1. After writing the Letter
CXXXIII.letter
to Ctesiphon, in which I replied to the questions propounded, I
received frequent expostulations from the brethren, who wanted to know
why I any longer delayed the promised work in which I undertook to
answer all the subtleties of the preachers of Impassibility. ᾽Απάθεια. For every one knows what was the
contention of the Stoics and Peripatetics, that is, the old Academy,
some of them asserted that the πάθη, which we may call
emotions, such as sorrow, joy, hope, fear, can be thoroughly
eradicated from the minds of men; others that their power can be
broken, that they can be governed and restrained, as unmanageable
horses are held in check by peculiar kinds of bits. Their views have
been explained by Tully in the “Tusculan Disputations,” and
Origen in his “Stromata” endeavours to blend them with
ecclesiastical truth. I pass over Manichæus, Priscillian was a
Spaniard, who began to propagate his views, which were a mixture of
various heresies, about the year 370. See Robertson, p. 295 sq., and
Note on Jerome, Letter CXXXIII. Priscillianus, Evagrius
Iberita. The name is taken either from a town named Ibera or Ibora in
Pontus, or from the province of Iberia. Jerome, in the letter to which
he refers, styles Evagrius Hyperborita, but this is thought to
be an error for Hyborita. It has been suggested that Jerome was
playing on the word Iberita. He was born in 345. He wrote,
amongst many other works, a treatise Περὶ
ἀπαθείας (On
Impassibility), and no doubt Jerome refers to this a few lines above.
He was a zealous champion of Origen. See also Jerome, Letter CXXXIII.
and note. Evagrius of Ibora, Jovinianus, and the
heretics found throughout almost the whole of Syria, who, by a
perversion of the import of their name, are commonly called The Massalians
or Euchites derived their name from their habit of continual
prayer. The words are etymological equivalents (Massalians, from
צלּא to pray).
The perversity lay in the misinterpretation of such texts as Luke xviii. 1, and 1 Thess. v. 17.Massalians, in Greek,
Euchites, all of whom hold that it is possible for human virtue
and human knowledge to attain perfection, and arrive, I will not say
merely at a likeness to, but an equality with God; and who go the length of asserting
that, when once they have reached the height of perfection, even sins
of thought and ignorance are impossible for them. And although in my
former letter addressed to Ctesiphon and aimed at their errors, so far
as time permitted, I touched upon a few points in the book which I am
now endeavouring to hammer out, I shall adhere to the method of
Socrates. What can be said on both sides shall be stated; and the truth
will thus be clear when both sides express their opinions. Origen is
peculiar in maintaining on the one hand that it is impossible for human
nature to pass through life without sin, and on the other, that it is
possible for a man, when he turns to better things, to become so strong
that he sins no more.