(b) The first exile of Athanasius. The
duration is fixed by the Hist. Aceph. (see Introd. p. 495,
sq.) as two years, four months, and eleven days, and this
exactly coincides with the dates given by the Index for his
departure for Tyre, July 11, 335, and his return from exile Nov. 23,
337 (not 338; for the Diocletian year began at the end of August).
Although, therefore, the Hist. Aceph. is not available for the
date, the constructive agreement between it and the Index is
complete. But it has been contended that the year of the return from
this exile must still be placed in 338, in spite of the new evidence to
the contrary. The reasons alleged are very weak. (1) The letter of
Constantine II., dated Treveri, June 17, so far from making against the
year 337, clinches the argument in its favour. Constantine is still
only ‘Cæsar’ when he writes it (pp. 146, 272); he was
proclaimed Augustus on Sep. 9, 337 (Montf. in ann. 338 tries in
vain to parry this decisive objection to the later date. He appeals to
Maximin in Eus. H. E. ix. 10, but overlooks the word σεβαστός there. Is
it conceivable that a disappointed eldest son, as sensitive about his
claims as Constantine was, would within so short a time of becoming
‘Augustus’ be content to call himself merely
‘Cæsar’?) The objection as to the distance of Treveri
from Nicomedia has no weight, as we show elsewhere (p. xli., note 4);
Constantine might have heard of his father’s death a fortnight
before the date of this letter. (2) The law (Cod. Th. X. x. 4)
dated Viminacium, June 12, 338, if correctly ascribed to Constantius,
would certainly lend plausibility to the view that it was at that time
that Athanasius met Constantius at Viminacium (p. 240). But the names
are so often confused in mss., and the text of the Theodosian Code requires
such frequent correction, that there is no solid objection to set
against the extremely cogent proofs (Gwatkin, p. 138) that the law
belongs to Constantine, who in that case cannot have been at Trier on
June 17, 338. As to Constantius, there is no reason against his having
been in Pannonia at some time in the summer of 337. (3) The statement
of Theodoret (H. E. ii. 1) that Ath. ‘stayed at Treveri
two years and four months’ seems to reproduce that of the
Hist. Aceph. as to the length of the exile, and is only verbally
inexact in applying it to the period actually spent in Trier. (4) The
language of Letter 10, the Festal letter for 338, is not
absolutely decisive, but §§3, 11 certainly imply that when it
was written, whether at Alexandria or elsewhere, the durance of
Athanasius was at an end. There can, we submit, be no reasonable doubt
that the first exile of Athanasius began with his departure from
Alexandria on July 11, 335, and ended with his return thither on Nov.
23, 337.