The above account of Lucian is based on that of
Harnack, Dogmg. ii. 184, sqq. It is at once in harmony with all
our somewhat scanty data (Alexander, Epiphanius, Philostorgius, and the
fragment of his last confession of faith preserved by Rufin. in Eus.
H. E. ix. 9, Routh, Rell. iv. pp. 5–7, from which
Harnack rightly starts) and is the only one which accounts for the
phenomena of the rise of Arianism. We find a number of leading
Churchmen in agreement with Arius, but in no way dependent on him. They
are Eusebius of Nicomedia, Maris, Theognis, Athanasius of Anazarba,
Menophantus; all Lucianists. The first Arian writer, Asterius (see
below), is a Lucianist. (The Egyptian bishops Secundus and Theonas
cannot be put down to any school; we do not know their history; but
they are distinguished from the Lucianists by Philost. ii. 3.) It has
been urged that, although Arius brought away heresy from the school of
Lucian, yet he was not the only one that did so. True; but then the
heresy was all of the same kind (list of pupils of Lucian in
Philost. ii. 14, iii. 15). Aetius, the founder of logical
ultra-Arianism and teacher of Eunomius, was taught the exegesis of the
New Testament by the Lucianists Athanasius of Anazarba and Antony of
Tarsus, of the Old by the Lucianist Leontius. This fairly covers the
area of Arianism proper. But it may be noted that some Origenists of
the ‘left wing,’ whose theology emphasized the
subordination, and vacillated as to the eternity of the Son, would find
little to shock them in Arianism (Eusebius of Cæsarea, Paulinus of
Tyre), while on the other hand there are traces of a Lucianist
‘right wing,’ men like Asterius,
who while essentially Arian, made concessions to the
‘conservative’ position chiefly by emphasising the cosmic
mediation of the Word and His ‘exact likeness’ to the
Father ἀπαράλλακτον
εἰκόνα, which
an Arian would be prepared to admit as the result of the προκοπή. (See below, §6, on the Creeds of 341). I cannot regard
Asterius as a ‘semi-Arian;’ the only grounds for it
are the above phrase and the statement (Lib. Syn.) that he
attended the Council of 341 with the Conservative Dianius. But Asterius
was as ready to compromise with conservatism as he had formerly been
with heathenism, and his anxiety for a bishopric would carry him to
even greater lengths in order to attend a council under influential
patronage.. The Theology of the Eastern Church was
suffering from the effort to assimilate the Origenist theology: it
could not do so without eliminating the underlying and unifying idea of
Origenism; this done, the overwhelming influence of the great teacher
remained, while dissonant fragments of his system, vaguely comprehended
in many cases, permeated some here, some there The
letter of Alexander to his namesake of Byzantium in Thdt. i. 4, cannot
be exempted from this generalisation..
Meanwhile the school of Lucian had a method and a system; they knew
their own minds, and relied on reason and exegesis. This was the secret
of their power. Had Arius never existed, Arianism must have tried its
strength under such conditions. But the age was ready for Arius; and
Arius was ready. The system of Arius was in
effect that of Lucian: its formulation appears to have been as much the
work of Asterius as of Arius himself. (Cf. p. 155, §8, ὁ δὲ ᾽Αρ.
μεταγράψας
δέδωκε τοῖς
ἰδίοις. The extant writings of
Arius are his letters to Eus. Nic. and to Alexander, preserved by
Theodoret and Epiph. Hær. 69, and the extracts from the
‘Thalia’ in Ath., pp. 308–311, 457, 458; also the
‘confession’ in Socr. i. 26, Soz. ii. 27. Cf. also
references to his dicta in Ath. pp. 185, 229, &c.) Arius started
from the idea of God and the predicate ‘Son.’
God is above all things uncreated, or unoriginate, ἀγέν[ν]ητος, (the
ambiguity of the derivatives of γεννᾶσθαι and
γενέσθαι are a
very important element in the controversy. See p. 475, note 5, and
Lightfoot, Ignat. ii. p. 90 sqq.) Everything else is
created, γενητόν. The name
‘Son’ implies an act of procreation. Therefore,
before such act, there was no Son, nor was God properly speaking a
Father. The Son is not coeternal with Him. He was originated by the
Father’s will, as indeed were all things. He is, then, τῶν
γενητῶν, He came into being
from non-existence (ἐξ οὐκ
ὄντων), and before that did not exist
(οὐκ ἦν
πρὶν
γένηται). But His relation
to God differs from that of the Universe generally. Created nature
cannot bear the awful touch of bare Deity. God therefore created the
Son that He in turn might be the agent in the Creation of the
Universe—‘created Him as the beginning of His ways,’
(Prov. viii. 22, LXX.). This being so, the nature of the
Son was in the essential point of ἀγεννησία
unlike that of the Father; (ξένος τοῦ
υἱοῦ κατ᾽
οὐσίαν ὁ
Πατὴρ ὅτι
ἄναρχος): their substances
(ὑποστάσεις)
are ἀνεπίμικτοι,—have
nothing in common. The Son therefore does not possess the fundamental
property of sonship, identity of nature with the Father. He is a Son by
Adoption, not by Nature; He has advanced by moral probation to be Son,
even to be μονογενὴς
θεός (Joh. i. 14). He is not the eternal Λόγος, reason, of God, but
a Word (and God has spoken many): but yet He is the Word
by grace; is no longer, what He is by nature, subject to
change. He cannot know the Father, much less make Him known to others.
Lastly, He dwells in flesh, not in full human nature (see above, p.
xxviii. and note 2). The doctrine of Arius as to the Holy Spirit is not
recorded, but probably He was placed between the Son and the other
κτίσματα (yet see
Harnack ii. 199, note 2).