4), and that he has been counted
among the apostles (14. 8).
Compare Plate, in Smith,
Dict
. 1. 179; Klippel, in Herzog, 1 (1877), 427–429,
&c.
(50)
Glycas
,
Mich
(after 1118).
Chronicle
(or
Annals
). Ed. Bekker, Bonn. 1836; the
section relating to Constantine occupies p. 460–468, ed. Migne,
158 (Par. 1866), 1–958. This work of Glycas extends from the
beginning of the world to
a.d.
1118. Though
“justly placed among the better Byzantine historians”
(Plate), for the period of Constantine he is one of the worst. His
critical judgment seems to incline to the selection of the most
unhistoric. He gives at end of preceding section a description of the
work of Scylitzes (cf. Cedrenus), and quotes in it a work of Alexander
on the Invention of the Cross.
Compare Plate, in Smith,
Dict
. 2. 277; Joubert. in
Nouv. biog. gén
. (Hoefer), 20
(1857), 845–846; and for literature, Chevalier; also for
editions, Hoffmann.
(51)
Nicetas
Choniatas
(Acominatus) (1150–1216+).
History
. Ed.
Bekker, in
Corp. scr. hist. Byz
. Bonn. 1835, 8°; ed. Migne,
Patrol. Gr
. 139 (1865), 282–1088 (=Mai,
Bibl. nov.
patr.
6. ?).
Thesaurus
, in Migne,
Patrol. Gr
.
139–140 (1865), 1087–1443, 1–282 (=Mai,
Spicil.
Rom.
v. 4). Born about 1150, and lived until 1216 at least. Gives
in his
History
two or three things which relate to “the
first and mightiest among Christian emperors” (
De Is. Aug
.
3. 7, ed. Bonn. p. 583); e.g. the tale of the nails from the cross (do.
p. 584), and the despoiling of his tomb (
De Al. Is. Aug.
1. 7,
p. 632); also a few in the
Thesauri
, e.g. his conciliation to
Arianism through his sister and her friend, the Arian presbyter (6. 3
and 6), and various matters relating to the Arian controversy (mainly
in Bk. 5), where he uses the familiar sources,—Eusebius,
Socrates, Sozomen, Theodoret, Philostorgius, &c, but also some
other less familiar ones.
Compare Worman, in
M’Clintock and Strong,
Cyclop
. 7 (1877), 54–55;
Plate, in Smith,
Dict
. 2. 1182–1183; Ullmann, in
Stud.
u. Krit
. (1833), 674–700; Gass, in Herzog, 10 (1882),
540–541, and abridged in Schaff-Herz. 2. 1652. Compare for
literature, the above and Chevalier; and for editions, Worman, Plate,
Brunet, Graesse, Hoffmann, &c.
(52)
Gregoras,
Nicephoras
(1295–1359).
Byzantine History
, Bks.
1–37. Ed. Shopen (v. 1–2) and Bekker (v. 3), Bonn. 1829,
1830, and 1855. In
Corp. scr. hist. Byz.
; ed. Migne,
Patrol.
Lat
. 148–149 (1865). Mentions incidentally half a dozen facts
relating to foundation of Constantinople (10.1; 14. 3, &c.), his
destruction of idolatry (19. 1), treatment of the Jews (26. 15), and
enlargement of empire (26. 37). He was born 1295, and died after 1359.
Was more learned but less judicious than Cantacuzenus
(Plate).
Compare Plate, in Smith,
Dict
. 2. 304–306; Joubert, in
Nouv. biog. gén
. 21 (1857),
889–891; also for literature, Chevalier, and for editions, Plate
and Joubert.
(53)
Ephræmius
(fourteenth century).
Cæsars
(?). Constantinus. Ed. Bekker, Bonn. 1840, 8°; section on
Constantine occupies p. 21–25; ed. Migne, 143 (Par. 1865),
1–380. It was first edited by Mai,
Scr. vet. nov. coll
. 3
(1828), 1–225 (Dowl.). This metrical chronicle introduces one or
two fables, but is in the main at least semi-historical, but its
additional facts give no impression of having special sources,—in
brief, it is scarcely a source, rather literature.
Compare Smith,
Dict.
2.
28; Bonneau, in
Nouv. biog. gén
. (Hoefer) 16 (1856), 127;
Mai,
Præf
. in ed. Bekker, also ed. Migne. Compare for
literature, Chevalier.
(54)
Cantacuzenus, Joannes. Angelus Comnenus Palæologus
(d. 1375+).
Histories
. Ed. Schopen, Bonn. 1828–1832, 3 v.;
also in Migne,
Patrol. Gr
. 153–154 (Dowl. 1866). Speaks of
Constantine as a model of clemency (4. 2; ed. Bonn. v. 3, p. 18) worthy
to be compared with the apostles (3. 92), and as led by the spirit of
God like David (4. 48; ed. Bonn. v. 3, p. 351), and mentions the time
(in May) when his memory is celebrated (4. 4; 3. 92), but has hardly a
half-dozen mentions and fewer facts of interest or value. He reigned
1342–1355, abdicated, and lived until after 1375.
Compare Plate, in Smith,
Dict
. 579–581; and for farther literature, Chevalier and
Engelmann, also for editions.
(55)
Nicephorus Callistus
(d. ab. 1450).
Ecclesiastical
History
, 7. 17–18, 55. In Migne,
Patrol. Gr.
145–147. Bk. 7 is in 145, and Bk. 8 in 146. This late history,
not so bad as some in style, but full of legendary matter, was compiled
from the standard existing historians, and perhaps some others. The
portions on Constantine are taken almost wholly from Eusebius,
Socrates, Sozomen, and other existing historians.
Compare Schaff,
Church
Hist
. 3 (1884), 883–884; Plate, in Smith,
Dict
. 2
(1859), 1180–1181; Dowling,
Introd
.(1838),
91–93.
(56)
Monody on the Younger
Constantine
(ab. 1450). Ed. Frotscher,
Anon. Græci oratio
funebris
, Freiberg i. S., 1855. This work has not been seen, but
according to Seeck (
Ztschr. f. Wiss. Theol.
1890, p. 64) and
Wordsworth (p. 630) this edition contains the result of a study by
Wesseling, which shows that this work, referring to an anonymous
emperor, does not refer to Constantine II. at all, but to some ruler
who belongs in the fifteenth century.
Compare Seeck and Wordsworth for
editions.
(57)
Codinus
(d. ab. 1453?).
Excerpts on the origins of
Constantinople
. Ed. Bekker (Bonn. 1843). For
other editions, compare
articles of Plate and the
Nouv.
biog. gén
. Contains considerable
relating to Constantine, especially respecting the founding of
Constantinople, and the buildings and statues in it. Mainly
compilation, or compilation from compilation, but is from partly lost
sources and far from unnecessary. He died about 1453 (?).
Compare Plate, in Smith,
Dict
. 1 (1859), 810–811;
Nouv. biog. gén
. 11
(1855), 24–25; and for literature, Chevalier.
(58)
Ducas
(fl. 1450–1460
a.d.
)
gives “From the incarnation until Constantine the Great, 318
years,” and speaks of a church restored by him. Ed. Bekker, in
Corp. scr. hist. Byz
. (1834), p. 13 and 48.
(59)
Geoffrey
of Monmouth
(d. 1154).
British History
. English
translation (Lond. Bohn, 1848), 162– . The passage relating to
Constantine covers a number of pages, and is ninety-five per cent
fiction, five per cent fact.
Compare Tedder, in Stephen,
Dict. of Nat. Biog.
21 (1890), 133–135.
Various of the old chronicles
are only translations or paraphrases of this; e.g. the
Chronicle
of Pierre de Langtoft (ed. Wright, Lond. 1866, p. 76–78), various
Welsh, Anglo-Saxon, and French chronicles, Waurin’s
Recueil des Chroniques
(ed. Hardy, Lond. 1864), although Hardy maintains that
neither Waurin or any of the other versions are real translations, but
says there is some lost common source.
(60)
Henry of
Huntingdon
(1135).
History of the English.
Ed. Arnold,
Lond. 1879, 8°, p. 29–31. Engl. translation, Lond. Bohn,
1853, p. 28–29. This is written from generally good sources,
notably Eutropius, and means to be historical; but its mythical
details—e.g. Helena, a British princess, Constantine cured of
leprosy—make it useless.
Compare Forester, Preface to
translation; Wright,
Biog. Brit. Lit.
2 (1846),
167–173.
(61)
William
of Malmesbury
(1137).
Chronicle of England
. English
translation, Giles (Lond. Bohn, 1847), 6. Mentioned as a source because
often quoted in literature. He ascribes to Constantine the introduction
of the British settlement in France.
Compare Wright,
Biog. Brit.
Lit.
2 (1846), 134–142.
(62)
Diceto,
Ralph de
(d. 1202?).
Abbreviated Chronicles
. Ed. Stubbs,
Lond. 1876; section on Constantine, p. 73–76. This work was
composed before 1188. It consists in the main of abstracts from
Eutropius, Eusebius, Jerome, and Rufinus, with various mythical details
from William of Malmesbury and other sources.
Compare Poole, in Stephen,
Dict. of Nat. Biog
. 15 (1888), 12–14. This is taken from
Stubbs, Introduction, q.v.
(63)
Eulogium Historiarum
(ab. 1366). Ed. Haydon, Lond. 1858, 3 v.; section on Constantine, 1.
337–339; 2. 267–268, 332–333; 3. 12, 265. This was
probably written by Peter, a monk of Malmesbury (Haydon), about 1366.
Compiled from various sources, has familiar facts, but is of no value
except for legends.
Compare Preface of
Haydon.
(64)
Voragine
(1230–1298).
Golden Legend. Legend
concerning the Invention of the Cross.
Ed. Graesse (Lips. 1846,
repr. Vratisl. 1890). French translation by Brunet, 2 (1843),
118–116. Early English translation printed by Caxton. A curious
mixture of fact and fable, in which legendary is gathered, but all
facts are expressed with a curious conscientiousness, or pretended
conscientiousness, in quoting authorities. But on Constantine, however,
his authorities do not always come to the test of containing what he
quotes from them.
Compare article
Varaggio
,
in M’Clintock and Strong,
Cyclop
. 10 (1881), 719,
Brunet’s
Preface
and the Proceedings of the American Soc.
of Ch. Hist. for 1889.
Besides the above-mentioned
sources there are many mentions which may be found in the various
collections of mediæval documents, such, e.g., as Pertz,
Monumenta Germaniæ Historica
, which has various interesting
chronicles covering the period of Constantine.