OBJECT. VII.
Christ himself administered the Lord’s supper to Judas, whom he knew at the same time
to be graceless; which is a full evidence, that grace is not in itself a requisite qualification in
order to coming to the Lord’s supper; and if it be not requisite in itself, a profession of it
cannot be requisite.
Answ. 1. It is to me apparent, that Judas was not present at the administration of the
Lord’s supper. It is true, he was present at the passover, and dipped with Christ in the paschal
dish. The three former evangelists do differ in the order of the account they give of this
dipping in the dish.—Luke gives an account of it after his account of the Lord’s supper, Luke
xxii. 21.. But Matthew and Mark both give an account of it before. (Matt. xxvi. 23.. Mark
xiv. 20.) And the like might be shown in other instances of these three evangelists differing
one from another in the order of their narratives; one places those things in his history after
others, which another places first. These sacred historians do not undertake to declare pre-
cisely the date of every incident, but regard more the truth of facts, than the order of time.
However, in the present case, the nature of the thing speaks for itself, and shows, that Judas’s
dipping with Christ in the dish, or his hand being with Christ on the table, or receiving a sop
dipped in the dish, must be in that order wherein Matthew and Mark place it in their history,
viz. at the passover, antecedent to the Lord’s supper. For there is no such thing in the Lord’s
supper as dipping of sops, and dipping together in the dish; but there was in the passover,
where all had their hands together in the dish, and dipt their sops in the bitter sauce. None
of these three evangelists give us any account of the time when Judas went out: but John—who
is vastly more particular as to what passed that night, and is every where more exact as to
the order of time than the other evangelists—is very precise as to the time, viz. that Jesus
when he gave him the sop, at the same time sent him away, bidding him do quickly what he
intended to do; and accordingly when he had received the sop, he went immediately out, John
xiii. 27-30.. Now this sop being at the passover, it is evident he was not present at the Lord’s
supper which followed. Many of the best expositors are of this opinion, such as Van Mastricht,
Dr. Doddridge, and others.
Answ. 2. If Judas was there, I deny the consequence. As I have observed once and again
concerning the Lord’s dealings with his people under the Old Testament, so under the New
the same observation takes place. Christ did not come to judge the secrets of men, nor did
ordinarily act in his external dealings with his disciples, and in the administration of ordin-
ances, as the Searcher of hearts; but rather as the Head of the visible church, proceeding ac-
cording to what was exhibited in profession and visibility; herein setting an example to his
ministers, who should stand in his place when he was gone, and act in his name in the ad-
ministration of ordinances. Judas had made the same profession of regard to his Master,
and of forsaking all for him, as the other disciples: and therefore Christ did not openly re-
nounce him till he himself had destroyed his profession and visibility of saintship, by public
OBJ. VII. Case of Judas.
1845
OBJ. VII. Case of Judas.