him), and how, by the will of Him Who has so ordained, ever running his own particular
course, he accomplishes his appointed orbit and progress, opening out the four seasons of
the year in succession; we, as I say, when we contemplate these phenomena by the aid of
sight, are in no doubt of their existence, though we are as far from comprehending their
essential nature as if sight had not given us any glimpse whatever of what we have seen; and
even so, with regard to the Creator of the world, we know that He exists, but of His essential
nature we cannot deny that we are ignorant. But, boasting as they do that they know these
things, let them first tell us about the things of inferior nature; what they think of the body
of the heavens, of the machinery which conveys the stars in their eternal courses, or of the
sphere in which they move; for, however far speculation may proceed, when it comes to the
uncertain and incomprehensible it must stop. For though any one say that another body,
like in fashion (to that body of the heavens), fitting to its circular shape, checks its velocity,
so that, ever turning in its course, it revolves conformably to that other upon itself, being
retained by the force that embraces it from flying off at a tangent, yet how can he assert that
these bodies will remain unspent by their constant friction with each other? And how, again,
258
is motion produced in the case of two coeval bodies mutually conformed, when the one re-
mains motionless (for the inner body, one would have thought, being held as in a vice by
the motionlessness of that which embraces it, will be quite unable to act); and what is it that
maintains the embracing body in its fixedness, so that it remains unshaken and unaffected
by the motion of that which fits into it? And if in restless curiosity of thought we should
conceive of some position for it that should keep it stationary, we must go on in logical
consistency to search for the base of that base, and of the next, and of the next, and so on,
and so the inquiry, proceeding from like to like, will go on to infinity, and end in helpless
perplexity, still, even when some body has been put for the farthest foundation of the system
of the universe, reaching after what is beyond, so that there is no stopping in our inquiry
after the limit of the embracing circles. But not so, say others: but (according to the vain
theory of those who have speculated on these matters) there is an empty space spread over
the back of the heavens, working in which vacuum the motion of the universe revolves upon
itself, meeting with no resistance from any solid body capable of retarding it by opposition
and of checking its course of revolution. What, then, is that vacuum, which they say is neither
a body nor an idea? How far does it extend, and what succeeds it, and what relation exists
between the firm, resisting body, and that void and unsubstantial one? What is there to
unite things so contrary by nature? and how can the harmony of the universe consist out
of elements so incongruous; and what can any one say of Heaven itself? That it is a mixture
of the elements which it contains, or one of them, or something else beside them? What,
again, of the stars themselves? whence comes their radiance? what is it and how is it com-
posed? and what is the reason of their difference in beauty and magnitude? and the seven
inner orbs revolving in an opposite direction to the motion of the universe, what are they,
490
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.