Origen was not the first to interpret the Scriptures
allegorically. The method began among the Alexandrian Jews some time
before the Christian era, the effort being made to reconcile the Mosaic
revelation with Greek philosophy, and to find in the former the
teachings of the latter. This effort appears in many of the apocryphal
books, but the great exponent of the method was the Alexandrian Philo.
It was natural that the early Christians, especially in Alexandria,
should be influenced by this already existing method of interpretation,
which enabled them to make of the Old Testament a Christian book, and
to find in it all the teachings of the Gospel. Undoubtedly the Old
Testament owes partly to this principle of interpretation its adoption
by the Christian Church. Had it been looked upon as the Jewish
Scriptures only, containing Jewish national history, and in large part
Jewish national prophecy, it could never have retained its hold upon
the early Church, which was so bitterly hostile to all that savored of
Judaism. The early Gentile Christians were taught from the beginning by
Jewish Christians who could not do otherwise than look upon their
national Scriptures as divine, that those Scriptures contained
prophecies of Jesus Christ, and hence those Gentile Christians accepted
them as divine. But it must be remembered that they could of course
have no meaning to these Gentile Christians except as they did prophesy
of Christian things or contain Christian teaching. They could not be
content to find Christian prophecy in one part and only Jewish history
or Jewish prophecy in another part. It must all be Christian if
it was to have any meaning to them. In this emergency the allegorical
method of interpretation, already practiced upon the Old Testament by
the Alexandrian Jews, came to their assistance and was eagerly adopted.
The so-called epistle of Barnabus is an early and most significant
instance of its use. With Clement of Alexandria the matter first took
scientific shape. He taught that two senses are everywhere to be
assumed; that the verbal sense is only for babes in the faith, and that
the allegorical sense alone leads to true spiritual knowledge. With
Origen allegorical interpretation reached its height. He taught a
threefold sense of Scripture, corresponding to body, soul, and spirit.
Many voices were raised against his interpretation, but they were
directed against his particular explanations of the meaning of
passages, seldom against his method. In the early centuries Alexandria
remained the chief center of this kind of exegesis, while Antioch
became in the fifth century the seat of a school of exegetes who
emphasized rather the grammatical and historical interpretation of
Scripture over against the extremes of the Alexandrian teachers. And
yet even they were not entirely free from the vicious methods of the
age, and, moreover, errors of various kinds crept in to lessen their
influence, and the allegorical method finally prevailed almost
universally; and it has not even yet fully lost its hold. This method
of Scripture interpretation has, as Porphyry says, its analogy in the
methods of the Greek philosophers during the centuries immediately
preceding the Christian era. It became early the custom for
philosophers, scandalized by the licentious stories of their gods, to
interpret the current myths allegorically and refer them to the
processes of nature. Homer and others of the ancient poets were thus
made by these later philosophers to teach philosophies of nature of
which they had never dreamed. With the Neo-Platonists this method
reached its highest perfection, and while the Christian teachers were
allegorizing the Old Testament Scriptures, these philosophers were
transforming the popular myths into records of the profoundest physical
and spiritual processes. Porphyry saw that the method of pagans and
Christians was the same in this respect, and he may be correct in
assigning some influence to these writings in the shaping of
Origen’s thinking, but the latter was an allegorist before he
studied the philosophers to whom Porphyry refers (cf. chap. 2, §9,
above), and would have been an allegorist had he never studied them.
Allegory was in that age in the atmosphere of the Church as well as of
the philosophical school.