brief temporal reward, but of unending and eternal bliss. What, then, will the advocates
and apologists of these gods say in their defence, when charged with the blood of these
Saguntines; for they are professedly worshipped and invoked for this very purpose of securing
prosperity in this fleeting and transitory life? Can anything be said but what was alleged in
the case of Regulus’ death? For though there is a difference between the two cases, the one
being an individual, the other a whole community, yet the cause of destruction was in both
cases the keeping of their plighted troth. For it was this which made Regulus willing to return
to his enemies, and this which made the Saguntines unwilling to revolt to their enemies.
Does, then, the keeping of faith provoke the gods to anger? Or is it possible that not only
individuals, but even entire communities, perish while the gods are propitious to them?
Let our adversaries choose which alternative they will. If, on the one hand, those gods are
enraged at the keeping of faith, let them enlist perjured persons as their worshippers. If, on
the other hand, men and states can suffer great and terrible calamities, and at last perish
while favored by the gods, then does their worship not produce happiness as its fruit. Let
those, therefore, who suppose that they have fallen into distress because their religious
worship has been abolished, lay aside their anger; for it were quite possible that did the gods
not only remain with them, but regard them with favor, they might yet be left to mourn an
unhappy lot, or might, even like Regulus and the Saguntines, be horribly tormented, and at
last perish miserably.
145
Of the Destruction of the Saguntines, Who Received No Help from the Roman…