The
interpretation of this sentence is very difficult. The Greek
runs ἑξῆς ταύτῃ
καὶ ἑτέρα τις
ἐπιστολὴ
τοῖς ἐν
῾Ρώμῃ τοῦ
Διονυσίου
φέρεται
διακονικὴ
διὰ
῾Ιππολύτου. The φέρεται, according to the usage of Eusebius, must mean “is
extant,” and some participle (e.g. “written” or
“sent”) must then be supplied before διὰ
῾Ιππολύτου. Whether Eusebius means that the letter was written by
Hippolytus or was carried by him to Rome cannot be determined. The
latter is more probable and is the commonly accepted interpretation.
That Eusebius should name a messenger in this particular case and in no
other seems peculiar, unless it be supposed that Hippolytus was so
prominent a character as to merit especial mention. Who he was we do
not know, for chronology will not permit us (as was formerly done by
some scholars) to identify him with the great writer of the Roman
church (see above, chaps. 20 and 22), and no other Hippolytus of
prominence is known to us. In view of Eusebius’ mention of the
name at this point, I am inclined, however, to think that he, knowing
so little about the Roman Hippolytus, fancied that this was the same
man. If he did, he had good reason to mention him. The word
“diaconal” (διακονικὴ) in this sentence has caused much dispute. Rufinus
translates epistola de ministeriis; Valesius, epistola de
officio diaconi, that is, “concerning the office (or duties)
of the diaconate,” and it seems out of the question to understand
the word in any other way. Why Dionysius should address an epistle on
this subject to the Roman church it is impossible to say. Magistris
supposed that it was called “diaconal” because it was to be
read in church by a deacon, and concluded that it was an exhortation to
peace, since it was customary for the deacons to offer the εἰρηνικ€, or prayers for peace. The supposition is attractive, for
it is natural to think that this epistle, like the others, discussed
the Novatian schism and contained an exhortation to peace. But we
cannot without further evidence adopt Magistris’ explanation, nor
indeed can we assume that a diaconal epistle as such (whether the word
is a technical one or not, and though it might seem such we have no
other trace of such a use of it) had to do with the unity or peace of
the Church. We must, in fact, leave the matter quite undetermined.
Compare Dittrich, ibid. p. 55.