Eusebius follows what was undoubtedly the oldest tradition in
making Evodius the first bishop of Antioch, and Ignatius the second
(see above, chap. 22, note 2). Granting the genuineness of the shorter
Greek recension of the Ignatian epistles (to be mentioned below), the
fact that Ignatius was bishop of the church of Antioch in Syria is
established by Ep. ad Rom. 9, compared with ad Smyr. 11
and ad Polycarp. 7. If the genuineness of the epistles be
denied, these passages seem to prove at least his connection with the
church of Antioch and his influential position in it, for otherwise the
forgery of the epistles under his name would be
inconceivable.
There are few more prominent
figures in early Church history than Ignatius, and yet there are few
about whom we have less unquestioned knowledge. He is known in history
pre-eminently as a martyr. The greater part of his life is buried in
complete obscurity. It is only as a man condemned to death for his
profession of Christianity that he comes out into the light, and it is
with him in this character and with the martyrdom which followed that
tradition has busied itself. There are extant various Acts of the
Martyrdom of St. Ignatius which contain detailed accounts of his death,
but these belong to the fourth and subsequent centuries, are quite
contradictory in their statements, and have been conclusively proved to
be utterly unreliable and to furnish no trustworthy information on the
subject in hand. From writers before Eusebius we have but four notices
of Ignatius (Polycarp’s Ep. ad Phil. 9, 13;
Irenæus’ Adv. Hær. V. 18. 3, quoted below;
Origen, Prol. in Cant., and Hom. VI. in Luc.). These
furnish us with very little information. If the notice in
Polycarp’s epistle be genuine (and though it has been widely
attacked, there is no good reason to doubt it), it furnishes us with
our earliest testimony to the martyrdom of a certain Ignatius and to
the existence of epistles written by him. Irenæus does not name
Ignatius, but he testifies to the existence of the Epistle to the
Romans which bears his name, and to the martyrdom of the author of that
epistle. Origen informs us that Ignatius, the author of certain
epistles, was second bishop of the church of Antioch and suffered
martyrdom at Rome. Eusebius, in the present chapter, is the first one
to give us an extended account of Ignatius, and his account contains no
information beyond what he might have drawn from the Ignatian epistles
themselves as they lay before him, except the statements, already made
by Origen, that Ignatius was the second bishop of Antioch and suffered
martyrdom at Rome. The former statement must have rested on a
tradition, at least in part, independent of the epistles (for they
imply only the fact of his Antiochian episcopacy, without specifying
the time); the latter might have arisen from the epistles themselves
(in which it is clearly stated that the writer is on his way to Rome to
suffer martyrdom), for of course it would be natural to assume that his
expectation was realized.
The connection in which Eusebius
records the martyrdom implies that he believed that it took place in
the reign of Trajan, and in his Chronicle he gives precise dates
for the beginning of his episcopate (the 212th Olympiad, i.e.
69–72 a.d.) and for his martyrdom (the
tenth year of Trajan, i.e. 107 a.d.).
Subsequent notices of Ignatius are either quite worthless or are based
solely upon the epistles themselves or upon the statements of Eusebius.
The information, independent of the epistles, which has reached us from
the time of Eusebius or earlier, consequently narrows itself down to
the report that Ignatius was second bishop of Antioch, and that he was
bishop from about 70 to 107 a.d. The former
date may be regarded as entirely unreliable. Even were it granted that
there could have been a bishop at the head of the Antiochian church at
so early a date (and there is no warrant for such a supposition), it
would nevertheless be impossible to place any reliance upon the date
given by Eusebius, as it is impossible to place any reliance upon the
dates given for the so-called bishops of other cities during the first
century (see Bk. IV. chap. 1, note 1). But the date of Ignatius’
martyrdom given by Eusebius seems at first sight to rest upon a more
reliable tradition, and has been accepted by many scholars as correct.
Its accuracy, however, has been impugned, especially by Zahn and
Lightfoot, who leave the date of Ignatius’ death uncertain,
claiming simply that he died under Trajan; and by Harnack, who puts his
death into the reign of Hadrian. We shall refer to this again further
on. Meanwhile, since the information which we have of Ignatius,
independent of the Ignatian epistles, is so small in amount, we are
obliged to turn to those epistles for our chief knowledge of his life
and character.
But at this point a difficulty
confronts us. There are extant three different recensions of epistles
ascribed to Ignatius. Are any of them genuine, and if so, which? The
first, or longer Greek recension, as it is called, consists of fifteen
epistles, which were first published in the fifteenth and sixteenth
centuries. Of these fifteen, eight are clearly spurious, and seven are
at least largely interpolated. The genuineness of the former and the
integrity of the latter now find no defenders among scholars. The
second, or shorter Greek recension, contains seven of the fifteen
epistles of the longer recension, in a much shorter form. Their titles
are the same that are given by Eusebius in this chapter. They were
first discovered and published in the seventeenth century. The third,
or Syriac recension, contains three of these seven epistles (to
Polycarp, to the Ephesians, and to the Romans), in a still shorter
form, and was discovered in the present century. Since its discovery,
opinions have been divided between it and the shorter Greek recension;
but the defense of the genuineness of the latter by Zahn and Lightfoot
may be regarded as finally settling the matter, and establishing the
originality of the shorter Greek recension as over against that
represented by the Syriac version. The former, therefore, alone comes
into consideration in discussing the genuineness of the Ignatian
epistles. Their genuineness is still stoutly denied by some; but the
evidence in their favor, external and internal, is too strong to be set
aside; and since the appearance of Lightfoot’s great work, candid
scholars almost unanimously admit that the question is settled, and
their genuineness triumphantly established. The great difficulties
which have stood in the way of the acceptance of the epistles are,
first and chiefly, the highly developed form of church government which
they reveal; and secondly, the attacks upon heresy contained in them.
Both of these characteristics seem to necessitate a date later than the
reign of Trajan, the traditional time of Ignatius’ martyrdom.
Harnack regards these two difficulties as very serious, if not
absolutely fatal to the supposition that the epistles were written
during the reign of Trajan; but in a very keen tract, entitled Die
Zeit des Ignatius (Leipzig, 1878), he has endeavored to show that
the common tradition that Ignatius suffered martyrdom under Trajan is
worthless, and he therefore brings the martyrdom down into the reign of
Hadrian, and thus does away with most of the internal difficulties
which beset the acceptance of the epistles. Whether or not
Harnack’s explanation of Eusebius’ chronology of the
Antiochian bishops be accepted as correct (and the number of its
adherents is not great), he has, at least, shown that the tradition
that Ignatius suffered martyrdom under Trajan is not as strong as it
has been commonly supposed to be, and that it is possible to question
seriously its reliability. Lightfoot, who discusses Harnack’s
theory at considerable length (II. p. 450–469), rejects it, and
maintains that Ignatius died sometime during the reign of Trajan,
though, with Zahn and Harnack, he gives up the traditional date of 107
a.d., which is found in the Chronicle
of Eusebius, and has been very commonly accepted as reliable.
Lightfoot, however, remarks that the genuineness of the epistles is
much more certain than the chronology of Ignatius, and that, therefore,
if it is a question between the rejection of the epistles and the
relegation of Ignatius’ death to the reign of Hadrian (which he,
however, denies), the latter alternative must be chosen without
hesitation. A final decision upon this knotty point has not yet been,
and perhaps never will be, reached; but Harnack’s theory that the
epistles were written during the reign of Hadrian deserves even more
careful consideration than it has yet received.
Granting the genuineness of the
Ignatian epistles, we are still in possession of no great amount of
information in regard to his life. We know from them only that he was
bishop of the church of Antioch in Syria, and had been condemned to
martyrdom, and that he was, at the time of their composition, on his
way to Rome to suffer death in the arena. His character and opinions,
however, are very clearly exhibited in his writings. To quote from
Schaff, “Ignatius stands out in history as the ideal of a
Catholic martyr, and as the earliest advocate of the hierarchical
principle in both its good and its evil points. As a writer, he is
remarkable for originality, freshness, and force of ideas, and for
terse, sparkling, and sententious style; but in apostolic simplicity
and soundness, he is inferior to Clement and Polycarp, and presents a
stronger contrast to the epistles of the New Testament. Clement shows
the calmness, dignity, and governmental wisdom of the Roman character.
Ignatius glows with the fire and impetuosity of the Greek and Syrian
temper which carries him beyond the bounds of sobriety. He was a very
uncommon man, and made a powerful impression upon his age. He is the
incarnation, as it were, of the three closely connected ideas: the
glory of martyrdom, the omnipotence of episcopacy, and the hatred of
heresy and schism. Hierarchical pride and humility, Christian charity
and churchly exclusiveness, are typically represented in
Ignatius.”
The literature on
Ignatius and the Ignatian controversy is very extensive. The principal
editions to be consulted are Cureton’s The Ancient Syriac
Version of the Epistles of St. Ignatius to St. Polycarp, the Ephesians,
and the Romans, with English translation and notes (the editio
princeps of the Syriac version), London and Berlin, 1845;
Zahn’s Ignatii et Polycarpi Epistulæ, Martyria
fragmenta, Lips. 1876 (Patrum Apostolicorum Opera, ed.
Gebhardt, Harnack, and Zahn, Vol. II); Bishop Lightfoot’s St.
Ignatius and St. Polycarp (The Apostolic Fathers, Part II.),
London, 1885. This edition (in two volumes) is the most complete and
exhaustive edition of Ignatius’ epistles which has yet appeared,
and contains a very full and able discussion of all questions connected
with Ignatius and his writings. It contains the text of the longer
Greek recension and of the Syriac version, in addition to that of the
seven genuine epistles, and practically supersedes all earlier
editions. An English translation of all the epistles of Ignatius
(Syriac and Greek, in both recensions) is given in the Ante-Nicene
Fathers (Am. ed.), Vol. I. pp. 45–126. The principal
discussions which it is necessary to refer to here are those of
Lightfoot in his edition of the Ignatian epistles just referred to;
Zahn’s Ignatius von Antiochien, Gotha, 1873 (very full and
able); Harnack’s Die Zeit des Ignatius, Leipzig, 1878; and
the reviews of Lightfoot’s edition contributed by Harnack to the
Expositor, December, 1885, January and March, 1886. For a more
extended list of works on the subject, and for a brief review of the
whole matter, see Schaff’s Church History, Vol. II. p.
651–664.