16. But you will, perhaps, say that the gods have indeed other forms, and that you have
given the appearance of men to them merely by way of honour, and for form’s sake3969
which is much more insulting than to have fallen into any error through ignorance. For if
you confessed that you had ascribed to the divine forms that which you had supposed and
believed, your error, originating in prejudice, would not be so blameable. But now, when
you believe one thing and fashion another, you both dishonour those to whom you ascribe
that which you confess does not belong to them, and show your impiety in adoring that
which you fashion, not that which you think really is, and which is in very truth. If asses,
dogs, pigs,3970 had any human wisdom and skill in contrivance, and wished to do us honour
also by some kind of worship, and to show respect by dedicating statues to us, with what
rage would they inflame us, what a tempest of passion would they excite, if they determined
that our images should bear and assume the fashion of their own bodies? How would they,
I repeat, fill us with rage, and rouse our passions, if the founder of Rome, Romulus, were to
be set up with an ass’s face, the revered Pompilius with that of a dog, if under the image of
a pig were written Cato’s or Marcus Cicero’s name? So, then, do you think that your stupidity
is not laughed at by your deities, if they laugh at all? or, since you believe that they may be
enraged, do you think that they are not roused, maddened to fury, and that they do not wish
to be revenged for so great wrongs and insults, and to hurl on you the punishments usually
dictated by chagrin, and devised by bitter hatred? How much better it had been to give to
them the forms of elephants, panthers, or tigers, bulls, and horses! For what is there beautiful
in man,—what, I pray you, worthy of admiration, or comely,—unless that which, some
poet3971 has maintained, he possesses in common with the ape?
3969 The ms. and first four edd. read dotis causa—“for the sake of a dowry:” corrected as above, dicis causa
in the later edd.
3970 This argument seems to have been suggested by the saying of Xenophanes, that the ox or lion, if possessed
of man’s power, would have represented, after the fashion of their own bodies, the gods they would worship.
[“The fair humanities of old religion.”—Coleridge (Schiller).]
3971 Ennius (Cic., de Nat. Deor., i. 35): Simia quam similis, turpissima bestia, nobis.
Chapter XVI.
1103
Chapter XVI.