lutely no sin, either original or personal, on account of which death could be supposed to
be merited by Him, since He paid on our behalf that which was not on His own account
due by Him, in whom the prince of this world, who had the power of death, found noth-
521
ing2695—and there is nothing unreasonable in the supposition that He who created a soul
for the first man should create a soul for Himself; or if the soul of Christ be derived from
Adam’s soul He in assuming it to Himself, cleansed it so that when He came into this world
He was born of the Virgin perfectly free from sin either actual or transmitted. If, however,
the souls of men are not derived from that one soul, and it is only by the flesh that original
sin is transmitted from Adam, the Son of God created a soul for Himself, as He creates souls
for all other men, but He united it not to sinful flesh, but to the “likeness of sinful flesh.”2696
For He took, indeed, from the Virgin the true substance of flesh; not, however, “sinful flesh,”
for it was neither begotten nor conceived through carnal concupiscence, but mortal, and
capable of change in the successive stages of life, as being like unto sinful flesh in all points,
sin excepted.
20. Therefore, whatever be the true theory concerning the origin of souls,—and on this
I feel it would be rash for me to pronounce, meanwhile, any opinion beyond utterly rejecting
the theory which affirms that each soul is thrust into the body which it inhabits as into a
prison, where it expiates some former actions of its own of which I know nothing, it is certain,
regarding the soul of Christ, not only that it is, according to the nature of all souls, immortal,
but also that it was neither put to death by sin nor punished by condemnation, the only two
ways in which death can be understood as experienced by the soul; and therefore it could
not be said of Christ that with reference to the soul He was “quickened in the spirit.” For
He was quickened in that in which He had been put to death; this, therefore, is spoken with
reference to His flesh, for His flesh received life again when the soul returned to it, as it also
had died when the soul departed. He was therefore said to be “put to death in the flesh,”
because He experienced death only in the flesh, but “quickened in the spirit,” because by
the operation of that Spirit in which He was wont to come and preach to whom He would,
that same flesh in which He came to men was quickened and rose from the grave.
21. Wherefore, passing now to the words which we find farther on concerning unbeliev-
ers, “Who shall give account to Him who is ready to judge the quick and the dead,” there
is no necessity for our understanding the “dead” here to be those who have departed from
the body. For it may be that the apostle intended by the word “dead” to denote unbelievers,
as being spiritually dead, like those of whom it was said, “Let the dead bury their dead,”2697
and by the word “living” to denote those who believe in Him, having not heard in vain the
2695 John xiv. 30.
2696 Rom. viii. 3.
2697 Matt. viii. 22.
1110
To Evodius