Meanwhile in Alexandria disorders had continued.
The ‘duke’ appears to have been either unable for a time,
or to have thought it needless, to take possession of the churches; but
we hear of a violent dispersion of worshippers from the neighbourhood
of the cemetery on Easter Day (p. 249, cf. the Virgins after
Syrianus but before Heraclius, p. 288); while throughout Egypt
subscription to an Arianising formula was being enforced on the bishops
under pain of expulsion. After Easter, a change of governor took place,
Maximus of Nicæa (pp. 301 sqq., 247) being succeeded by
Cataphronius, who reached Alexandria on the 10th of June (Hist.
Aceph. iv.). He was accompanied by a Count Heraclius, who brought a
letter from Constantius threatening the heathen with severe measures
(pp. 288, 290), unless active hostilities against the Athanasian party
were begun (this letter was not the one given p. 249; Ath. rightly
remarks ‘it reflected great discredit upon the writer’).
Heraclius announced that by Imperial order the Churches were to be
given up to the Arians, and compelled all the magistrates, including
the functionaries of heathen temples, to sign an undertaking to execute
the Imperial incitements to persecution, and to agree to receive as
Bishop the Emperor’s nominee. These incredible precautions shew
the general esteem for Athanasius even outside the Church, and the
misgivings felt at Court as to the reception of the new bishop. The
Gentiles reluctantly agreed, and the next acts of violence were carried
out with their aid, ‘or rather with that of the more abandoned
among them’ (p. 291). On the fourth day from the arrival of
Cataphronius, that is in the early hours of Thursday, June 13, after a
service (which had began overnight, pp. 290, 256 fin., Hist.
Aceph. v.), just as all the congregation except a few women had
left, the church of Theonas was stormed and violences perpetrated which
left far behind anything that Syrianus had done. Women were murdered,
the church wrecked and polluted with the very worst orgies of
heathenism, houses and even tombs were ransacked throughout the city
and suburbs on pretence of ‘seeking for Athanasius.’
Sebastian the Manichee, who about this time succeeded to the military
command of Syrianus, appears to have carried on these outrages with the
utmost zest (yet see Hist. Ar. 60). Many more bishops were
driven into exile (compare the twenty-six of p. 297 with the
‘sixteen’ p. 248, but some may belong to a still later
period, see p. 257), and the Arian bishops and clergy installed,
including the bitterly vindictive Secundus in Libya (p. 257). The
formal transfer of churches at Alexandria took place on Saturday, June
15 (infr., p. 290, note 9): the anniversary of Eutychius (p.
292) was kept at Alexandria on July 11, (Martyrol. Vetust. Ed.
1668). After a further delay of ‘eight months and eleven
days’ George, the new bishop, made his appearance (Feb. 24, 357 This
date, coming from the common source of the Historia Acephala and
Festal Index (i.e. from the accredited Alexandrian chronology of
the period), must be accepted unless there is cogent proof of its
incorrectness. No such proof is offered: we have no positive
statement to the contrary, but only (1) the fact that the intrusion
of George is related, Apol. Fug. 6, immediately after an attack
on the great church, possibly the coup de main of Syrianus, but
more probably that of p. 290, note 9, without any hint of a long
interval. This is true, and if there were no evidence the other
way might justify a guess that George came in Lent, 356; but
no one would claim that the passage is conclusive by itself; (2) the
‘improbability’ of George delaying his arrival so long.
Improbability is a relative term; we know too little of George’s
consecration or movements to justify its use in the present connection.
All the evidence goes to shew that the court party were far from
sanguine as to the nature of his reception, and that their misgivings
were well-founded. The above considerations look very small when we
compare them with the mass of positive evidence the other way. (1.) The
civil Governor had changed: Maximus held the post on Feb. 8, 356
(Hist. Ar. 81, &c.), Cataphronius when the churches were
transferred to the party of George, see below, 6. (2.) The military
Commander had changed: Syrianus was replaced by Sebastian, who appears
just after the transfer of churches, Hist. Ar. 55–60 (Dr.
Bright in D.C.B. i. 194, note, seems to admit that Sebastian
belongs to a later date than the Lent of 356). (3.) The Wednesday (and
Thursday) of Hist. Ar. 55 were not ‘in Lent.’
They suit the data of Hist. Aceph. perfectly well. (4.) Had
George arrived before Easter 356, Athan. would have heard of it
‘in the Desert,’ Apol. Const. 27; but he has only
heard of his nomination ὠνομάσθη 28, probably from the letters given in §§30, 31). (5.)
The Letter to the Egyptian bishops was written from Libya or Cyrenaica,
when the coercion of the episcopate had begun: it postulates some time
since his expulsion, but George was then (§7) only in
contemplation. (6.) There is no evidence that the coup de main
of Syrianus was other than unpopular in the city. This was reported to
Const., who after the (Easter) outrages on the Virgins (Ap.
Const. 27; Hist. Ar. 48), and after the expulsion of
the sixteen bishops (Hist. Ar. 54, this was probably about
Easter, Ap. Const. 27) sent Heraclius (with the
‘discreditable’ letter), in whose company (Hist.
Ar. 55) the new Prefect Cataphronius first appears. This let
loose the refuse of the heathen population as described, ib.
55–60. (7.) Here the precise statement of the Hist. Aceph.
fits in exactly. The Presbyters and people of Ath. remained in
possession of the Churches until the arrival of the new Prefect,
with Count Heraclius, on June 10. (8.) Heraclius is expressly
called the precursor of George (p. 288) and is evidently sent to
disarm the reported hostility of the (even heathen) public to the
appointment. It may be added that if we are to take
‘probabilities’ into account, it is easier to imagine a
reason for a court nominee like George having been slow to take up a
dangerous post, than for the Alexandrian chronologists of the day
having invented a year’s interval when none had existed.
Montfaucon had already noticed that ‘a good deal must have
happened’ between the irruption of Syrianus and the entry of
George. The data of Athanasius are for the first time clearly explained
by the light thrown on them by the chroniclers. I should also have
urged the fact that the commemoration of George’s Pentecost
Martyrs on May 21 in the Roman Martyrology suits 357 and
not 356, had I succeeded in tracing the history of the entry, which
has, however, so far eluded my efforts., third Friday in Lent). His previous career We are
quite in the dark as to when, and by whom, George was consecrated
bishop. The statement of Sozomen iv. 8, that he was ordained by a
council of thirty bishops at Antioch, including Theodore of Heraclea,
who had died before the exile of Liberius in 355 (Thdt. H. E.
ii. 16, p. 93. 13), is involved in too hopeless a tangle of
anachronisms to be of any value for our enquiry. But that George was
ordained in Antioch is in itself likely enough, and if so, his
ordination would probably follow close upon the expulsion of
Athanasius. But the repeated assurances of Ath. that George came
from court would imply that after his ordination George went to
Italy. That at once puts his arrival in Alxa. in Lent 356 out of the
question. and character The
statements of Ath. as to George are made at secondhand, and must be
taken cum grano. He is ‘notoriously wealthy,’ yet
‘hired’ by the Arians. (Cf. p. 249; but apparently he
combined wealth and avarice.) That he was ‘a heathen’ is
certainly untrue. His ‘ignorance’ is equally so: we know
that he was a well-read man and possessed a remarkably good library
(D.C.B. ii. 638). That he had ‘the temper of a hangman’ (p.
227) is in keeping with all that we know of him, and as to his general
character, the statements of Athanasius and other churchmen are not
stronger than Amm. Marcell. XXII. xi. 4 (cf. Gibbon, iii. 171
sqq., ed. Smith, but correct his jeu d’esprit on
‘S. George and the Dragon’ by Bright, in D.C.B. ubi
supra; yet see Stanley, Eastern Church, Lect. vii.
III..). were strange
qualifications for the second bishopric in Christendom. He had been a
pork-contractor at Constantinople, and according to his many enemies a
fraudulent one; he had amassed considerable wealth, and was a zealous
Arian. His violent temper perhaps recommended him as a man likely to
crush the opposition that was expected. The history of his episcopate
may be briefly disposed of here. He entered upon his See in Lent, 357,
with an armed force. At Easter he renewed the violent persecution of
bishops, clergy, virgins, and lay people. In the week after Pentecost he let loose the cruel
commandant Sebastian against a number of persons who were worshipping
at the cemetery instead of communicating with himself; many were
killed, and many more banished. The expulsion of bishops (‘over
thirty,’ p. 257, cf. other reff. above) was continued (the
various data of Ath. are not easy to reconcile, the first 16 of p. 257
may be the ‘sixteen’ of p. 248, before Easter, 356: we miss
the name of Serapion in all the lists!) Theodore, Bishop of Oxyrynchus,
the largest town of middle Egypt, upon submitting to George, was
compelled by him to submit to reordination. The people refused to have
anything more to do with him, and did without a bishop for a long time,
until they obtained a pastor in one Heraclides, who is said to have
become a ‘Luciferian.’ (Cf. Lib. Prec., and Le Quien
ii. p. 578.) George carried on his tyranny eighteen months, till Aug.
29, 358. His fierce insults against Pagan worship were accompanied by
the meanest and most oppressive rapacity. At last the populace,
exasperated by his ‘adder’s bites’ (Ammian.),
attacked him, and he was rescued with difficulty. On Oct. 2 he left the
town, and the party of Athanasius expelled his followers from the
churches on Oct. 11, but on Dec. 24, Sebastian came in from the country
and restored the churches to the people of George. On June 23, 359,
‘the notary Paul’ (‘in complicandis calumniarum
nexibus artifex dirus, unde ei Catenæ inditum est
cognomentum,’ Ammian. Marc. XIV. v., XV. iii.), the Jeffreys of
the day, held a commission of blood, and ‘vindictively punished
many p. 497.
George was at Sirmium in the Spring of 359 (Soz. (v. 16). Paul
Catena came to Alxa. from a similar commission at Scythopolis.
He was apparently aided in both places by Modestus the Comes Orientis.
From Liban. Ep. 205, we gather, to the credit of George, that he
was the intermediary of requests for mitigation on some of the
sentences. He was at this time at Antioch, from whence also ‘Ex
Comitatu Principis,’ Amm. XXII. xi., he returned to Alxa. in 361,
evidently before he had heard of the Emperor’s death. (Sievers,
pp. 138 sq.).’ George was at this time busy with the
councils of Seleucia and Constantinople (he was not actually present at
the latter, Thdt. H. E. ii. 28), and was in no hurry to return.
At last, just after the death of Constantius, he ventured back, Nov.
26, 361, but on the proclamation of Julian on Nov. 30 was seized by the
populace and thrown into chains; on Dec. 24, ‘impatient of the
tedious forms of judicial proceedings,’ the people dragged him
from prison and lynched him with the utmost ignominy.