TO THE KING OF FRANCE. 15
and wine in the Eucharist does not cease but remains, just
as the nature and substance of man remains united to the
Godhead in the Lord Jesus Christ." This boundary they
pass in pretending that, as soon as the words of our Lord
are pronounced, the substance of bread and wine ceases, and
is transubstantiated into body and blood.
They were Fathers, who, as they exhibited only one Eu
charist to the whole Church,1 and kept back from it the
profane and flagitious ; so they, in the severest terms, cen
sured all those2 who, being present, did not communicate.
How far have they removed these landmarks, in filling not
churches only, but also private houses, with their masses,
admitting all and sundry to be present, each the more will
ingly the more largely he pays, however wicked and im
pure he may be, — not inviting any one to faith in Christ
and faithful communion in the sacraments, but rather vend
ing their own work for the grace and merits of Christ !3
There were two Fathers, the one of whom decided that
those were to be excluded altogether from partaking of
Christ's sacred supper,4 who, contented with communion in one kind, abstained from the other; while the other Fa
ther strongly contends5 that the blood of the Lord ought
not to be denied to the Christian people, who, in confessing
him, are enjoined to shed their own blood. These land
marks, also, they removed, when, by an unalterable law, they
ordered the very thing which the former Father punished with
excommunication, and the latter condemned for a valid
reason.
It was a Father who pronounced it rashness,6 in an ob
scure question, to decide in either way without clear and
1 x. Chrys. in 1. cap. Ephes.
8 xi. Calixt. Papa, De Consecrat. dist. 2.
3 Instead of the whole passage, beginning at bottom of p. 14, " It is
a Father who testifies," &c. the Ed. 1536 has the following sentence : —
' Ex patribus erat qui negavit in sacramento ccenae esse verum corpus
sed mysterium duntaxat corporis ; sic enim ad verbum loquitur." On the margin reference is made to the author of an unfinished Tract on
Matthew, forming the llth Homil. among the works of Chrysostom.
4 xii. Gelas. can. Comperimus, De Consec. dist. 2.
5 xiii. Cypr. Epist. 2, lib. i. De Lapsis.
6 xiv. August, lib. ii. De Peccat. Mer. cap. ult.