IV. If a man who knows himself to be destitute of any certain qualification, yet makes
a profession or pretence, in words of double meaning, equally signifying that qualification,
and something else very different, with a design to recommend himself to others’ judgment
and apprehension, as possessed of that qualification, he is guilty of deceitful equivocation,
viz. using words of double meaning, or capable of double application, with a design to induce
others to judge something to be true, which is not true. But he that would recommend
himself by such terms to others’ opinion or judgment, as being what he at the same time
knows he is not, endeavours to induce them to believe what he knows is not true, which is
to deceive them. 402
But if the scheme which Mr. W. undertakes to defend were true, it would follow that
such a kind of equivocation as this, (be it far from us to suppose it,) is what the infinitely
wise and holy God has instituted to be publicly used in the solemn services of his house, as
the very condition of persons’ admission to the external privileges of his people! For Mr.
W. abundantly asserts, that persons must be esteemed in the judgment and apprehension of
others to have true piety; and that one thing that must be done in order to it, one thing per-
taining to the moral evidence that recommends them to this judgment, is the profession they
make of religion, (p. 5. p. 139. p. 47. b, c. p. 132. p. 44. d.) In p. 42. speaking of the profession
of visible Christians, he has these words, “And it is from the nature and purport of this
profession, we say, the church is to judge the members to be wise virgins, of what they make
a show of.” And Mr. W. insists upon it, that according to Christ’s institution, this must be
in words equally signifying true godliness, and something else, without any discrimination
or marks of difference.—This is the scheme! And certainly such a doctrine of deceitful
equivocation in the public exercises of religion, is more agreeable to the principles and
practices of a religion I am loth to name, than the true religion of Jesus Christ.
Mr. W. says, (p. 35. d.) “I am at a loss to conceive how it will help the cause of truth to
represent those who are of Mr. S—‘s opinion, as teaching men that they may enter into
covenant with God with known and allowed guile.” Supposing I had made such a represent-
ation, I can tell him how it would have helped the cause of truth, (as it would be speaking
nothing but the truth,) if he be one of Mr. Stoddard’s opinion, (as he says he is,) and repres-
ents his own opinion truly.
But let the unreasonableness of this notion of professing gospel-holiness in words of
two meanings, without any discrimination or mark of difference, be a little further considered.
Since it is allowed, that gospel-holiness is the thing which is to be exhibited in the profession,
and there are words which signify this by a determinate meaning, why must they needs be
402 “To advance a dubious proposition, knowing it will be understood in a sense different from what you
give it in your mind, is an equivocation, in breach of good faith and sincerity.” Chamber’s Dictionary, under
the word Equivocation. ‡ Pref. (p. 3. d. e. and 5. d. p. 24 b. 25. b. 22. d. 27. a. 58. d. 69. d
1930
SECTION IV. Of an indeterminate profession.