Notwithstanding this, these canons, and particularly the
fifty mentioned by Dionysius, did not entirely fall into discredit in
the West; but rather they came to be received, because the first
collection of Dionysius was considered of great authority. They
also passed into other collections, and particularly into that of the
pseudo-Isidore; and in 1054, Humbert, legate of Pope Leo IX., made the
following declaration: Clementis libel, id est itinerarium
Petri Apostoli et Canones Apostolorum numerantur inter apocrypha,
Exceptis Capitulis
Quisquaginta, quæ decreverunt regulis
orthodoxis adjungenda. Gratian also, in his decree, borrowed
from the fifty Apostolic Canons, and they gradually obtained the force
of laws. But many writers, especially Hincmar of Rheims, like
Dionysius Exiguus, raised doubts upon the apostolical origin of these
canons. From the sixteenth century the opinion has been universal
that these documents are not authentic; with the exception, however, of
the French Jesuit Turrianus, who endeavoured to defend their
genuineness, as well as the authenticity of the pseudo-Isidorian
decrees. According to the Centuriators of Magdeburg, it was
especially Gabriel d’Aubespine, Bishop of Orleans, the celebrated
Archbishop Peter de Marca, and the Anglican Beveridge, who proved that
they were not really compiled by the Apostles, but were made partly in
the second and chiefly in the third century. Beveridge considered
this collection to be a repertory of ancient canons given by synods in
the second and third centuries. In opposition to them, the
Calvinist Dallæus (Daillé) regarded it as the work of a
forger who lived in the fifth and sixth centuries; but Beveridge
refuted him so convincingly, that from that time his opinion, with some
few modifications, has been that of all the learned.