an impious conclusion. And it will result that the unchangeable and unaltered God has
altered and changed. For if He made the universe later, it is clear that He passed from not
making to making. But this is absurd in connection with what has been said. It is impossible,
therefore, to say that the universe is not unbeginning and co-eternal with God. To whom
the saint replies, in the person of another, asking, “Do you not consider God the beginning
and fountain of wisdom and glory, and in short of all virtue in substance and not by acquis-
ition?” “Certainly,” he says. “And what besides? Is He not by Himself perfect and independ-
ent?” “True; for it is impossible that he who is independent should have his independence
from another. For we must say, that all which is full by another is also imperfect. For it is
the thing which has its completeness of itself, and in itself alone, which can alone be con-
sidered perfect.” “You say most truly. For would you pronounce that which is neither by
itself complete, nor its own completeness, to be independent?” “By no means. For that which
is perfect through anything else must needs be in itself imperfect.” “Well, then shall God be
considered perfect by Himself, and not by some other?” “Most rightly.” “Then God is
something different from the world, and the world from God?” “Quite so.” “We must not
then say that God is perfect, and Creator, and Almighty, through the world?” “No; for He
must surely by Himself, and not by the world, and that changeable, be found perfect by
Himself.” “Quite so.” “But you will say that the rich man is called rich on account of his
riches? And that the wise man is called wise not as being wisdom itself, but as being a pos-
sessor of substantial wisdom?” “Yes.” “Well, then, since God is something different from
the world, shall He be called on account of the world rich, and beneficent, and Creator?”
380
“By no means. Away with such a thought!” “Well, then, He is His own riches, and is by
Himself rich and powerful.” “So it seems.” “He was then before the world altogether inde-
pendent, being Father, and Almighty, and Creator; so that He by Himself, and not by another,
was this.” “It must be so.” “Yes; for if He were acknowledged to be Almighty on account of
the world, and not of Himself, being distinct from the world,—may God forgive the words,
which the necessity of the argument requires,—He would by Himself be imperfect and have
need of these things, through which He is marvellously Almighty and Creator. We must
not then admit this pestilent sin of those who say concerning God, that He is Almighty and
Creator by the things which He controls and creates, which are changeable, and that He is
not so by Himself.”
III. Now consider it thus: “If, you say, the world was created later, not existing before,
then we must change the passionless and unchangeable God; for it must needs be, that he
who did nothing before, but afterwards, passes from not doing to doing, changes and is
altered.” Then I said, “Did God rest from making the world, or not?” “He rested.” “Because
otherwise it would not have been completed.” “True.” “If, then, the act of making, after not
making, makes an alteration in God, does not His ceasing to make after making the same?”
“Of necessity.” “But should you say that He is altered as not doing to-day, from what He
853
Extracts from the Work on Things Created.