Arianism is practical paganism, for to make the
Son a creature, and at the same time to offer Him worship, is to
reintroduce polytheism. Sabellianism is practical
Judaism,—a denial of the Son. cf. ccx.
p. 249.
John i. 1, xiv. 9, 7, xvi. 28, and viii.
16 are quoted against
both extremes. There may be a note of time in the admitted
impatience of the auditory at hearing of every other subject than
the Holy Spirit. The preacher is constrained to speak upon
this topic, and he speaks with the combined caution and
completeness which characterize the De Spiritu
Sancto. “Your ears,” he says, “are
all eager to hear something concerning the Holy Ghost. My
wish would be, as I have received in all simplicity, as I
have assented with
guileless agreement, so to deliver the doctrine to you my
hearers. I would if I could avoid being constantly
questioned on the same point. I would have my disciples
convinced of one consent. But you stand round me rather as
judges than as learners. Your desire is rather to test and
try me than to acquire anything for yourselves. I must
therefore, as it were, make my defence before the court, again
and again giving answer, and again and again saying what I have
received. And you I exhort not to be specially anxious to
hear from me what is pleasing to yourselves, but rather what is
pleasing to the Lord, what is in harmony with the Scriptures,
what is not in opposition to the Fathers. What, then, I
asserted concerning the Son, that we ought to acknowledge His
proper Person, this I have also to say concerning the Holy
Spirit. The Spirit is not identical with the Father,
because of its being written ‘God is a
Spirit.’ John iv. 24. Nor on
the other hand is there one Person of Son and of Spirit, because
it is said, ‘If any man have not the spirit of Christ he is
none of his.…Christ is in you.’ Rom. viii. 9 and
10. From this passage some persons
have been deceived into the opinion that the Spirit and Christ
are identical. But what do we assert? That in this
passage is declared the intimate relation of nature and not a
confusion of persons. For there exists the Father having
His existence perfect and independent, root and fountain of the
Son and of the Holy Ghost. There exists also the Son living
in full Godhead, Word and begotten offspring of the Father,
independent. Full too is the Spirit, not part of another,
but contemplated whole and perfect in Himself. The Son is
inseparably conjoined with the Father and the Spirit with the
Son. For there is nothing to divide nor to cut asunder the
eternal conjunction. No age intervenes, nor yet can our
soul entertain a thought of separation as though the
Only-begotten were not ever with the Father, or the Holy Ghost
not co-existent with the Son. Whenever then we conjoin the
Trinity, be careful not to imagine the Three as parts of one
undivided thing, but receive the idea of the undivided and common
essence of three perfect incorporeal [existences]. Wherever
is the presence of the Holy Spirit, there is the indwelling of
Christ: wherever Christ is, there the Father is
present. ‘Know ye not that your body is the temple of
the Holy Ghost which is in you ?’” 1 Cor. vi. 19.