45. They fled, beloved brethren, not only on
account of the calumnies they had uttered, but because they saw that
those had come who had various charges to advance against them. For
chains and irons were brought forward which they had used; persons
appeared who had returned from banishment; there came also our
brethren, kinsmen of those who were still detained in exile, and
friends of such as had perished through their means. And what was the
most weighty ground of accusation, Bishops were present, one Perhaps
Lucius of Hadrianople, says Montfaucon, referring to Apol. de
Fug. §3. vid. also Hist. Arian. 19. of whom brought forward the irons and chains
which they had caused him to wear, and others appealed to the death
which had been brought about by their calumnies. For they had proceeded
to such a pitch of madness, as even to attempt to destroy Bishops; and
would have destroyed them, had they not escaped their hands. Our
fellow-ministers, Theodulus of blessed memory Theodulus, Bishop of Trajanopolis in Thrace, who is here spoken of
as deceased, seems to have suffered this persecution from the Eusebians
upon their retreat from Sardica, vid. Athan. Hist. Arian.
§19. We must suppose then with Montfaucon, that the Council, from
whom this letter proceeds, sat some considerable time after that
retreat, and that the proceedings spoken of took place in the interval.
Socrates, however, makes Theodulus survive Constans, who died 350.
H. E. ii. 26., died
during his flight from their false accusations, orders having been
given in consequence of these to put him to death. Others also
exhibited sword-wounds; and others complained that they had been
exposed to the pains of hunger through their means. Nor were they
ordinary persons who testified to these things, but whole Churches, in
whose behalf legates appeared The
usual proceeding of the Arians was to retort upon the Catholics the
charges which they brought against them, supr. §33, note 4.
Accordingly, in their Encyclical from Philippopolis, they say that
“a vast multitude had congregated at Sardica, of wicked and
abandoned persons, from Constantinople and Alexandria; who lay under
charges of murder, blood, slaughter, robbery, plunder, spoiling, and
all nameless sacrileges and crimes; who had broken altars, burnt
Churches, ransacked private houses,” &c. &c. Hil.
Fragm. iii. 19., and told us of
soldiers sword in hand, of multitudes armed with clubs, of the threats
of judges, of the forgery of false letters. For there were read certain
false letters of Theognius and his fellows against our fellow-ministers
Athanasius, Marcellus, and Asclepas, written with the design of
exasperating the Emperors against them; and those who had then been
Deacons of Theognius proved the fact. From these men, we heard of
virgins stripped naked, churches burnt, ministers in custody, and all
for no other end, but only for the sake of the accursed heresy of the
Arian madmen, whose communion whoso refused was forced to suffer these
things.