The council held at Alexandria
in the year 362, during the brief restoration of S. Athanasius, shows
us at once the point of contrast and the substantial agreement between
the Western school, with which S. Athanasius himself is in this matter
to be reckoned, and the Eastern theologians to whom has been given the
title of “Neo-Nicene.” The question at issue was one of
language, not of belief; it turned upon the sense to be attached to the
word ὑπόστασις. The Easterns, following a use of the term which may be
traced perhaps to the influence of Origen, employed the word in the
sense of the Latin “Persona,” and spoke of the Three
Persons as τρεῖς
ὑποστάσεις, whereas the Latins employed the term
“hypostasis” as equivalent to
“sub-stantia,” to express what the Greeks
called οὐσία,—the one Godhead of the Three Persons. With the Latins
agreed the older school of the orthodox Greek theologians, who applied
to the Three Persons the phrase τρία
πρόσωπα,
speaking of the Godhead as μία
ὑπόστασις. This phrase, in the eyes of the newer Nicene school, was
suspected of Sabellianism It is to
be noted further that the use of the terms “Persona”
and πρόσωπον by those who avoided the phrase τρεῖς
ὑποστάσεις
no doubt assisted in the formation of this suspicion.
At the same time the Nicene anathema favoured the sense of ὑπόστασις as equivalent to οὐσία, and so
appeared to condemn the Eastern use., while on the other
hand the Westerns were inclined to regard the Eastern phrase
τρεῖς
ὑποστάσεις
as implying tritheism. The synodal letter sets forth
to us the means by which the fact of substantial agreement between the
two schools was brought to light, and the understanding arrived at,
that while Arianism on the one hand and Sabellianism on the other were
to be condemned, it was advisable to be content with the language of
the Nicene formula, which employed neither the phrase μία
ὑπόστασις nor the phrase τρεῖς
ὑποστάσεις S.
Athanasius, Tom. ad Antioch, 5.. This resolution, prudent as
it may have been for the purpose of bringing together those who were in
real agreement, and of securing that the reconciled parties should, at
a critical moment, present an unbroken front in the face of their
common and still dangerous enemy, could hardly be long maintained. The
expression τρεῖς
ὑποστάσεις
was one to which many of the orthodox, including those
who had formerly belonged to the Semi-Arian section, had become
accustomed: the Alexandrine synod, under the guidance of S. Athanasius,
had acknowledged the phrase, as used by them, to be an orthodox one,
and S. Basil, in his efforts to conciliate the Semi-Arian party, with
which he had himself been closely connected through his namesake of
Ancyra and through Eustathius of Sebastia, saw fit definitely to adopt
it. While S. Athanasius, on the one hand, using the older terminology,
says that ὑπόστασις is equivalent to οὐσία, and has
no other meaning Ad Afr.
Episc. §4. S. Athanasius, however, does not shrink from the
phrase τρεῖς
ὑποστάσεις
in contradistinction to the μῖα
οὐσία: see the
treatise, In illud, ‘Omnia mihi tradita sunt.’
§6., S. Basil, on the other hand, goes so
far as to say that the terms οὐσία and ὑπόστασις, even in the Nicene anathema, are not to be understood as
equivalent S. Bas.
Ep. 125 (being the confession of faith drawn up by S. Basil for the
subscription of Eustathius).. The adoption of the new phrase, even
after the explanations given at Alexandria, was found to require, in
order to avoid misconstruction, a more precise definition of its
meaning, and a formal defence of its orthodoxy. And herein consisted
one principal service rendered by S. Basil and S. Gregory; while with
more precise definition of the term ὑπόστασις there emerged, it may be, a more precise view of the
relations of the Persons, and with the defence of the new phrase as
expressive of the Trinity of Persons a more precise view of what is
implied in the Unity of the Godhead.