Next he confutes them upon their charge that he
called the Son one of the things originated, and not of one essence
with the Father (once more in the first book) as follows: ‘Only
in saying that certain things were perceived to be originated and
created, I gave them as examples cursorily, as being less adequate,
saying that neither was the plant [of one essence] with the husbandman,
nor the boat with its builder. Then I dwelt more upon more apposite and
suitable comparisons, and went at greater length into those nearer the
truth, making out various proofs, which I wrote to you ‘To you’ is omitted in the extract de Decr.
25. in another letter, by means of which proofs I
shewed also that the charge they allege against me is untrue, namely,
that I denied Christ to be of one essence with God. For even if I argue
that I have not found this word (ὁμοούσιον)
nor read it anywhere in the Holy Scriptures, yet my subsequent
reasonings, which they have suppressed, do not discord with its
meaning. For I gave the example of human birth evidently as being
homogeneous, and saying that certainly the parents only differed from
their children in not being themselves the children, else it would
follow that there was no such thing as parents or children. And the
letter, as I said before, I am prevented by circumstances from
producing, else I would have sent you the exact words I then used, or
rather a copy of all the letter: which I will do if I have an
opportunity. But I know, and recollect, that I added several
similitudes from kindred relations. For I said that a plant, sprung
from a seed or root, was different from that whence it sprung, and at
the same time entirely of one nature with it: and that a stream flowing
from a well receives another form and name,—for the well is not
called a river, nor the river a well,—and that both existed, and
that the well was as it were a father, while the river was water from
the well. But they pretend not to see these and the like written
statements, but to be as it were blind, while they try to pelt me with
two unconnected expressions like stones, from a distance, not knowing
that in matters beyond our knowledge, and which require training to
apprehend, frequently not only foreign, but even contrary examples
serve to illustrate the problem in hand.’ And in the third book
he says, ‘Life was begotten of Life, and flowed as a river from a
well, and from Light unquenchable bright Light was kindled.’