§2.
Eusebius’ Birth and Training. His Life in
Cæsarea until the Outbreak of the Persecution.
Our author was commonly known
among the ancients as Eusebius of Cæsarea or Eusebius Pamphili.
The former designation arose from the fact that he was bishop of the
church in Cæsarea for many years; the latter from the fact that he
was the intimate friend and devoted admirer of Pamphilus, a presbyter
of Cæsarea and a martyr. Some such specific appellation was
necessary to
distinguish him from others of the same name. Smith and Wace’s
Dictionary of Christian Biography
mentions 137 men of the first
eight centuries who bore the name Eusebius, and of these at least forty
were contemporaries of our author. The best known among them were
Eusebius of Nicomedia (called by Arius the brother of Eusebius of
Cæsarea), Eusebius of Emesa, and Eusebius of Samosata.
The exact date of our
author’s birth is unknown to us, but his
Ecclesiastical
History
contains notices which enable us to fix it approximately.
In
H. E.
V. 28 he reports that Paul of Samosata attempted to
revive again in his day (
καθ᾽ ἡμᾶς
) the heresy of Artemon. But Paul of Samosata was deposed
from the episcopate of Antioch in 272, and was condemned as a heretic
at least as early as 268, so that Eusebius must have been born before
the latter date, if his words are to be strictly interpreted. Again,
according to
H. E.
III. 28, Dionysius was bishop of Alexandria
in Eusebius’ time (
καθ᾽ ἡμᾶς
). But Dionysius was bishop from 247 or 248 to 265, and
therefore if Eusebius’ words are to be interpreted strictly here
as in the former case, he must have been born before 265. On the other
hand, inasmuch as his death occurred about 340, we cannot throw his
birth much earlier than 260. It is true that the references to Paul and
to Dionysius do not prove conclusively that Eusebius was alive in their
day, for his words may have been used in a loose sense. But in
H.
E.
VII. 26, just before proceeding to give an account of Paul of
Samosata, he draws the line between his own and the preceding
generation, declaring that he is now about to relate the events of his
own age (
τὴν
καθ᾽ ἡμᾶς
). This still further confirms the other indications, and we shall
consequently be safe in concluding that Eusebius was born not far from
the year 260
a.d.
His birthplace cannot be
determined with certainty. The fact that he is called “Eusebius
the Palestinian” by Marcellus (
Euseb. lib. adv. Marcell
.
I. 4), Basil (
Lib. ad. Amphil. de Spir. Sancto
, c. 29), and
others, does not prove that he was a Palestinian by birth; for the
epithet may be used to indicate merely his place of residence (he was
bishop of Cæsarea in Palestine for many years). Moreover, the
argument urged by Stein and Lightfoot in support of his Palestinian
birth, namely, that it was customary to elect to the episcopate of any
church a native of the city in preference to a native of some other
place, does not count for much. All that seems to have been demanded
was that a man should have been already a member of the particular
church over which he was to be made bishop, and even this rule was not
universal (see Bingham’s
Antiquities
, II. 10, 2 and 3).
The fact that he was bishop of Cæsarea therefore would at most
warrant us in concluding only that he had made his residence in
Cæsarea for some time previous to his election to that office.
Nevertheless, although neither of these arguments proves his
Palestinian birth, it is very probable that he was a native of that
country, or at least of that section. He was acquainted with Syriac as
well as with Greek, which circumstance taken in connection with his
ignorance of Latin (see below, p. 47) points to the region of Syria as
his birthplace. Moreover, we learn from his own testimony that he was
in Cæsarea while still a youth (
Vita Constantini
, I. 19),
and in his epistle to the church of Cæsarea (see below, p. 16) he
says that he was taught the creed of the Cæsarean church in his
childhood (or at least at the beginning of his Christian life:
ἐν τῇ
κατηχήσει
), and that he accepted it at baptism. It would seem
therefore that he must have lived while still a child either in
Cæsarea itself, or in the neighborhood, where its creed was in
use. Although no one therefore (except Theodorus Metochita of the
fourteenth century, in his
Cap. Miscell. 17;
Migne,
Patr.
Lat.
CXLIV. 949) directly states that Eusebius was a Palestinian by
birth, we have every reason to suppose him such.
His parents are entirely
unknown. Nicephorus Callistus (
H. E.
VI. 37) reports that his
mother was a sister of Pamphilus. He does not mention his authority for
this statement, and it is extremely unlikely, in the face of the
silence of Eusebius himself and of all other writers, that it is true.
It is far more probable that the relationship was later assumed to
account for the close intimacy of the two men. Arius, in an epistle
addressed to Eusebius of Nicomedia (contained in Theodoret’s
Hist. Eccles
. I. 5), calls Eusebius of Cæsarea the
latter’s brother. It is objected to this that Eusebius of
Nicomedia refers to Eusebius of Cæsarea on one occasion as
his
“master” (
τοῦ
δεσπότου
μου
, in his epistle to Paulinus
contained in Theodoret’s
Hist. Eccles
. I. 6), and that on
the other hand Eusebius of Cæsarea calls Eusebius of Nicomedia,
“the great Eusebius” (
Euseb. lib. adv. Marcell
. I.
4), both of which expressions seem inconsistent with brotherhood.
Lightfoot justly remarks that neither the argument itself nor the
objections carry much weight. The term
ἀδελφός
may
well have been used to indicate merely theological or ecclesiastical
association, while on the other hand, brotherhood would not exclude the
form of expression employed by each in speaking of the other. Of more
weight is the fact that neither Eusebius himself nor any historian of
that period refers to such a relationship, and also the unlikelihood
that two members of one family should bear the same name.
From Eusebius’ works we
gather that he must have received an extensive education both in
secular philosophy and in Biblical and theological science. Although
his immense erudition was doubtless the result of wide and varied
reading continued throughout life, it is highly probable that he
acquired the taste for such reading in his youth. Who his early
instructors were we do not know, and therefore cannot estimate the
degree of their influence over him. As he was a man, however, who
cherished deep admiration for those whom he regarded as great and good
men, and as he possessed an unusually acquisitive mind and a pliant
disposition, we should naturally suppose that his instructors must have
possessed considerable influence over him, and that his methods of
study in later years must have been largely molded by their example and
precept. We see this exemplified in a remarkable degree in the
influence exerted over him by Pamphilus, his dearest friend, and at the
same time the preceptor, as it were, of his early manhood. Certainly
this great bibliopholist must have done much to strengthen
Eusebius’ natural taste for omnivorous reading, and the
opportunities afforded by his grand library for the cultivation of such
a taste were not lost. To the influence of Pamphilus, the devoted
admirer and enthusiastic champion of Origen, was doubtless due also in
large measure the deep respect which Eusebius showed for that
illustrious Father, a respect to which we owe one of the most
delightful sections of his Church History, his long account of Origen
in the sixth book, and to which in part antiquity was indebted for the
elaborate
Defense of Origen,
composed by Pamphilus and himself,
but unfortunately no longer extant. Eusebius certainly owed much to the
companionship of that eager student and noble Christian hero, and he
always recognized with deep gratitude his indebtedness to him. (Compare
the account of Pamphilus given below in Bk. VII. chap. 32, §25
sq.) The names of his earlier instructors, who were eminently
successful, at least in fostering his thirst for knowledge, are quite
unknown to us. His abiding admiration for Plato, whom he always placed
at the head of all philosophers (see Stein, p. 6), would lead us to
think that he received at least a part of his secular training from
some ardent Platonist, while his intense interest in apologetics, which
lasted throughout his life, and which affected all his works, seems to
indicate the peculiar bent of his early Christian education. Trithemius
concluded from a passage in his
History
(VII. 32) that Eusebius
was a pupil of the learned Dorotheus of Antioch, and Valesius,
Lightfoot and others are apparently inclined to accept his conclusion.
But, as Stroth remarks (
Eusebii Kirchengeschichte,
p. xix), all
that Eusebius says is that he had heard Dorotheus expound the
Scriptures in the church (
τούτου
μετρίως τὰς
γραφὰς ἐπὶ
τῆς
ἐκκλησίας
διηγουμένου
κατηκούσαμεν
), that is, that he had heard him preach. To conclude from
this statement that he was a pupil of Dorotheus is certainly quite
unwarranted.
Stroth’s suggestion that
he probably enjoyed the instruction of Meletius for seven years during
the persecution rests upon no good ground, for the passage which he
relies upon to sustain his opinion (
H. E.
VII. 32. 28) says only
that Eusebius “observed Meletius well” (
κατενοήσαμεν
) during those seven years.
In Cæsarea Eusebius was at
one time a presbyter of the church, as we may gather from his words in
the epistle to that church already referred to, where, in speaking of
the creed, he says, “As we believed and taught in the presbytery
and in the episcopate itself.” But the attempt to fix the date of
his ordination to that office is quite vain. It is commonly assumed
that he
became presbyter while Agapius was bishop of Cæsarea, and
this is not unlikely, though we possess no proof of it (upon Agapius
see below,
H. E.
VII. 32, note 39). In his
Vita
Constantini,
I. 19, Eusebius reports that he saw Constantine for
the first time in Cæsarea in the train of the Emperor Diocletian.
In his
Chron
. Eusebius reports that Diocletian made an
expedition against Egypt, which had risen in rebellion in the year 296
a.d.
, and Theophanes, in his
Chron.
,
says that Constantine accompanied him. It is probable therefore that it
was at this time that Eusebius first saw Constantine in Cæsarea,
when he was either on his way to Egypt, or on his way back (see
Tillemont’s
Hist. des Emp.,
IV. p. 34).
During these years of quiet,
before the great persecution of Diocletian, which broke out in 303
a.d.
, Eusebius’ life must have been a
very pleasant one. Pamphilus’ house seems to have been a sort of
rendezvous for Christian scholars, perhaps a regular divinity school;
for we learn from Eusebius’
Martyrs in Palestine
(Cureton’s edition, pp. 13 and 14) that he and a number of
others, including the martyr Apphianus, were living together in one
house at the time of the persecution, and that the latter was
instructed in the Scriptures by Pamphilus and acquired from him
virtuous habits and conduct. The great library of Pamphilus would make
his house a natural center for theological study, and the immense
amount of work which was done by him, or under his direction, in the
reproduction of copies of the Holy Scriptures, of Origen’s works
(see Jerome’s
de vir. ill.
75 and 81, and
contra
Ruf.
I. 9), and in other literary employments of the same kind,
makes it probable that he had gathered about him a large circle of
friends and students who assisted him in his labors and profited by his
counsel and instruction. Amidst these associations Eusebius passed his
early manhood, and the intellectual stimulus thus given him doubtless
had much to do with his future career. He was above all a literary man,
and remained such to the end of his life. The pleasant companionships
of these days, and the mutual interest and sympathy which must have
bound those fellow-students and fellow-disciples of Pamphilus very
close together, perhaps had much to do with that broad-minded spirit of
sympathy and tolerance which so characterized Eusebius in later years.
He was always as far as possible from the character of a recluse. He
seems ever to have been bound by very strong ties to the world itself
and to his fellow-men. Had his earlier days been filled with trials and
hardships, with the bitterness of disappointed hopes and unfulfilled
ambitions, with harsh experiences of others’ selfishness and
treachery, who shall say that the whole course of his life might not
have been changed, and his writings have exhibited an entirely
different spirit from that which is now one of their greatest charms?
Certainly he had during these early years in Cæsarea large
opportunities for cultivating that natural trait of admiration for
other men, which was often so strong as to blind him even to their
faults, and that natural kindness which led him to see good wherever it
existed in his Christian brethren. At the same time these associations
must have had considerable influence in fostering the apologetic
temper. The pursuits of the little circle were apparently exclusively
Christian, and in that day when Christianity stood always on its
defense, it would naturally become to them a sacred duty to contribute
to that defense and to employ all their energies in the task. It has
been remarked that the apologetic temper is very noticeable in
Eusebius’ writings. It is more than that; we may say indeed in
general terms that everything he wrote was an apology for the faith.
His
History
was written avowedly with an apologetic purpose, his
Chronicle
was composed with the same end in view. Even when
pronouncing a eulogy upon a deceased emperor he seized every possible
opportunity to draw from that emperor’s career, and from the
circumstances of his reign, arguments for the truth and grandeur of the
Christian religion. His natural temper of mind and his early training
may have had much to do with this habit of thought, but certainly those
years with Pamphilus and his friends in Cæsarea must have
emphasized and developed it.
Another characteristic which
Pamphilus and the circle that surrounded him doubtless did something to
develop in our author was a certain superiority to the trammels of mere
traditionalism, or we might perhaps better say that they in some
measure checked the opposite tendency of
slavishness to the traditional
which seems to have been natural to him. Pamphilus’ deep
reverence for Origen proclaims him at once superior to that kind of
narrow conservatism which led many men as learned and doubtless as
conscientious as himself to pass severe and unconditional condemnation
upon Origen and all his teaching. The effect of championing his cause
must have fostered in this little circle, which was a very hotbed of
Origenism, a contempt for the narrow and unfair judgments of mere
traditionalists, and must have led them to seek in some degree the
truth solely for its own sake, and to become in a measure careless of
its relation to the views of any school or church. It could hardly be
otherwise than that the free and fearless spirit of Origen should leave
its impress through his writings upon a circle of followers so devoted
to him as were these Cæsarean students. Upon the impressionable
Eusebius these influences necessarily operated. And yet he brought to
them no keen speculative powers, no deep originality such as Origen
himself possessed. His was essentially an acquisitive, not a productive
mind, and hence it was out of the question that he should become a
second Origen. It was quite certain that Origen’s influence over
him would weaken somewhat his confidence in the traditional as
such,—a confidence which is naturally great in such minds as
his,—but at the same time would do little to lessen the real
power of the past over him. He continued to get his truth from others,
from the great men of the past with whom he had lived and upon whose
thought he had feasted. All that he believed he had drawn from them; he
produced nothing new for himself, and his creed was a traditional
creed. And yet he had at the same time imbibed from his surroundings
the habit of questioning and even criticising the past, and, in spite
of his abiding respect for it, had learned to feel that the voice of
the many is not always the voice of truth, and that the widely and
anciently accepted is sometimes to be corrected by the clearer sight of
a single man. Though he therefore depended for all he believed so
completely upon the past, his associations had helped to free him from
a slavish adherence to all that a particular school had accepted, and
had made him in some small measure an eclectic in his relations to
doctrines and opinions of earlier generations. A notable instance of
this eclecticism on his part is seen in his treatment of the Apocalypse
of John. He felt the force of an almost universal tradition in favor of
its apostolic origin, and yet in the face of that he could listen to
the doubts of Dionysius, and could be led by his example, in a case
where his own dissatisfaction with the book acted as an incentive,
almost, if not quite, to reject it and to ascribe it to another John.
Instances of a similar mode of conduct on his part are quite numerous.
While he is always a staunch apologist for Christianity, he seldom, if
ever, degenerates into a mere partisan of any particular school or
sect.
One thing in fact which is
particularly noticeable in Eusebius’ works is the comparatively
small amount of time and space which he devotes to heretics. With his
wide and varied learning and his extensive acquaintance with the past,
he had opportunities for successful heresy hunting such as few
possessed, and yet he never was a heresy hunter in any sense. This is
surprising when we remember what a fascination this employment had for
so many scholars of his own age, and when we realize that his
historical tastes and talents would seem to mark him out as just the
man for that kind of work. May it not be that the lofty spirit of
Origen, animating that Cæsarean school, had something to do with
the happy fact that he became an apologist instead of a mere polemic,
that he chose the honorable task of writing a history of the Church
instead of anticipating Epiphanius’ Panarium?
It was not that he was not alive
to the evils of heresy. He shared with nearly all good church-men of
his age an intense aversion for those who, as he believed, had
corrupted the true Gospel of Christ. Like them he ascribed heresy to
the agency of the evil one, and was no more able than they to see any
good in a man whom he looked upon as a real heretic, or to do justice
in any degree to the error which he taught. His condemnations of
heretics in his
Church History
are most severe. Language is
hardly strong enough to express his aversion for them. And yet,
although he is thus most thoroughly the child of his age, the
difference between him and most of his contemporaries is very apparent.
He mentions these heretics only to dismiss them with dis
approval or
condemnation. He seldom, if ever, discusses and refutes their views.
His interests lie evidently in other directions; he is concerned with
higher things. A still more strongly marked difference between himself
and many churchmen of his age lies in his large liberality towards
those of his own day who differed with him in minor points of faith,
and his comparative indifference to the divergence of views between the
various parties in the Church. In all this we believe is to be seen not
simply the inherent nature of the man, but that nature as trained in
the school of Pamphilus, the disciple of Origen.