Only-begotten God. He, at that time when He willed it, did make the creation; at that time,
by means of the circumambient essence, He surrounded with the body of heaven all that
universe that is shut off within its compass: at that time, when He thought it well that this
should be, He displayed the dry land to view, He enclosed the waters in their hollow places;
vegetation, fruits, the generation of animals, the formation of man, appeared at that time
when each of these things seemed expedient to the wisdom of the Creator:—and He Who
made all these things (I will once more repeat my statement) is the Only-begotten God Who
made the ages. For if the interval of the ages has preceded existing things, it is proper to
employ the temporal adverb, and to say “He then willed” and “He then made”: but since the
age was not, since no conception of interval is present to our minds in regard to that Divine
Nature which is not measured by quantity or by interval, the force of temporal expressions
must surely be void. Thus to say that the creation has had given to it a beginning in time,
according to the good pleasure of the wisdom of Him Who made all things, does not go
beyond probability: but to regard the Divine Nature itself as being in a kind of extension
212
measured by intervals, belongs only to those who have been trained in the new wisdom.
What a point is this, embedded in his words, which I intentionally passed by in my eagerness
to reach the subject! I will now resume it, and read it to show our author’s cleverness.
“For He Who is most highly exalted in God Himself908 before all other things that are
generated,” he says, “has dominion over His own power.” The phrase has been transferred
by our pamphleteer word for word from the Hebrew Philo to his own argument, and Eun-
omius’ theft will be proved by Philo’s works themselves to any one who cares about it. I note
the fact, however, at present, not so much to reproach our speech-monger with the poverty
of his own arguments and thoughts, as with the intention of showing to my readers the close
relationship between the doctrine of Eunomius and the reasoning of the Jews. For this phrase
of Philo would not have fitted word for word into his argument had there not been a sort
of kindred between the intention of the one and the other. In the Hebrew author you may
find the phrase in this form: “God, before all other things that are generated”; and what
follows, “has dominion over His own power,” is an addition of the new Judaism. But what
an absurdity this involves an examination of the saying will clearly show. “God,” he says,
“has dominion over His own power.” Tell me, what is He? over what has He dominion? Is
He something else than His own power, and Lord of a power that is something else than
908 This seems to be the force of the phrase if we are to follow Oehler’s mss. and read ὁ γὰρ ἐξοχώτατος
αὐτοῦ θεοῦ. The αὐτὸς θεὸς of the earlier editions gives a simpler sense. The phrase as read by Oehler certainly
savours more of Philo than of Eunomius: but it is worth noting that S. Gregory does not dwell upon this part
of the clause as being borrowed from Philo (though he may intend to include it in the general statement), but
upon what follows it: and from his citation from Philo it would seem that the latter spoke (not of ὁ ἐξοχώτατος
θεοῦ but) of ὁ Θεὸς πρὸ τῶν ἄλλων ὅσα γεννητά.
406
The ninth book declares that Eunomius' account of the Nature of God is,…