A. I will requite like with like, and will show that,
according to you, the little epistle of the Evangelist contradicts
itself. For, if whosoever is begotten of God sinneth not because His
seed abideth in him, and he cannot sin, because he is born of God, how
is it that the writer says in the same place: 1 John i. 8.“If we say that we have no sin, we
deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us?” You cannot
explain. You hesitate and are confused. Listen to the same Evangelist
telling us that 1 John i. 9.“If we
confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins, and
to cleanse us from all unrighteousness.” We are then righteous
when we confess that we are sinners, and our righteousness depends not
upon our own merits, but on the mercy of God, as the Holy Scripture
says, Prov. xviii. 17, Vulg. nearly.“The righteous man
accuseth himself when he beginneth to speak,” and elsewhere, Is. xliii. 26, Sept.“Tell thy sins that thou mayest
be justified.” Rom. xi. 32.“God
hath shut up all under sin, that He may have mercy upon all.” And
the highest righteousness of man is this—whatever virtue he may
be able to acquire, not to think it his own, but the gift of God. He
then who is born of God does not sin, so long as the seed of God
remains in him, and he cannot sin, because he is born of God. But
seeing that, while the householder slept, an enemy sowed tares, and
that when we know not, a sower by night scatters in the Lord’s
field darnel and wild oats among the good corn, this parable of the
householder in the Gospel should excite our fears. He cleanses his
floor, and gathers the wheat into his garner, but leaves the chaff to
be scattered by the winds, or burned by the fire. And so we read in
Jeremiah, Jer. xxiii. 28. “What is the chaff to the
wheat? saith the Lord.” The chaff, moreover, is separated from
the wheat at the end of the world, a proof that, while we are in the
mortal body, chaff is mixed with the wheat. But if you object, and ask
why did the Apostle say “and he cannot sin, because he is born of
God,” I reply by asking you what becomes of the reward of his
choice? For if a man does not sin because he cannot sin, free will is
destroyed, and goodness cannot possibly be due to his efforts, but must
be part of a nature unreceptive of evil.