Book IV.
Faustus’s reasons for rejecting the Old Testament, and Augustin’s animadversions
thereon.
1. Faustussaid: Do I believe the Old Testament? If it bequeaths anything to me, I believe
it; if not, I reject it. It would be an excess of forwardness to take the documents of others
which pronounce me disinherited. Remember that the promise of Canaan in the Old
Testament is made to Jews, that is, to the circumcised, who offer sacrifice, and abstain from
swine’s flesh, and from the other animals which Moses pronounces unclean, and observe
Sabbaths, and the feast of unleavened bread, and other things of the same kind which the
author of the Testament enjoined. Christians have not adopted these observances, and no
one keeps them; so that if we will not take the inheritance, we should surrender the docu-
ments. This is my first reason for rejecting the Old Testament, unless you teach me better.
My second reason is, that this inheritance is such a poor fleshly thing, without any spiritual
blessings, that after the New Testament, and its glorious promise of the kingdom of heaven
and eternal life, I think it not worth the taking.
2. Augustin replied: No one doubts that promises of temporal things are contained in
the Old Testament, for which reason it is called the Old Testament; or that the kingdom of
heaven and the promise of eternal life belong to the New Testament. But that in these
temporal things were figures of future things which should be fulfilled in us upon whom
the ends of the ages are come, is not my fancy, but the judgment of the apostle, when he
says of such things, "These things were our examples;" and again, "These things happened
to them for an example, and they are written for us on whom the ends of the ages are
come."314 We receive the Old Testament, therefore, not in order to obtain the fulfillment
of these promises, but to see in them predictions of the New Testament; for the Old bears
witness to the New. Whence the Lord, after He rose from the dead, and allowed His disciples
not only to see but to handle Him, still, lest they should doubt their mortal and fleshly senses,
gave them further confirmation from the testimony of the ancient books, saying, "It was
necessary that all things should be fulfilled which were written in the law of Moses, and in
the Prophets and Psalms, concerning me."315 Our hope, therefore, rests not on the promise
162
of temporal things. Nor do we believe that the holy and spiritual men of these times—the
patriarchs and prophets—were taken up with earthly things. For they understood, by the
revelation of the Spirit of God, what was suitable for that time, and how God appointed all
these sayings and actions as types and predictions of the future. Their great desire was for
the New Testament; but they had a personal duty to perform in those predictions, by which
the new things of the future were foretold. So the life as well as the tongue of these men was
314 1 Cor. x. 6, 11.
315 Luke xxiv. 44.
Faustus’s reasons for rejecting the Old Testament, and Augustin’s animadversions thereon.
274
Faustus’s reasons for rejecting the Old Testament, and Augustin’s animadversions…