274 INSTITUTES OF THE [bOOK II
fection wliich nothing can alter. "^ hosoever is born of God,"
he says, " cannot sin ; for his seed remaineth in him." (d) Fot
we see that the neutral, inefficacious impulse imagined by the
sophists, which every one would be at liberty to obey or resist,
is evidently excluded, where it is asserted that God gives a
constancy that is effectual to perseverance.
XI. Concerning perseverance there would have been no
doubt that it ought to be esteemed the gratuitous gift of God,
had it not been for the prevalence of a pestilent error, that it is
dispensed according to the merit of men, in proportion to the
gratitude which each person has discovered for the grace be-
stowed on him. But as that opinion arose from the supposition
that it was at our own option to reject or accept the offered
grace of God, this notion being exploded, the other falls of
course. Though here is a double error ; for beside teaching
that our gratitude for the grace first bestowed on us, and our
legitimate use of that grace, are remunerated by subsequent
blessings, they add also, that now grace does not operate alone
in us, but only cooperates with us. On the first point, we
must admit that the Lord, while he daily enriches and loads
his servants with new communications of his grace, perceiving
the work which he has begun in them grateful and accept-
able, discovers something in them which he blesses with still
greater degrees of grace. And this is implied in the following
declarations: "Unto every one that hath, shall be given."
And, " Well done, good and faithful servant ; thou hast been
faithful over a few things, I will make thee ruler over many
things." (e) But here two errors must be avoided ; the legiti-
mate use of the grace first bestowed must not be said to be re-
warded with subsequent degrees of grace, as though man, by
his own industry, rendered the grace of God efficacious ; nor
must it be accounted a remuneration in such a sense as to cease
to be esteemed the free favour of God. I grant, then, that this
Divine benediction is to be expected by the faithful, that the
better they have used the former measures of grace, they shall
afterwards be enriched with proportionably greater degrees of
it. But I assert that this use also is from the Lord, and that
this remuneration proceeds from his gratuitous benevolence.
They are equally awkward and unhappy in their use of the
trite distinction of operating and cooperating grace. Augustine
has used it indeed, but softens it by a suitable definilion ; that
God in cooperating completes what in operatmg he begins, and
that it is the same grace, but derives its name from the c ifferent
mode of its efficiency. Whence it follows, that he makes no
partition of the work between God and us, as though there
irf) 1 John iii. 9 (e) Matt. xxv. 23, 29. Luke xix. 17,26
)