Introductory Note to Irenæus Against Heresies
[
a.d.
120–202.]
This
history introduces us to the Church in her Western outposts. We reach the
banks of the Rhone, where for nearly a century Christian missions have
flourished. Between Marseilles and Smyrna there seems to have been a
brisk trade, and Polycarp had sent Pothinus into Celtic Gaul at an early
date as its evangelist. He had fixed his see at Lyons, when Irenæus
joined him as a presbyter, having been his fellow-pupil under Polycarp.
There, under the “good Aurelius,” as he is miscalled (
a.d.
177), arose the terrible
persecution which made “the martyrs of Lyons and Vienne” so
memorable. It was during this persecution that Irenæus was sent to Rome
with letters of remonstrance against the rising pestilence of heresy; and
he was probably the author of the account of the sufferings of the
martyrs which is appended to their testimony.
2649
But he had the mortification of finding the Montanist heresy patronized
by Eleutherus the Bishop of Rome; and there he met an old friend from the
school of Polycarp, who had embraced the Valentinian heresy. We cannot
doubt that to this visit we owe the lifelong struggle of Irenæus against
the heresies that now came in, like locusts, to devour the harvests of
the Gospel. But let it be noted here, that, so far from being “the
mother and mistress” of even the Western Churches, Rome herself is
a mission of the Greeks;
2650
Southern Gaul is evangelized from Asia Minor, and
Lyons checks the heretical tendencies of the Bishop at Rome. Ante-Nicene
Christianity, and indeed the Church herself, appears in Greek costume
which lasts through the synodical period; and Latin Christianity, when it
begins to appear, is African, and not Roman. It is strange that those who
have recorded this great historical fact have so little perceived its
bearings upon Roman pretensions in the Middle Ages and modern times.
Returning to Lyons, our author found that the venerable
Pothinus had closed his holy career by a martyr’s death; and
naturally Irenæus became his successor. When the emissaries of heresy
followed him, and began to disseminate their licentious practices and
foolish doctrines by the aid of “silly women,” the great work
of his life began. He condescended to study these diseases of the human
mind like a wise physician; and, sickening as was the process of
classifying and describing them, he made this also his laborious task,
that he might enable others to withstand and to overcome them. The works
he has left us are monuments of his fidelity to Christ, and to the
charges of St. Paul, St. Peter, and St. Jude, whose solemn warnings now
proved to be prophecies. No marvel that the great apostle, “night
and day with tears,” had forewarned the churches of “the
grievous wolves” which were to make havoc of the fold.
If it shocks the young student of the virgin years of
Christianity to find such a state of things, let him reflect that it was
all foretold by Christ himself, and demonstrates the malice and power of
the adversary. “An enemy hath done this,” said the Master.
The spirit that was then working
“in the children of
disobedience,” now manifested itself. The awful visions of the
Apocalypse began to be realized. It was now evident in what sense
“the Prince of peace” had pronounced His mission, “not
peace, but a sword.” In short, it became a conspicuous fact, that
the Church here on earth is “militant;” while, at the same
time, there was seen to be a profound philosophy in the apostolic
comment,
2651
“There must be also heresies among
you, that they which are approved may be made manifest.” In the
divine economy of Providence it was permitted that every form of heresy
which was ever to infest the Church should now exhibit its essential
principle, and attract the censures of the faithful. Thus testimony to
primitive truth was secured and recorded: the language of catholic
orthodoxy was developed and defined, and landmarks of faith were set up
for perpetual memorial to all generations. It is a striking example of
this divine economy, that the see of Rome was allowed to exhibit its
fallibility very conspicuously at this time, and not only to receive the
rebukes of Irenæus, but to accept them as wholesome and necessary; so
that the heresy of Eleutherus, and the spirit of Diotrephes in Victor,
have enabled reformers ever since, and even in the darkest days of
pontifical despotism, to testify against the manifold errors patronized
by Rome. Hilary and other Gallicans have been strengthened by the example
of Irenæus, and by his faithful words of reproof and exhortation, to
resist Rome, even down to our own times.
That the intolerable absurdities of Gnosticism should
have gained so many disciples, and proved itself an adversary to be
grappled with and not despised, throws light on the condition of the
human mind under heathenism, even when it professed
“knowledge” and “philosophy.” The task of
Irenæus was twofold: (1) to render it impossible for any one to confound
Gnosticism with Christianity, and (2) to make it impossible for such a
monstrous system to survive, or ever to rise again. His task was a
nauseous one; but never was the spirit enjoined by Scripture more
patiently exhibited, nor with more entire success.
2652
If Julian had found Gnosticism just made to
his hand, and powerful enough to suit his purposes, the whole history of
his attempt to revive Paganism would have been widely different. Irenæus
demonstrated its essential unity with the old mythology, and with heathen
systems of philosophy. If the fog and malaria that rose with the
Day-star, and obscured it, were speedily dispersed, our author is largely
to be identified with the radiance which flowed from the Sun of
righteousness, and with the breath of the Spirit that banished them for
ever.
The Episcopate of Irenæus was distinguished by
labours, “in season and out of season,” for the
evangelization of Southern Gaul; and he seems to have sent missionaries
into other regions of what we now call France. In spite of Paganism and
heresy, he rendered Lyons a Christian city; and Marcus seems to have
retreated before his terrible castigation, taking himself off to regions
beyond the Pyrenees.
2653
But the pacific name he bears, was
rendered yet more illustrious by his interposition to compose the Easter
Controversy, then threatening to impair, if not to destroy, the unity of
the Church. The beautiful
concordat
between East and West, in
which Polycarp and Anicetus had left the question, was now disturbed by
Victor, Bishop of Rome, whose turbulent spirit would not accept the
compromise of his predecessor. Irenæus remonstrates with him in a
catholic spirit, and overrules his impetuous temper. At the Council of
Nice, the rule for the observance of Easter was finally settled by the
whole Church; and the forbearing example of Irenæus, no doubt
contributed greatly to this happy result. The blessed peacemaker survived
this great triumph, for a short time only, closing his life, like a true
shepherd, with thousands of his flock, in the massacre (
a.d.
202) stimulated by the
wolfish Emperor Severus.
The
Introductory
Notice
of the learned translators
2654
is as
follows:—
The
work of Irenæus
Against
Heresies
is one of the most precious remains of early Christian
antiquity. It is devoted, on the one hand, to an account and refutation
of those multiform Gnostic heresies which prevailed in the latter half of
the second century; and, on the other hand, to an exposition and defence
of the Catholic faith.
In the prosecution of this plan, the author divides his
work into five books. The first of these contains a minute description of
the tenets of the various heretical sects, with occasional brief remarks
in illustration of their absurdity, and in confirmation of the truth to
which they were opposed. In his second book, Irenæus proceeds to a more
complete demolition of those heresies which he has already explained, and
argues at great length against them, on grounds principally of reason.
The three remaining books set forth more directly the true doctrines of
revelation, as being in utter antagonism to the views held by the Gnostic
teachers. In the course of this argument, many passages of Scripture are
quoted and commented on; many interesting statements are made, bearing on
the rule of faith; and much important light is shed on the doctrines,
held, as well as the practices observed, by the Church of the second
century.
It may be made matter of regret, that so large a
portion of the work of Irenæus is given to an exposition of the manifold
Gnostic speculations. Nothing more absurd than these has probably ever
been imagined by rational beings. Some ingenious and learned men have
indeed endeavoured to reconcile the wild theories of these heretics with
the principles of reason; but, as Bishop Kaye remarks (
Eccl. Hist. of
the Second and Third Centuries
, p. 524), “a more arduous or
unpromising undertaking cannot well be conceived.” The fundamental
object of the Gnostic speculations was doubtless to solve the two grand
problems of all religious philosophy, viz., How to account for the
existence of evil; and, How to reconcile the finite with the infinite.
But these ancient theorists were not more successful in grappling with
such questions than have been their successors in modern times. And by
giving loose reins to their imagination, they built up the most
incongruous and ridiculous systems; while, by deserting the guidance of
Scripture they were betrayed into the most pernicious and extravagant
errors.
Accordingly, the patience of the reader is sorely
tried, in following our author through those mazes of absurdity which he
treads, in explaining and refuting these Gnostic speculations. This is
especially felt in the perusal of the first two books, which, as has been
said, are principally devoted to an exposition and subversion of the
various heretical systems. But the vagaries of the human mind, however
melancholy in themselves, are never altogether destitute of instruction.
And in dealing with those set before us in this work, we have not only
the satisfaction of becoming acquainted with the currents of thought
prevalent in these early times, but we obtain much valuable information
regarding the primitive Church, which, had it not been for these
heretical schemes, might never have reached our day.
Not a little of what is contained in the following
pages will seem almost unintelligible to the English reader. And it is
scarcely more comprehensible to those who have pondered long on the
original. We have inserted brief notes of explanation where these seemed
specially necessary. But we have not thought it worth while to devote a
great deal of space to the elucidation of those obscure Gnostic views
which, in so many varying forms, are set forth in this work. For the same
reason, we give here no account of the origin, history, and successive
phases of Gnosticism. Those who wish to know the views of the learned on
these points, may consult the writings of Neander, Baur, and others,
among the Germans, or the lectures of Dr. Burton in English; while a
succinct description of the whole matter will be found in the
“Preliminary Observations on the Gnostic System,” prefixed to
Harvey’s edition of Irenæus.
The great work of Irenæus, now for the first time
translated into English, is unfortunately no longer extant in the
original. It has come down to us only in an ancient Latin version, with
the exception of the greater part of the first book, which has been
preserved in the original Greek, through means of copious quotations made
by Hippolytus and Epiphanius. The text, both Latin
and
Greek, is often most uncertain. Only three
mss.
of the work
Against
Heresies
are at present known to exist. Others, however, were used in
the earliest printed editions put forth by Erasmus. And as these codices
were more ancient than any now available, it is greatly to be regretted
that they have disappeared or perished. One of our difficulties
throughout, has been to fix the readings we should adopt, especially in
the first book. Varieties of reading, actual or conjectural, have been
noted only when some point of special importance seemed to be
involved.
After the text has been settled, according to the best
judgment which can be formed, the work of translation remains; and that
is, in this case, a matter of no small difficulty. Irenæus, even in the
original Greek, is often a very obscure writer. At times he expresses
himself with remarkable clearness and terseness; but, upon the whole, his
style is very involved and prolix. And the Latin version adds to these
difficulties of the original, by being itself of the most barbarous
character. In fact, it is often necessary to make a conjectural
re-translation of it into Greek, in order to obtain some inkling of what
the author wrote. Dodwell supposes this Latin version to have been made
about the end of the fourth century; but as Tertullian seems to have used
it, we must rather place it in the beginning of the third. Its author is
unknown, but he was certainly little qualified for his task. We have
endeavoured to give as close and accurate a translation of the work as
possible, but there are not a few passages in which a guess can only be
made as to the probable meaning.
Irenæus had manifestly taken great pains to make
himself acquainted with the various heretical systems which he describes.
His mode of exposing and refuting these is generally very effective. It
is plain that he possessed a good share of learning, and that he had a
firm grasp of the doctrines of Scripture. Not unfrequently he indulges in
a kind of sarcastic humour, while inveighing against the folly and
impiety of the heretics. But at times he gives expression to very strange
opinions. He is, for example, quite peculiar in imagining that our Lord
lived to be an
old
man, and that His public ministry embraced at
least
ten
years. But though, on these and some other points, the
judgment of Irenæus is clearly at fault, his work contains a vast deal
of sound and valuable exposition of Scripture, in opposition to the
fanciful systems of interpretation which prevailed in his day.
We possess only very scanty accounts of the personal
history of Irenæus. It has been generally supposed that he was a native
of Smyrna, or some neighbouring city, in Asia Minor. Harvey, however,
thinks that he was probably born in Syria, and removed in boyhood to
Smyrna. He himself tells us (iii. 3, 4) that he was in early youth
acquainted with Polycarp, the illustrious bishop of that city. A sort of
clue is thus furnished as to the date of his birth. Dodwell supposes that
he was born so early as
a.d.
97, but this is clearly a
mistake; and the general date assigned to his birth is somewhere between
a.d.
120 and
a.d.
140.
It is certain that Irenæus was bishop of Lyons, in
France, during the latter quarter of the second century. The exact period
or circumstances of his ordination cannot be determined. Eusebius states
(
Hist. Eccl.
, v. 4) that he was, while yet a presbyter, sent with
a letter, from certain members of the Church of Lyons awaiting martyrdom,
to Eleutherus, bishop of Rome; and that (v. 5) he succeeded Pothinus as
bishop of Lyons, probably about
a.d.
177. His great work
Against Heresies
was, we learn, written during the episcopate of
Eleutherus, that is, between
a.d.
182 and
a.d.
188, for Victor succeeded to
the bishopric of Rome in
a.d.
189. This new bishop of Rome
took very harsh measures for enforcing uniformity throughout the Church
as to the observance of the paschal solemnities. On account of the
severity thus evinced, Irenæus addressed to him a letter (only a
fragment of which remains), warning him that if he persisted in the
course on which he had entered, the effect would be to rend the Catholic
Church in pieces. This letter had the desired result; and the question
was more temperately debated, until finally settled by the Council of
Nice.
The full title of the principal work of Irenæus, as
given by Eusebius (
Hist. Eccl.
, v. 7), and
indicated
frequently by the author himself, was
A Refutation and Subversion of
Knowledge falsely so called
, but it is generally referred to under
the shorter title,
Against Heresies
. Several other smaller
treatises are ascribed to Irenæus; viz.,
An Epistle to Florinus
,
of which a small fragment has been preserved by Eusebius; a treatise
On the Valentinian Ogdoad
; a work called forth by the paschal
controversy, entitled
On Schism
, and another
On Science
;
all of which that remain will be found in our next volume of his
writings. Irenæus is supposed to have died about
a.d.
202; but there is probably
no real ground for the statement of Jerome, repeated by subsequent
writers, that he suffered martyrdom, since neither Tertullian nor
Eusebius, nor other early authorities, make any mention of such a
fact.
As has been already stated, the first printed copy of
our author was given to the world by Erasmus. This was in the year 1526.
Between that date and 1571, a number of reprints were produced in both
folio and octavo. All these contained merely the ancient barbarous Latin
version, and were deficient towards the end by five entire chapters.
These latter were supplied by the edition of Feuardent, Professor of
Divinity at Paris, which was published in 1575, and went through six
subsequent editions. Previously to this, however, another had been set
forth by Gallasius, a minister of Geneva, which contained the first
portions of the Greek text from Epiphanius. Then, in 1702, came the
edition of Grabe, a learned Prussian, who had settled in England. It was
published at Oxford, and contained considerable additions to the Greek
text, with fragments. Ten years after this there appeared the important
Paris edition by the Benedictine monk Massuet. This was reprinted at
Venice in the year 1724, in two thin folio volumes, and again at Paris in
a large octavo, by the Abbé Migne, in 1857. A German edition was
published by Stieren in 1853. In the year 1857 there was also brought out
a Cambridge edition, by the Rev. Wigan Harvey, in two octavo volumes. The
two principal features of this edition are: the additions which have been
made to the Greek text from the recently discovered
Philosophoumena
of Hippolytus; and the further addition of
thirty-two fragments of a Syriac version of the Greek text of Irenæus,
culled from the Nitrian collection of Syriac
mss.
in the British Museum. These
fragments are of considerable interest, and in some instances rectify the
readings of the barbarous Latin version, where, without such aid, it
would have been unintelligible. The edition of Harvey will be found
constantly referred to in the notes appended to our translation.
2649
Eusebius, book v. to the twenty-seventh
chapter, should be read as an introduction to this author.
2650
Milman,
Hist. Latin Christianity
, b. i. pp. 27, 28, and the
notes.
2651
1 Cor.
xi. 19
.
2652
2 Tim. ii. 24, 25,
26
.
2653
On
the authority of St. Jerome. See Guettée,
De l’église de
France
, vol. 1. p. 27.
2654
The first two books of Irenæus
Against Heresies
have been translated by Dr. Roberts. The groundwork of the translation of
the third book, and that portion of the fourth book which is continued in
this volume, has been furnished by the Rev. W. H. Rambaut. An attempt has
been made, in rendering this important author into English, to adhere as
closely as possible to the original. It would have been far easier to
give a loose and flowing translation of the obscure and involved
sentences of Irenæus; but the object has been studiously kept in view,
to place the English reader, as much as possible, in the position of one
who has immediate access to the Greek or Latin text.