The fragments of this epistle, preserved by Eusebius in this and
the next chapter, are printed with a commentary by Routh, in his
Rel. Sacræ. I. p. 285 sq., and an English translation is
given in the Ante-Nicene Fathers, VIII. p. 778 sq. There can be
no doubt as to the early date and reliability of the epistle. It bears
no traces of a later age, and contains little of the marvelous, which
entered so largely into the spurious martyrologies of a later day. Its
genuineness is in fact questioned by no one so far as I am aware. It is
one of the most beautiful works of the kind which we have, and well
deserves the place in his History which Eusebius has accorded
it. We may assume that we have the greater part of the epistle in so
far as it related to the martyrdoms. Ado, in his Mart., asserts
that forty-eight suffered martyrdom, and even gives a list of their
names. It is possible that he gained his information from the epistle
itself, as given in its complete form in Eusebius’ Collection
of Martyrdoms; but I am inclined to think rather that Eusebius has
mentioned if not all, at least the majority of the martyrs referred to
in the epistle, and that therefore Ado’s list is largely
imaginary. Eusebius’ statement, that a “multitude”
suffered signifies nothing, for μυρία was a very
indefinite word, and might be used of a dozen or fifteen as easily as
of forty-eight. To speak of the persecution as “wholesale,”
so that it was not safe for any Christian to appear out of doors
(Lightfoot, Ignatius, Vol. I. p. 499), is rather overstating the
case. The persecution must, of course, whatever its extent, appear
terrible to the Christians of the region; but a critical examination of
the epistle itself will hardly justify the extravagant statements which
are commonly made in regard to the magnitude and severity of the
persecution. It may have been worse than any single persecution that
had preceded it, but sinks into insignificance when compared with those
which took place under Decius and Diocletian.
It is interesting to
notice that this epistle was especially addressed to the Christians of
Asia and Phrygia. We know that Southern Gaul contained a great many
Asia Minor people, and that the intercourse between the two districts
was very close. Irenæus, and other prominent Christians of Gaul,
in the second and following centuries, were either natives of Asia
Minor, or had pursued their studies there; and so the Church of the
country always bore a peculiarly Greek character, and was for some
centuries in sympathy and in constant communication with the Eastern
Church. Witness, for instance, the rise and spread of semi-Pelagianism
there in the fifth century,—a simple reproduction in its main
features of the anthropology of the Eastern Church. Doubtless, at the
time this epistle was written, there were many Christians in Lyons and
Vienne, who had friends and relations in the East, and hence it was
very natural that an epistle should be sent to what might be called, in
a sense, the mother churches. Valesius expressed the opinion that
Irenæus was the author of this epistle; and he has been followed
by many other scholars. It is possible that he was, but there are no
grounds upon which to base the opinion, except the fact that
Irenæus lived in Lyons, and was, or afterward became, a writer. On
the other hand, it is significant that no tradition has connected the
letter with Irenæus’ name, and that even Eusebius has no
thought of such a connection. In fact, Valesius’ opinion seems to
me in the highest degree improbable.