And if the word Action is arbitrarily used by some men otherwise, to suit some scheme
of metaphysics or morality, no argument can reasonably be founded on such a use of this
term, to prove any thing but their own pleasure. For divines and philosophers strenuously
to urge such arguments, as though they were sufficient to support and demonstrate a whole
scheme of moral philosophy and divinity, is certainly to erect a mighty edifice on the sand,
or rather on a shadow. And though it may now perhaps, through custom, have become
natural for then to use the word in this sense, (if that may be called a sense or meaning,
which is inconsistent with itself,) yet this does not prove, that it is agreeable to the natural
notions men have of things, or that there can be any thing in the creation that should answer
such a meaning. And though they appeal to experience, yet the truth is, that men are so far
from experiencing any such thing, that it is impossible for them to have any conception of
it.
If it should be objected, that Action and Passion are doubtless words of a contrary signi-
fication; but to suppose that the agent, in its Action, is under the power and influence of
something intrinsic, is to confound Action and passion, and make them the same thing:
I answer, that Action and Passion are doubtless, as they are sometimes used, words of
opposite signification; but not as signifying opposite existences, but only opposite relations.
The words cause and effect are terms of opposite signification; but, nevertheless, if I assert,
that the same thing may, at the same time, in different respects and relations, be both cause
and effect, this will not prove that I confound the terms. The soul may be both active and
passive in the same thing in different respects; active with relation to one thing, and passive
with relation to another. 139 The word Passion, when set in opposition to Action, or rather
activeness, is merely a relative: it signifies no effect or cause, nor any proper existence; but
is the same with Passiveness, or a being passive, or a being acted upon by something. Which
is a mere relation of a thing to some power or force exerted by some cause, producing some
effect in it, or upon it. And Action, when set properly in opposition to Passion, or Passiveness,
is no real existence; it is not the same with an Action, but is a mere relation: it is the activeness
of something on another thing, being the opposite relation to the other, viz. a relation of
power, or force, exerted by some cause, towards another thing, which is the subject of the
effect of that power. Indeed, the word Action is frequently used to signify something not
139 This distinction is of considerable moment. The soul is passive, for instance, in reference to that necessity
of dependence which is inseparable from a created nature; and when the subject of providential energy in nat-
ural acts; and also when the subject of that divine influence which purifies and enables the mind, and whereby
holy effects are secured; and in all these respects it is passive at the very time that it is active in its choice or
preference. In other words, the mind is necessitated in some respects; as, to exist, to think, to will, to suffer, or
to enjoy; at the same instant that it is free in other respects, as, from contingence, (understanding thereby an
event without any cause,) and from compulsions, or physical necessity in its acts as moral.—W.
687
SECTION II. The Falseness and Inconsistence of that metaphysical notion…