Against III.—The sense of the terms used is misty and obscure. Who
needs to be told that there is no difference between conjunction and
concurrence? The concurrence is a concurrence of the separated parts;
and the conjunction is a conjunction of the distinguished parts. The
very clever author of the phrases has laid down things that agree as
though they disagreed. It is wrong, he says, to conjoin the hypostases
by conjunction; they ought to be conjoined by concurrence, and that a
natural concurrence. Possibly he states this not knowing what he says;
if he knows, he blasphemes. Nature has a compulsory force and is
involuntary; as for instance, if I say we are naturally hungry, we do
not feel hunger of free-will but of necessity; and assuredly paupers
would have left off begging if the power of ceasing to be hungry had
lain in their own will; we are naturally thirsty; we naturally sleep;
we naturally breathe; and all these actions, I repeat, belong to the
category of the involuntary, and he who is no longer capable of them
necessarily ceases to exist. If then the concurrence in union of the
form of God and the form of a servant was natural, then God the Word
was united to the form of the servant under the compulsion of
necessity, and not because He put in force His loving kindness, and the
Lawgiver of the Universe will be found to be a follower of the laws of
necessity. Not thus have we been taught by the blessed Paul; on the
contrary, we have been taught that He took the form of a servant and
“emptied Himself;” Phil. ii. 7 and the
expression “emptied Himself” indicates the voluntary act.
If then He was united by purpose and will to the nature assumed from
us, the addition of the term natural is superfluous. It suffices to
confess the union, and union is understood of things distinguished, for
if there were no division an union could never be apprehended. The
apprehension then of the union implies previous apprehension of the
division. How then can he say that the hypostases or natures ought not
to be divided? He knows all the while that the hypostasis of God the
Word was perfect before the ages; and that the form of the servant
which was assumed by It was perfect; and this is the reason why he said
hypostases and not hypostasis. If therefore either nature is perfect,
and both came together, it is obvious that after the form of God had
taken the form of a servant, piety compels us to confess one son and
Christ; while to speak of the united hypostases or natures as two, so
far from being absurd, follows the necessity of the case. For if in the
case of the one man we divide the natures, and call the mortal nature
body, but the immortal nature soul, and both man, much more consonant
is it with right reason to recognise the properties alike of the God
who took and of the man who was taken. We find the blessed Paul
dividing the one man into two where he says in one passage,
“Though our outward man perish yet the inward man is
renewed,” 2 Cor. iv. 16 and in another
“For I delight in the law of God after the inward man.” Rom. vii. 22 And again “that Christ may dwell in
the inner man.” Ephes. iii.
17.
Greek as in A.V. “in your hearts.” Now if the apostle
divides the natural conjunction of the synchronous natures, with what
reason can the man who describes the mixture to us by means of other
terms indite us as impious when we divide the properties of the natures
of the everlasting God and of the man assumed at the end of
days?