There
is introduced at these words in the text of the Paris Edition the
following “Explicatio,” in Greek. “Here it is
manifest that the father means by the ‘purging fire’ the
torments and agonies suffered by those who having sinned have not
completed a worthy and adequate repentance, according to the Gospel
parable of the Rich Man and Lazarus. For it is clear that he is
thinking of this parable when he says, ‘either purged in
fire’ (i.e. the Rich Man), ‘or refreshed with the
dew of blessing’ (i.e. Lazarus). But that sentence of the
Judgment, ‘They shall go, these into everlasting punishment, but
the just into life everlasting,’ has no place as yet in
these sufferings.” In other words, the commentator sees here the
doctrine of Purgatory, as held by the Roman Church. And when we compare
the other passages in Gregory about the “cleansing fire,”
especially that De Animâ et Resurrectione,
247 B, we shall see that he contemplates the judgment (“the
incorruptible tribunal”) as coming not only after the
Resurrection, but also after the chastising process. Not till the
Judgment will the moral value of each life be revealed; the
chastising is a purely natural process. But then the belief in a
Judgment coming after everything rather contradicts the Universalism
with which he has been charged, for what necessity would there be for
it, if the chastising was successful in every instance? With regard to
the nature of this “fire,” it is spiritual or material with
him according to the context. The invisible natures will be punished
with the one, the visible (i.e. the World) with the other:
although this destruction is not always preserved by him. See E.
Moeller (on Gregory’s Doctrine on Human Nature), p.
100.