19-21. In the preceding verses St John has shewn what love brings to the believer. He now lays open the obligation which it imposes upon him. The love which is inspired by God must be manifested towards the brethren according to His commandment.
¹⁹ We love, because he first loved us. If any one say I love God, and hate his brother, he is a liar; for he that loveth not his brother whom he hath seen cannot love God, whom he hath not seen. And this commandment have we from him that he who loved God love his brother also.
19. Ἡμεῖς ἀγ.] Nos ergo diligamus invicem V. The absence of any title of
20 — ὅτι ℵ.
address and the addition of the personal pronoun distinguish this phrase from v. 7 ἀγαπητοί, ἀγαπῶμεν ἀλλήλους, and seem to shew clearly that the verb is an indicative (We love), and not a conjunctive (Let us love). It is worthy of notice that the Latin and Pesh. Syriac which give the hortatory rendering add a connecting particle as many Greek authorities (οὖν).
The indicative also suits the context better. The fact of love is assumed, and then it is shewn in its workings. Comp. iii. 16.
According to the true reading the idea of love is left in its full breadth without any definition of the object, as God (αὐτόν or τὸν θεόν), or man (invicem V.). This is required by what follows, where it is falsely urged that the claims of 'love' can be satisfied by bare 'love of God.' ὅτι αὐτὸς πρ. ἦγ. ἡμ.] Comp. v. 10. The thought here is different from that in the former context. There love was regarded in its essence: here it is regarded in its personal exercise. Our love is the light kindled by the love of God. And the divine origin of love determines its character and also assures its stability. Comp. John xv. 16.
πρῶτος ἦγ.] prior dilexit V. Comp. Rom. v. 8. The priority of the love of God to all love on man's part which is accentuated here, is a ground for the spontaneous exercise of love on the part of the believer towards those who do not seem to invite it.
20, 21. The consequences of the preceding statement are traced out in two ways from the nature of the case (v. 20), and from the direct commandment of God (v. 21). The love of God, which is assumed to exist at least in profession, must include love of the brethren, and so God has Himself enjoined. The thought of loving God is here first discussed (comp. v. 10).