easy to make these things consist with what he says in his answer to Mr. Croswell, (p. 26. b.
c.) He there says, “There is not a son nor daughter of Adam excluded from salvation, who
will accept Christ upon God’s offer, and take him in his person and offices, and whole work
of redemption, to be their Saviour, and they find themselves willing to accept of Christ as
so offered to them, and pleased with that device for their salvation, and heartily choosing
him to be to them, and in them, wisdom, righteousness, sanctification, and redemption.”
(See also to the same purpose, Ibid. p. 32. e. and p. 33. a. b. and p. 94. c.)
Mr. W. though he holds, that it is lawful for some unsanctified men to come to sacra-
ments, yet supposes it not to be lawful for those that are lukewarm in religion to come, (p.
35. d. e.) So that according to his scheme some unsanctified professors are above lukewarm-
ness: that is to say, their hearts within them are truly hot or fervent with christian zeal, and
they such as Christ will never spue out of his mouth; in a great inconsistence with the
Scripture. He suggests, that it is an injury done to the cause of truth, in me, to represent Mr.
Stoddard as being of another opinion, (p. 35. c. d. e.) But let us see whether such a represent-
ation be an injury to truth or no. Mr. S. taught, that natural men have no sincerity in them.
(Guide to Christ, p. 60, 61.) That their hearts are dead as a stone, that there is no disposition
or inclination to any thing that is good, but a total emptiness of all goodness. (Ibid. p. 63.
b.) That some of them have considerable shows of goodness, there is an appearance of good
desires, &c. but there is nothing of goodness in all this; that all they do is in hypocrisy. (Benef.
of the Gos. p. 73. d. c.) That they are acted by a lust of self-love in all their religion;—If they
are swept and garnished, they are empty: there may be some similitude of faith and love,
but no reality, not a spark of goodness in their hearts; though corruption may be restrained,
yet it reigns. He speaks abundantly to the same purpose in his sermon, entitled, Natural
men are under the government of self-love.
And Mr. W. himself, in his sermon on Psal. xci. 1. describing carnal men, by which he
means the same with unconverted men, (as is evident through the book, particularly p. 36.
c.) says, p. 27, 28. that to such “Religion looks like a dull unpleasant kind of exercises, and
so different from the sensual joys and pleasures which they choose, that they hate to set
about it, as long as they dare let it alone; and would do as little as ever they can at it:—That
when they durst not let it alone any longer, they set about it, but would fain despatch it as
soon and as easily as they can; because it seems to them a miserable uncomfortable sort of
life. Ask your own conscience, (says he,) see if this be not the truth of the case.”—Now let
the reader judge, whether this be a description of persons whom it would be injurious to
represent as having nothing above lukewarmness.
Another thing, which Mr. W. supposes must be professed in order to come to sacraments,
and therefore according to him is what an unsanctified man can profess, and speak true, is,
“That they with all their hearts cast themselves upon the mercy of God, to help them to keep
covenant.” (p. 31. e. and p. 32. a.) And yet elsewhere he mentions a depending on Christ
1936
SECTION V. Mr. W. inconsistent with Mr. Stoddard.