A single doctrine or group of
doctrines, however, may be unduly pressed in accounting for the
influence of Origen upon a kindred spirit like Gregory. Doubtless
fragments of Origen’s teaching, mere details very often, were
seized upon and appropriated by others; they were erected into dogmas
and made to do duty for the whole living fabric; and even those details
were sometimes misunderstood. ‘ Bunsen.What he had said
with a mind full of thought, others took in the very letter.’
Hence arose the evil of ‘Origenism,’ so prevalent in the
century in which Gregory lived. Different ways of following him were
found, bad and good. Even the Arians could find in his language now and
then something they could claim as their own. But as Rupp well says,
‘Origen is not great by virtue of those particular doctrines,
which are usually exhibited to the world as heretical by weak heads who
think to take the measure of everything with the mere formulæ of
orthodoxy. He is great by virtue of one single thought, i.e. that of
bringing philosophy into union with religion, and thereby creating a
theology. With Clement of Alexandria this thought was a mere instinct:
Origen gave it consciousness: and so Christendom began to have a
science of its own.’ It was this single purpose, visible in all
Origen wrote, that impressed itself so deeply upon Gregory. He, too,
would vindicate the Scriptures as a philosophy. Texts, thanks to the
labours of Origen as well as to the councils of the Church, had now
acquired a fixed meaning and an importance that all could acknowledge.
The new spiritual philosophy lay within them; he would make them speak
its language. Allegory was with him, just as with Origen, necessary, in
order to find the Spirit which inspires them. The letter must not
impose itself upon us and stand for more than it is worth; just as the
practical experience of evil in the world must not blind us to the fact
that it is
only a passing dispensation. If only the animus and intention is
regarded, we may say that all that Gregory wrote was
Origenistic.