it down in his Epistle,1642 whereas, if before He was begotten there was nothing, I see not
wherefore He, before Whom none was, should be said to have been after any.
101. With the consideration whereof we must join another most blasphemous objection
of theirs, which covers a subtle purpose to confuse the sense and understanding of simple
folk. They ask whether everything that comes to an end had also at any time a beginning.
If they are told that what has an end also had a beginning, then they return to the charge
with the question whether the Father has ceased to beget His Son. This by our consent being
granted them, they conclude that the generation of the Son had a beginning. The which if
you allow, it seems to follow that if the Generation had a beginning, it appears to have begun
in Him Who was begotten; so that one, who had not existed before, may be called “begot-
ten”—their intent being to close the inquiry by laying down as conclusive that there was a
time when the Son existed not.
102. Besides this, there are other vain objections, such as persons of their glibness of
tongue would readily urge. If, say they, the Son is the Word of the Father, then He is called
“begotten,” inasmuch as He is the Word. But then since He is the Word, He is not a work.
Now the Father has spoken “in divers manners,”1643 whence it follows that He has begotten
many Sons, if He has spoken His Word, not created it as a work of His hands. O fools,
talking as though they knew not the difference between the word uttered and the Divine
Word, abiding eternally, born of the Father—born, I say, not uttered only—in Whom is no
combination of syllables, but the fulness of the eternal Godhead and life without end!1644
103. Follows another blasphemy, whereby they enquire whether it was of His own free
will, or on compulsion, that the Father begat [His Son], intending, if we say, “Of His own
free will,” that we should appear as though we acknowledged that the Father’s Will preceded
the [Divine] Generation, and to answer that there being something that preceded the exist-
ence of the Son, the Son is not co-eternal with the Father, or that He, like the rest of the
world, is a being created, forasmuch as it is written, “He hath made all things, as many as
276
He would,”1645 though this is spoken, not of the Father and the Son, but of those creatures
which the Son made. Whereas if we answered that the Father begat [His Son] on compulsion,
we should seem to have attributed infirmity to the Father.
104. But in the eternal Generation there is no foregoing condition, neither of will, nor
of unwillingness, and therefore I can neither say that the Father begat of His free Will, nor
yet that He begat on compulsion, for to beget depends not upon possibility as determined
by will, but rather appears to stand in a certain right and property of the hidden being of
1642 Col. i. 16.
1643 Heb. i. 1.
1644 Col. i. 19; ii. 9; iii. 4; S. John i. 4; v. 26; xi. 25; xiv. 6; Rev. i. 18.
1645 Ps. cxv. 3, which, however, in the English, runs: “He hath done whatsoever pleased Him.”—Prayer-book.
613
Chapter IX. Various quibbling arguments, advanced by the Arians to show…