It is remarkable how closely these two accounts, both contemporary with the facts they treat of, agree in all essential
points, though coming to us from sources not only independent, but even
adverse, inter se,—and in forms so little favourable to
exactness of statement as thanksgiving Hymns and encomiastic
Orations. When from Ephraim’s strophes we omit his pious
ascriptions of praise to God, and from Julian’s periods, the
fulsomeness of his panegyric on the Emperor, the residuum of material
fact is in either case much the same; the main outlines of narrative
(related or implied) are identical in both writers, each unconsciously
attests the truthfulness of the other. Both are farther confirmed
in great measure by the account of this siege embodied in the Pascha
Chronicle above referred to, which (as already stated) rests on
information drawn from a written record left by Valgesh who was Bishop
of Nisibis at the time, and to whose prayers Ephraim (Hymn XIII.
17) That Valgesh is the
“third” Bishop here meant, appears by comparison with Hymn
XVII. 2, where the three are named, Jacob, Babu (not elsewhere
mentioned), and Valgesh. attributed the speedy restoration of the
breach in the city wall.