had replied to the tribune-notary, with titles and recognition of character, Augustin rather
resents by saying that the Catholic had treated the heretic too kindly and incautiously, and
bids Gaudentius consider what he had said at the Collation. Gaudentius proposes to remain
in the communion where the name of God and of his Christ is and where the Sacraments
are, and pleads for religious liberty against compulsion as to matters of faith; and concludes,
by another hand, with wishing him well and desiring his recession from the disquieting of
Christians. Augustin objects that Gaudentius had not reproduced the language of Dulcitius
correctly, and accuses the Donatists of holding the truth of baptism in the iniquity of human
error; he comments on their false eagerness for death; he responds to all the good wishes
for the tribune, but not that he should cease from correcting the heretics.
The second epistle of Gaudentius is mainly a protest from Scriptural grounds; against
persecution he brings forward the case of Gabinus, who, if bad, should not have been received
without correction, that is, baptism; but if innocent, why kill the innocent Donatists from
whom he came to you? The false rumor about Emeritus, as having turned Catholic, is an-
other instance of this persecution. The duty of a persecuted pastor is to be a doer of the law
and to lay down his life for the sheep; there is no place whither the persecuted may now flee;
the divine right of free will is restrained by the arbitrary laws of the emperor; persecution
is a note of the Church from the blessings attached to it by Christ and the apostles. The
peace of Christ invites the willing but does not compel the unwilling; a thing very different
from the war-bearing peace and the bloody unity which their oppressors present. We rejoice
in the hatred of the world; there is a martyr host of the apocalypse; Christians may yield up
their souls in testimony against sacrilege, as Razius did. He begs Dulcitius to turn to the
few who have the solidity and not the semblance of truth. God gave prophets not kings to
402
teach the people: the Saviour sent fishermen not soldiers. God never needs the aid of sol-
diers. Gaudentius charges the Catholics with coveting the Donatist possessions. The farewell
is in another handwriting, in which he wishes Dulcitius well, and advises him to pursue a
lenient and temperate course.
The points of Augustin’s reply are in no way different save form from those so constantly
presented, unless there be an increase of roughness and a more hardened idea of the Church’s
right to use coercion. As to Gabinus, the Church’s course with regard to him is a vindication
of the right to receive a convert without rebaptism: in communion with charity and unity
he received the profit of that rite which had been administered among the Donatists. In the
case of Emeritus, Augustin confesses that the rumor of his having turned Catholic was false;
but Emeritus came to Cæsarea of his own will; he came to the Church where a multitude
was present; he could say nothing for his or his party’s defense; he kept quiet. The argument
against suicide from the case of Razius is well made; he died rather in suffering for the state;
and besides the narrative does not commend the deed, but only states it; then too the books
have not the weight that the Law, the Prophets and the Psalms carry with them. The plea
685
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.