25. If, however, those men who were ordained by Hilary,
and who have lately become sheep without a shepherd, are disposed to
allege Scripture in support of what the blessed Cyprian Cyprian’s
opinion as stated in his reply to the Numidian and Mauritanian bishops
(Ep. 71) was that converts must be baptized, unless they had received
the regular baptism of the Church before falling into heresy or schism,
in which case imposition of hands would suffice. The question was
afterwards decided against Cyprian’s views by the Council of
Arles (a.d. 314), which ordered that if the
baptism had been administered in the name of the Trinity, converts
should be admitted to the Church by imposition of hands. left in his letters advocating the
re-baptization of heretics, I beg them to remember that he did not
anathematize those who refused to follow him. At all events, he
remained in communion with such as opposed his views. He was content
with exhorting them, on account of For Novatus and an
account of the dispute between Cyprian and Stephen, see
Robertson’s “Hist. of Christian Church,” fourth ed.,
vol. i. pp. 120–127.Novatus and
the numerous other heretics then springing up, to receive no one who
did not condemn his previous error. In fact, he thus concludes the
discussion of the subject with Stephen, the Roman Pontiff: “These
things, dearest brother, I have brought to your knowledge on account of
our mutual respect and love unfeigned, believing, as I do, that from
the sincerity of your piety and your faith you will approve such things
as are alike consonant with piety and true in themselves. But I know
that some persons are unwilling to abandon views which they have once
entertained, and are averse to a change of purpose; they would rather,
without breaking the bond of peace and concord between colleagues,
adhere to their own plans, when once they have been adopted. This is a
matter in which we do not force anyone, or lay down a law for anyone;
let each follow his own free choice in the administration of the
Church: let each be ruler in his own sphere since he must give account
of his action to the Lord.” In the letter also to Jubaianus on
the re-baptization of heretics, towards the end, he says this: “I
have written these few remarks, my dearest brother, to the best of my
poor ability, without dictating to anyone, or prejudicing the case of
anyone: I would not hinder a single bishop from doing what he thinks
right with the full exercise of his own judgment. So far as is
possible, we avoid disputes with colleagues and fellow-bishops about
the heretics, and maintain with them a divine harmony and the
Lord’s peace, particularly since the Apostle says: 1 Cor. xi. 16. ‘But if any man seem to be
contentious, we have no such custom, neither the churches of
God.’ With patience and gentleness we preserve charity at heart,
the honour of our order, the bond of faith, the harmony of the
episcopate.”